Locunity — where decisions happen.
Menlo Park Council Punts Santa Cruz Plaza Decision to 2027

Menlo Park Council Punts Santa Cruz Plaza Decision to 2027

City Council • Menlo ParkNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

The fight over a single block of Santa Cruz Avenue will land on the incoming City Council's desk. Students, the school superintendent and a Complete Streets commissioner pushed back on a plan to reopen the plaza to cars, and the council chose to defer the item without taking a vote. The same night, the council honored retiring Police Chief Dave Norris and advanced a state-mandated ban on watering decorative lawns with drinking water.


  • Santa Cruz plaza repeal deferred to early 2027 after students, the school district and cyclists opposed reopening the lane
  • Retiring Police Chief Dave Norris honored by state, county, school and neighborhood leaders after five years with the city
  • AB 1572 turf-irrigation ordinance introduced unanimously ahead of the state's Jan. 1, 2027 deadline
  • All three downtown parking lot developers remain eligible under the Surplus Land Act exemption path

Santa Cruz Plaza Fight Moves to the Next Council

Why it matters: The block between Curtis and Doyle streets holds downtown's only bike lane and a teen gathering spot. Business concerns drove the push to reopen it to cars. Staff said striping could not start until about spring 2027 anyway, so deferring costs the city little.

Where things stand: The eastbound lane of Santa Cruz Avenue between Curtis and Doyle is closed to cars, and the refreshed plaza opened in June. Following council direction on Oct. 13, staff brought a resolution to repeal Resolution 6860. The repeal would reopen the travel lane, remove the bike lane and shrink the plaza. Economic Development Manager Collette Hanna presented the item. Staff said a new public works maintenance hire would handle cleanup.

“We would look for a decision closer in early 2027, potentially,” a city staff member said about the timing for striping.

The other side: Every public speaker opposed the repeal. “The staff report on this issue, which I read three times, is not serious,” said public commenter Peter Hottie. He argued the report ignored litter and safety concerns.

Superintendent Kristen Gracia of the Menlo Park City School District cited the middle-schooler gathering space and the loss of the bike lane. “And so my answer is partnership, not closure,” she said.

Complete Streets Commissioner Matthew Raskoff, speaking as a resident, said the item bypassed his commission and was not a pilot. “It repeals Resolution 6860 outright with no end date, no return to council, and no measure of success,” he said. Public commenter Ross Silberstein said that if the only alternative is bringing cars back, “That is rather disappointing and frankly lazy.” Anaya Batnagar, an 8th grade leadership member at Hilvey Middle School, said “removing it would do more harm than good, in my opinion.”

On the dais: Councilmember Drew Combs pointed to the business community's consistent concerns. “Certainly, what is being proposed here shrinks the plaza. I'll give you that, but it does not make the plaza go away,” he said. He added: “It seems as though, as a community, we are talking past each other.” Combs also clarified that an earlier remark about punting referred to making the plaza permanent.

Vice Mayor Jennifer Wise said she was open to continuing the item until spring or until construction is imminent. Councilmember Jeff Schmidt opposed repealing the closure now only to add it back later, and urged the council to “let the future council grapple with it.” He offered to join any listening sessions that bring students and business owners together.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No motion was made and no vote was taken. Mayor Betsy Nash proposed scheduling the item early next year, with outreach to businesses and the school district and attention to design safety. The clerk said “we would not need any action tonight,” and staff said they had the direction they needed. For now, students and cyclists keep the plaza and the bike lane. Downtown businesses wait for another hearing.

What's next: Staff will return early in 2027, after outreach.


Region Honors Chief Norris

Why it matters: Norris's retirement opens a leadership transition at a department that speakers said regained staffing and community trust under him. A new chief is coming.

Where things stand: Miles Goodman, District Representative for State Senator Josh Becker, read a joint resolution from Becker and Assemblymember Mark Berman. San Mateo County Supervisor Ray Mueller noted a county board resolution and credited Norris with bringing stability. Assistant Sheriff Ryan Monahan praised his collaboration across county agencies.

“Chief Norris stands out as among the best and the brightest in that category,” said District Attorney Steve Wagstaff, referring to setting a standard of integrity.

Tributes also came from Superintendent Gracia, who thanked Norris for prioritizing school safety and supporting school resource officers. Retired executive Dan Mulholland said Norris left the department in a better state. Belhaven Neighborhood Association Co-chair Karen Williams and her co-chair presented a small gift.

The other side: Belhaven resident Pam Jones credited Norris's authenticity with restoring trust. She also noted that he held firm against some community positions, including on flock cameras, which are automated license plate readers.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Mayor Nash read the city proclamation. It recognized Norris's improvements in technology, officer wellness and community-centered policing. No vote was evidenced. Norris recalled that when he arrived, “our staff had recently been cut by 20%.” He credited the department's employees: “Anything that I've accomplished here has been a product of shared ownership.”


Turf Ban Ordinance Clears First Reading

The basics: Assembly Bill 1572 bans the use of potable water, meaning drinking water, on nonfunctional turf. That is decorative grass that no one uses for recreation or gatherings.

Why it matters: State law requires water systems to adopt rules by Jan. 1, 2027. City properties already comply. Businesses, institutions and homeowners associations face deadlines that run through 2031.

Where things stand: Sustainability Specialist Michaela Camellamella outlined the phased schedule:
- Public properties in January 2027
- Commercial, industrial and institutional properties in 2028
- HOA common areas in 2029
- Public properties in disadvantaged communities in 2031

Four water providers serve Menlo Park, and each must adopt its own rules. “The city owns and maintains 68 total irrigated landscape sites,” Camellamella said. She added that all of them comply. Staff described outreach efforts, a Landscape Analysis Program and the Lawn Be Gone rebate of $3 per square foot.

Councilmember Combs asked, “Couldn't compliance also be irrigating with nonpotable water?” Staff said non-potable irrigation is allowed, but the city has no recycled water. Staff said compliance means stopping irrigation or replacing turf, and that exemptions apply for tree health. City turf has been left brown. Replanting with native species would require funding.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The council introduced the ordinance and waived its first reading. It amends Chapter 7.35, Water Conservation, of the municipal code. Vice Mayor Wise moved the item and Councilmember Cecilia Taylor seconded. The clerk declared it passed unanimously. Property managers at commercial sites and HOAs face the next compliance deadlines.


Three Developers Still in Running for Downtown Lots

The basics: The Surplus Land Act is a state law that requires cities to offer surplus public land for affordable housing before disposing of it. Certain exemptions apply.

Where things stand: Mayor Nash asked staff to clarify the exemption used to keep the Presidio Bay proposal in the running. A Community Development staff member said the state housing department's notice to interested parties is complete: “We've already done that as part of the initial exemption process.” Only a narrow list of local public agencies still needs notice. “All three developers that have applied are now still in the running,” Nash said.

Why it matters: The downtown parking lots appear on the city's housing element site list. That list shows the state how Menlo Park can meet its Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA). Staff said removing sites could force the city to find backfill sites. Staff and the mayor also discussed Program H-4G and possible further analysis if affordability assumptions change.

What's next: The new council will choose among the three proposals. Nash suggested more clearly separating site capacity from active projects, citing confusion among residents.


Minor Items

  • Consent calendar approved: The council approved the minutes, grant resolutions for the Belhaven Child Development Center and Las Lomitas Elementary School District, and an event sponsorship policy. Wise moved, Taylor seconded, and Combs was absent. The yes tally was not stated.
  • Artificial turf request: Public commenter John McKenna urged the council to agendize the Environmental Quality Commission's recommendation to “stop the installation of artificial grass in Menlo Park.”
  • Truck safety on El Camino: Menlo College student Kylie Lewis described a sideswipe by a side-loader truck making a U-turn near Middle Avenue. She asked the city to seek a Caltrans review of U-turn limits for large trucks.
  • Closed session: The council reported no reportable action on litigation, employee evaluations or labor negotiations.

Looking Ahead

City Manager Justin Murphy flagged off-cycle meetings of the Parks and Recreation and Complete Streets commissions. He said “there might be a special City Council meeting on December 1st.” The Complete Streets Commission will review the Santa Cruz Avenue and Sand Hill Road corridor study before it goes to the council in early 2027.