Louisville Planning Commission Approves $50M Retail Center, Rezones Explosion Site

The Louisville Metro Planning Commission packed its April 23 agenda with consequential land use decisions, unanimously green-lighting a 19-acre retail and grocery development on Preston Highway, downzoning a Clifton industrial site scarred by a 2024 explosion, and grappling with a recurring enforcement problem that lets property sellers walk away from binding element fines.

• $50M Preston Highway retail center with grocery store, 129,000 sq ft retail building, and Jaggers restaurant wins unanimous approval with up to $1M in required road improvements
• Clifton explosion site rezoned 8-1 from heavy industrial to commercial manufacturing, with a call for Metro Council to pursue broader area-wide rezoning of adjacent M-2 parcels
• Three binding element citations upheld but fines zeroed or deferred, exposing a KRS 100 loophole that lets violations evaporate when properties change hands
• Scrap metal transfer facility approved unanimously on Eiler Avenue near the airport with strict junkyard prevention conditions
• Poplar Level Road triplex conversion approved over one commissioner's objection, legalizing an existing housing configuration

---

Preston Hwy Gets a Grocery Store and 350 Jobs

Why it matters: A fast-growing stretch of Preston Highway will gain its first major grocery anchor, a 129,000-square-foot retail building, and a Jaggers drive-through restaurant — a combined $50 million private investment creating more than 350 permanent jobs and requiring nearly $1 million in publicly beneficial road upgrades.

Where things stand: Brad Smith, director of Stern Development, told commissioners the project represents six years of corridor development along Preston Highway. "The project represents a private investment of approximately $50 million. Would create more than 350 permanent jobs and several hundred additional temporary construction jobs," he said.

The plan calls for rezoning nine parcels totaling roughly 19 acres from R-4 residential to C-2 commercial, along with a form district change from neighborhood to suburban marketplace corridor. Attorney Nick Prosco of Bardenwerper, Talbott & Roberts presented the detailed development plan, which includes a 58,700-square-foot grocery store, a 129,000-square-foot retail building, and a 3,500-square-foot Jaggers restaurant.

Required infrastructure improvements are significant: a new traffic signal at Maple Spring Drive and Preston Highway, widening of Maple Spring Drive to 24 feet, and lengthening of the southbound left-turn lane — estimated at $700,000 to $1 million in off-site work. The Kentucky Transportation Cabinet's concerns were addressed through binding elements requiring KYTC approval before any certificate of occupancy is issued.

Assistant County Attorney Laura Ferguson read a new binding element into the record requiring Metro Council review for any significant future changes to the development plan, adding an additional layer of public oversight.

Decisions: All five motions — rezoning, form district change, waterway buffer variance, three building design waivers, and the detailed development plan with amended binding elements — passed unanimously (For: 8, Against: 0, Absent: 1). Commissioner Russ Lohan was absent.

What's next: The rezoning and form district change now go to Louisville Metro Council for final approval.

---

Clifton Explosion Site Downzoned After Heated Debate

The basics: Metro Council Resolution 121 (Series 2025) directed staff to evaluate more appropriate zoning for a 3.1-acre parcel at 1901 R Payne Street in Clifton — the site of a devastating industrial explosion in November 2024 that damaged the facility and surrounding homes. Staff recommended rezoning from M-2 (heavy industrial) to C-M (commercial manufacturing), which reduces allowed industrial intensity while opening the property to commercial and residential uses.

Why it matters: This is the first Metro Council-initiated area-wide rezoning of private property in recent Louisville Metro history. The outcome could set a precedent for how the city responds to industrial hazards in neighborhoods, and commissioners urged Metro Council to go further by studying rezoning of all adjacent M-2 parcels.

Where things stand: The Clifton Community Council turned out in force. Mike O'Leary, president of the Clifton Community Council, presented eight arguments in favor, centering on safety and neighborhood compatibility. "This issue is not about blame for the explosions that have occurred on site. This issue shows why intensity and proximity matter," he said. "What happens on this site can impact surrounding homes."

Pam Vetter, Clifton Community Council board member, also spoke in support, arguing that C-M zoning is more compatible with the Traditional Neighborhood Form District and Clifton Preservation District guidelines.

The other side: Commissioner Stephen Lannert was the lone dissenter, delivering pointed criticism of the rezoning. "CM zoning is so restrictive that it's virtually useless," he said. "Vengeance rezoning has no place in civil society." Lannert argued the property was being downzoned without owner consent and that C-2 uses permitted under C-M could bring liquor stores and strip clubs to the area.

Commissioner Suzanne Cheek acknowledged the difficulty of the case but ultimately voted yes. "I am prepared to support this rezoning because two reasons. One, I'm satisfied that the owner has been noticed properly about this," she said, adding that "the highest and best use of land changes over time."

Chair David Steff pushed for broader action: "I do think rezoning makes sense, but I would feel more comfortable if the adjacent owners were included in this." The final motion included a recommendation that Metro Council explore a more comprehensive area-wide rezoning of adjacent M-2 properties.

Decisions: The rezoning passed 8-1 (For: 8, Against: 1, Absent: 1). Commissioner Lannert dissented; Commissioner Lohan was absent.

What's next: The recommendation goes to Metro Council, which initiated the rezoning and will make the final decision. The broader area-wide study of adjacent M-2 parcels now sits with Council as well.

---

Property Sales Keep Voiding Binding Element Fines

Why it matters: Across three separate binding element citation appeals, commissioners confronted the same problem: when a property with unresolved violations changes hands, Kentucky law makes it nearly impossible to enforce fines against the new owner — or collect from the seller who already pocketed the proceeds.

Where things stand: At 6405 Chism Road, new owner Barbara Aguirre purchased the property from DJN LLC and was unfamiliar with the compliance requirements attached to the zoning. The commission upheld the citation but zeroed the fine, directing staff to re-inspect in 90 days.

At 5323 New Cut Road, Joe Worth of Dreamworth Homes bought the property off-market without being informed of binding element obligations. Neighbor Ann Ramser presented a detailed timeline of enforcement actions and expressed frustration with two years of non-compliance. The commission upheld the citation and continued the fine decision to June 4, demanding a revised development plan. Worth faces a $1,000 fine if the plan is not submitted.

At 4826 Preston Highway, owner Rawand Najm similarly inherited violations from a prior owner. The commission applied the same treatment: citation upheld, fine deferred to June 4 pending a revised development plan.

Chair Steff flagged the systemic problem: "Seems like you can sell the property and get it from under the fine." Assistant County Attorney Laura Ferguson confirmed the structural limitation: "That is a problem of the KRS 100 with binding elements. That needs a statutory change."

Decisions: All three citations were upheld unanimously (For: 9, Against: 0, Absent: 1). Fines were zeroed (Chism Road) or deferred to June 4 (New Cut Road and Preston Highway).

What's next: Staff will re-inspect 6405 Chism Road in 90 days. Property owners at 5323 New Cut Road and 4826 Preston Highway must submit revised development plans by June 4 or face fines. The KRS 100 enforcement gap remains unresolved absent action from the Kentucky General Assembly.

---

Scrap Metal Facility Approved With Tight Limits Near Airport

Why it matters: A new scrap metal intake facility on Eiler Avenue will operate under some of the most restrictive conditions the commission has imposed, preventing a collection operation from morphing into a full-scale junkyard in an industrial corridor near Louisville Muhammad Ali International Airport.

Where things stand: Attorney John Baker of Bricker Graydon, representing Hanna Investment Holdings LLC (Red Ball Recycling), explained the operation would be strictly a transfer facility — materials collected, sorted, and shipped to the company's main 20-acre processing site in Jeffersonville, Indiana. "There's also no area or part of their business plan that allows people to come on to their property to look for used car parts," Baker said. "They don't have heaps of items just sitting there day after day. They move them."

Brian Donahue, owner of Red Ball Recycling, confirmed the business model and voluntarily reduced closing hours from 8 p.m. to 6 p.m. Staff Planner Zack Jones read extensive modified conditions into the record, including a 10-car maximum storage cap and a 10-day holding limit. Engineer John Campbell of Heritage Engineering described the site plan, which includes an 8-to-12-foot opaque screening fence set back 25 feet from the property line with landscaping. Letters of support from Jeffersonville police were presented.

Decisions: All three motions — rezoning from EZ-1 to M-3, conditional use permit with modified conditions, and detailed development plan — passed unanimously (For: 8, Against: 0, Absent: 1).

---

Poplar Level Road Triplex: Low-Impact Infill

Commissioner Mims cast the sole dissenting vote as the commission approved converting an existing single-family home at 3827 Poplar Level Road into a duplex while legalizing a rear accessory dwelling unit as a third unit. No new construction is proposed.

Staff Planner Jude Mattingly presented the case, noting the proposal conformed to the comprehensive plan and was compatible with nearby R-5A and R-6 zoning. Property owner Mike Brewer of ZNB Properties explained that the gravel area on the lot predated his ownership and that he aimed only to convert the front structure. A waiver from landscape buffer requirements was justified by existing fencing and vegetation.

Decisions: The rezoning from R-5 to R-6, landscape buffer waiver, and detailed development plan all passed (For: 7, Against: 1, Absent: 1). Commissioner Jim Mims voted no on all three motions; Commissioner Lohan was absent.

---

Minor Items

• April 2 meeting minutes approved (For: 7, Against: 0, Abstain: 2, Absent: 1). Commissioners Cheek and Sistrunk abstained as they were absent from the April 2 meeting.