Locunity — where decisions happen.
Car Wash Noise Fix Stalls as Livingston Board Demands Worst-Case Modeling

Car Wash Noise Fix Stalls as Livingston Board Demands Worst-Case Modeling

Planning Board • LivingstonOctober 7, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Neighbors of the car wash at 107 East Mount Pleasant Avenue will wait at least another month for relief. The Livingston Planning Board spent about 90 minutes on Oct. 6, 2026, questioning a proposed sound fence whose noise model assumed only one of the site's 17 air guns was running, then carried the hearing to Nov. 10. Earlier in the night, the board approved a long-sought Route 10 exit for the 226-unit 45 South Livingston Avenue project.


  • Car wash sound fence hearing continued to Nov. 10 after the board challenged the noise model's one-air-gun assumption
  • Applicant's acoustical expert concedes the fence "conclusion wouldn't hold" if all air guns run at once
  • Applicant acknowledges the 38-decibel vacuum spec behind the earlier approval did not reflect real conditions
  • Route 10 egress approved for the 226-unit 45 South Livingston Avenue project, with nine conditions
  • Neighbor presses on Route 10 traffic. Expert says the new exit adds about 10 peak-period trips

Car Wash Fence Faces a 1-Decibel Margin

Why it matters: The renovated car wash at 107 East Mount Pleasant Avenue already exceeds the New Jersey Noise Code at the property line. The proposed fix is predicted to land just 1 decibel under the state limit, and the board doubts it covers real-world operations.

The basics: EAS Livingston LLC seeks amended preliminary and final site plan approval, Application 2024-54-PFSP, for Block 1512, Lot 12 in the B-1 zone. It also needs variances for a gray solid vinyl fence that would stand 6, 8 and 10 feet tall in different sections. The applicant filed after sound readings showed noncompliance with the state noise code.

"To cut to the chase, we are here tonight because we have a solution to the problem. It involves installing a fence at the property," said Thomas Troutner, attorney for EAS Livingston LLC.

Where things stand: Joseph Keefe, owner and principal of Ostergaard Acoustical Associates, testified that the model meets the 65 dBA limit at every receptor. The worst cases, receptors J1 and J2, came in at 64 dBA. The 2,000 Hz octave band sits right at the limit. Keefe said the model assumes a single air nozzle but still runs louder than field readings.

"So this model is more conservative and predicts higher sound levels than we've observed," said Keefe.

The other side: Board members noted that 17 nozzles exist on site and could operate together. Keefe said he could not say how many more nozzles could run without re-running the model. He then conceded the core vulnerability.

"So I'll say that certainly if all the air guns were on at once, our conclusion wouldn't hold, right?" said Keefe.

After a recess, the board's sound engineer asked for two additional models: one with four air guns and one with all 17. The engineer also noted that the county's April 16, 2026, violation involved higher-frequency bands, the same range where the current model has no margin. Board members also objected to receiving new material late in the process.

The 38-Decibel Problem

The board's skepticism has a history. A board member recalled earlier testimony that cited manufacturer readings of 38 decibels for the vacuums, a figure the board relied on in its prior approval.

Troutner said no sound consultant had verified that number. He added that the white enclosure built around the vacuum turbines did not solve the problem, and that the figure left out other sources, including the tunnel, the mat dryer and the air guns. Keefe said measured ambient noise at the site is already 61 dBA, driven by Route 10 traffic. He said he and the board's engineer would have rejected the 38-decibel figure.

"We both would have said that's bogus, right?" said Keefe.

That admission explains the board's posture. Having approved one fix based on unverified numbers, members now want worst-case, expert-verified modeling before signing off on a second.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. The applicant agreed to submit updated reports at least 10 days before the next hearing and accepted post-construction sound testing as a condition of any approval. Neighbors gain a more rigorous review but get no immediate relief. The operator faces added modeling costs and the possibility that a taller or different barrier will be required.

Near the end of the night, after the chair said public comments would be better taken at a later session, an audience member objected that residents' concerns are not irrelevant and asked what happens in the meantime. The chair said that is an enforcement matter outside the board's role in this hearing. No formal public statements have been taken yet.

What's next: The hearing resumes Tuesday, Nov. 10, without further notice. Updated models with four and 17 air guns are due at least 10 days earlier.


Route 10 Exit Approved for 226-Unit Project

Why it matters: The board approved a second way out of a large inclusionary development, meaning a project that includes affordable units. The new exit is meant to relieve congestion on South Livingston Avenue, a connection board members said had been sought for three or four years.

The basics: 45 Partners Urban Renewal LLC sought amended preliminary and final site plan approval, Application 2025-40-PFSP, for Block 3700, Lots 7, 28, 29 and 30. The board approved the 226-unit mixed-use project on Oct. 7, 2025. The amendment adds egress through the adjacent Lot 7, a connection the board and governing body had sought in the redevelopment plan.

"We are actually improving the egress from the site by obtaining the adjacent parcel and permitting the egress therefrom," said Derek Orth, attorney with Inglesino Taylor representing the applicant.

Where things stand: Engineering testimony described the following changes:

  • A 12-foot, one-way driveway with striping, stop signs and do-not-enter signs
  • A net loss of three parking spaces, leaving 497, which still meets requirements
  • A 103-square-foot reduction in impervious coverage
  • Agreement to loop the water service

Corey Chase, senior principal at Dynamic Traffic, said the change falls well below the New Jersey Department of Transportation's 100-trip review threshold. The applicant requested a letter of no interest from the state agency.

"It's approximately 10 additional trips during a peak period, so it's approximately 1 trip every 6 minutes," said Chase.

The other side: Nancy Wilson, a public commenter, asked how traffic would be managed. She noted it is already hard to turn onto Route 10 from the Sherbrooke Parkway area. Chase said overall traffic was approved previously and the new connection simply splits it between South Livingston Avenue and Route 10.

Board members raised a possible collision point where the new drive meets the existing lots and asked about stop control and sight distance. Chase said vehicles will stop and yield, and that sight distance is sufficient. Questions about easements produced a condition that recorded Lot 7 easements not be altered.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion passed by roll call with conditions the chair counted as nine. They include:

  • Relabeling the water loop
  • No change to recorded Lot 7 easements
  • Signage and striping
  • A state transportation department letter of no interest
  • A Title 39 jurisdiction request, which concerns New Jersey's motor vehicle and traffic law
  • Coordination on tree removal
  • No loss of Lot 7 parking
  • Keeping the Route 10 exit right-turn-only

Audible yes votes came from Mr. Lewis, Mr. Ratner, Mr. Diner, Ms. Fass, Mr. Dufford, Mr. Bottani, the alternate voting for the vice chair and Chairman Fernandez. Responses from Mr. Reber and Ms. Khanna were not clearly audible, so the full tally is unconfirmed. The chair declared, "Motion carries."

Residents along South Livingston Avenue stand to gain from split traffic. Lot 7 users are protected by the easement and parking conditions. Drivers near Sherbrooke Parkway, where Route 10 turns are already difficult, will be watching the right-turn-only exit closely.

What's next: The applicant must obtain the state letter of no interest and pursue the Title 39 jurisdiction request.


Minor Items

  • Quorum: Vice Chair Centola was absent, and an alternate voted in that seat.

Looking ahead: The car wash sound fence hearing returns Tuesday, Nov. 10. Neighbors who want to weigh in should be prepared for public statements at that session.