Locunity — where decisions happen.
Conservation Board Rewrites Scoring Rules as Waitlist Stretches to 2030

Conservation Board Rewrites Scoring Rules as Waitlist Stretches to 2030

Land Conservation Advisory Board • Buncombe CountyNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Buncombe County's Land Conservation Advisory Board on Nov. 18, 2026, changed how it ranks farm and forest projects for county money. It replaced a subjective "stewardship" test with a measurable share of forestland. The vote was unanimous, but the longer conversation was about a problem the new form cannot solve: landowners who want to conserve their land are lining up years ahead of the system's capacity to close easements.


  • Revised project evaluation form adopted unanimously; it scores forestland by percentage, uses tiered points, and adds a site-visit field
  • Land trust partner says demand is so heavy she is scheduling grant applications for 2030
  • Pinnacle Knob Slopes, about 41 acres in Sandy Mush, expected to close in December or January
  • Board weighs self-directed IRAs and estate planning to hold land while easements wait
  • County staff to clarify the land conservation share of the $30M bond

A Measurable Yardstick Replaces 'Stewardship'

Why it matters: The evaluation form drives how the board scores and ranks conservation projects before it recommends county funding. Any land trust applying in the next cycle will be judged on the new criteria.

Where things stand: County staff walked members through tracked changes from the prior meeting. Eligibility questions about applicants' track records did not change. Scoring did:

  • No question now scores zero; the lowest tier still earns 2 points
  • High, medium and low labels were added to each criterion
  • Language on leveraged funding now counts charitable donations as a funding source

The biggest change replaced the old criterion that asked whether a property "has forest" and whether its owners practice stewardship. Board members could not readily judge stewardship, staff said. The form now asks what percentage of the property is forestland.

"So we really just said we'd go to a percentage of the total property," said Ariel, county staff. Land trusts will have to report that percentage as a required field in the grant application.

Members also tightened the forestland ranges so the tiers do not overlap. One tier covers 30% to 60%, and the lowest tier is "less than 30."

The other side: Board Member Bruce Schlesinger raised a question about the quality of the board's own evaluations. "Might it be helpful to include a question as to whether or not the evaluation is based on an actual site visit or merely a presentation via our Zoom calls," he asked.

"We can add that, no problem," Ariel replied. Board Chair Nancy Edgerton noted that site visits already feed into decisions: "We always have a report back before the vote also."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board adopted the updated form as its ongoing evaluation tool, with a site-visit attendance field or comment section to be added. The vote passed unanimously by voice vote, with no individual tally recorded. Board Member Stagg Newman made the motion, and Board Member Liesl Erb seconded it.

Land trusts gain a clearer, more predictable standard, but they take on a new data requirement. Heavily forested properties stand to score higher. The site-visit field lets readers of a score see whether a member walked the land or only watched a presentation.

What's next: The next grant application went out after the meeting and is due Jan. 13. It will be the first cycle scored under the revised form.


Demand Outruns the Pipeline

Why it matters: Funding alone does not move land into protection. Staff time, surveys and closings do. Partners told the board that landowner interest now runs years ahead of what they can process.

Where things stand: Jess, a land trust partner, reported no recent Buncombe closings. She said the Pinnacle Knob Slopes project should close in December or January, pending landowner input. The board recommended the project, which covers about 41 acres in Sandy Mush next to already-protected land.

Her description of demand was blunt: "I'm telling landowners I can apply for grants on their behalf in 2030." She described her organization as "drinking from the fire hose" of landowner interest.

Jess also gave updates on two other projects:

  • Jenkins Branch Farm: Her organization is donating a conservation easement on its own 99-acre farm to the county's soil and water program. As a nonprofit, it cannot get present-use-value tax deferment, a program that lowers property taxes on working farmland, so it pays full taxes.
  • Swannanoa-area project: A board member asked about its status. Jess said closing is still projected for fall to winter 2027, and the Warren Wilson survey is not delaying it.

She praised the county's quarterly grant-reporting process. A second partner, Tom, had no update.

County staff reported that commissioners approved several projects, including a new one at Sluder Branch.

The outreach dilemma: Staff called a recent landowner event very successful:

  • Turnout ran above expectations
  • Staff are following up with four or five interested landowners
  • New voluntary agricultural district applications came in
  • Food costs were reimbursed through the North Carolina Foundation of Soil and Water Conservation Districts

Newman said the event led to roughly 50 more acres being conserved that may become part of Pisgah View State Park without LCAB funds.

Staff said they could host one or two such events a year if food funding is found. They added a caution, however, about generating interest when "you can't deliver an easement for 4+ years," Ariel said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Board members asked for updates on whether event leads become projects. Erb suggested a similar event in the Swannanoa area once those lands close, framed as a celebration of combined county and state funding.

The trade-off is plain. Outreach builds a constituency for conservation, but it also lengthens a line that landowners may not be willing to wait in.


Holding Land While the Money Waits

Why it matters: Years-long waits raise the risk that land is sold or developed before an easement closes. Interim tools could keep it undeveloped until funding arrives.

Where things stand: Newman cited a backlog of about 30 projects at SAHC. He proposed publicizing alternative models and drafting web content about them. "One model is an individual can put property in a self-directed IRA," he said, meaning a retirement account that can hold real estate until funding is available. He said several large landowners are interested in estate-based conservation.

Staff pointed to farm succession and estate planning as interim tools. Two upcoming events cover those topics:

  • A Friends of Agriculture breakfast on Feb. 12 at the Weaverville Community Center
  • A one-day succession school planned for March

The other side: Edgerton and Jess said land trusts already discuss every option case by case. They warned against overwhelming landowners with information. "It's not just pushing for an easement," Jess said. She called IRAs a fairly esoteric concept best handled in one-on-one conversation.

One participant floated building a database or list of alternatives. Jess recommended instead pointing landowners to project leads.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Staff offered to create a resource folder in the board's shared SharePoint.

Landowners with estate or retirement flexibility may gain options. Smaller or cash-strapped owners still depend on the grant queue.


Bond Approved; Conservation Share Still Unclear

Why it matters: Voters approved the county's new bond. How much of the $30M actually goes to land conservation will set the board's budget for years.

Where things stand: Responding to Schlesinger, staff said the Bond Oversight Committee was set to meet the day after the board meeting on the existing bond. A smaller internal committee will prepare for the new bond over the next couple of months.

That process, staff said, should produce a clear understanding of "what portion of the $30 million would be for land conservation," a figure that had been ambiguous. Staff expect LCAB and the Ag Advisory Board to receive updates.

Asked whether easement opportunities would increase, staff said they expect consistency rather than a surge.

What's next: Edgerton asked about the passive recreation committee. The three LCAB members who served on it have all left the board. If the committee is re-formed, three new members will need to be designated, though staff said that is not yet confirmed.


Minor Items

  • Agenda and Oct. 21 minutes: Both approved by voice vote; no tally was recorded.
  • New funding cycle: The next LCAB grant application is due Jan. 13, with project discussion at the January meeting.
  • Friends of Pisgah View State Park: The group announced an upcoming Saturday meeting at 1 p.m.

Looking Ahead

The board will not meet in December because of the holidays. It reconvenes in January, when the first applications scored under the revised form arrive.