

Hudson Ranch Geothermal Appeal Closes as Experts Clash Over Pricing
Board of Supervisors • Imperial CountyNovember 12, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Imperial County's Board of Supervisors, sitting as the Board of Equalization, closed the evidentiary record Nov. 12, 2026, on six property tax appeals from Hudson Ranch Power I LLC. The fight is over whether the plant's 2007 power contract or wholesale market prices should set its taxable value. The Board will deliberate privately and return by Dec. 22, 2026.
- Contract vs. market pricing drives a gap of well over $100M a year in disputed value
- Assessor defends roll values of about $234.7M, $216.2M and $188.3M for 2021–2023
- Assessor's appraiser concedes the 15% discount rate was likely too high; experts offer 10.98% and 8.1%
- Board admits late assessor exhibits over taxpayer objections, then closes the record
- Written closings due Dec. 8; Board returns by Dec. 22
Contract or Market: The $100 Million Question
Why it matters: The pricing method creates a gap of well over $100M per year between the assessor's values and the taxpayer's claimed values. The Board's choice will shape how geothermal plants in the county are valued and how much property tax revenue flows from them.
The basics: A power purchase agreement (PPA) is a long-term contract to sell a plant's electricity at set prices. Hudson Ranch's PPA dates to 2007. A discount rate converts projected income into present value. The lower the rate, the higher the value.
Where things stand: Sergio Luna, appraisal supervisor (commercial/industrial), Imperial County Assessor's Office, testified that the assessor moved the plant from market pricing to contract pricing. He called the switch a correction and said the dispute comes down to that choice. Under cross-examination, Luna conceded the assessor had not analyzed how the 2007 PPA compared with 2021 market pricing. Colin Fraser, counsel for Hudson Ranch Power I LLC, pressed him on the consequence: two identical plants with different PPAs would be valued differently.
Luna also said the 15% discount rate was carried forward from prior years and that his own calculations ran around 8% to 9%. "I think we were high," said Luna.
The assessor's alternative analysis, Exhibit Y, uses the taxpayer's inputs with contract pricing and a 10.98% rate. That rate came from Jeff Duran, tax representative and expert for Hudson Ranch Power I LLC. Exhibit Y supports higher values than the roll. Even so, the assessor did not ask the Board to raise the assessments. It asked only that the applications be denied.
Dawn Flessner, consultant retained by County counsel, Baker and O'Brien Inc., gave the county's rebuttal. "Market prices, especially the wholesale market prices, are not appropriate for valuing this facility," said Flessner. Flessner put the plant's levelized cost at $113.78 to $130.96 per megawatt-hour. Because that is far above market prices, Flessner said, on wholesale prices "the plant would be shut down." Flessner also said PPA prices show no excess profit, and therefore no intangible value to strip out.
On the discount rate, Flessner called 10.98% the high end of a reasonable range. Flessner's own derivation yields 8.1% for an LLC buyer, and Flessner disagreed with both Duran's derivation and Deloitte's adjustments. A lower rate, Flessner said, would push values above the roll. On cross-examination, Flessner conceded the PPA data relied on is also limited.
The other side: The taxpayer's experts rejected the premise that the plant depends on its contract. "There is no need for PPA for a plant like Hudson Ranch to be able to operate and to be able to earn revenue selling their products," said Arnie Olson, expert witness for the taxpayer, E3. Olson described the PPA as a financial hedging instrument and dismissed cost as a measure of value: "What you paid to build it 15 years ago is really completely irrelevant."
Duran defended the taxpayer's federal data. "FERC is a very good source of data for electric generating facilities of all types," said Duran. The assessor challenged an Imperial Irrigation District contract figure using Exhibit BB.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The Board made no decision. The county's revenue base and the taxpayer's bill both hinge on the answer. Other geothermal operators in the county have a stake in the precedent. The discount-rate testimony carries risk for Hudson Ranch: a lower rate cuts against its claim for lower assessments.
Board Lets Late Assessor Exhibits Into the Record
Why it matters: These rulings fix what evidence the Board may weigh in its findings, and they could shape any appeal.
Where things stand: Fraser argued that the assessor bore the burden of proof for 2021 and 2022. He said Rule 473 requires an allocation of value to mineral rights. Luna agreed an allocation is required. Asked about Exhibit Y, he answered, "There is no allocation," said Luna.
The assessor then offered Exhibit AA, a reserves allocation sheet. Luna said it was created two to three weeks earlier and allocates about $49M to 2021 reserves. Fraser objected that it had never been disclosed. "What I'm looking at here are documents that have never been exchanged with me before," said Fraser. Robin Thornton, counsel for the Imperial County Assessor, said AA rebuts testimony that no allocation was performed. Board counsel recommended overruling the objection, and the Board Chair agreed.
Fraser also moved to strike Flessner's rebuttal exhibits, W and X. "They're sandbagging the taxpayer by sneaking information into the case," said Fraser. "It is rebuttal evidence," said Thornton. Board counsel advised the Board to "make an exception and allow this evidence in" despite the exhibit-exchange deadline. The exhibits were admitted.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The Board handled the remaining exhibits this way:
- Exhibit BB, a later IID contract amendment, was first excluded, then admitted. The Board will weigh its date.
- Exhibit M, Revenue and Taxation Code Section 501, received judicial notice.
- Exhibits 49–63 received judicial notice as legal authority, not as evidence.
The record was then closed. No roll-call votes were taken. The Chair accepted counsel's recommendations from the dais. The taxpayer's objections to the late exhibits are now part of the record.
What's next: Findings will be based on this closed record.
Looking Ahead
Both sides waived oral closing arguments. Five-page written closings and 25-page proposed findings are due Dec. 8, 2026, and the court reporter was asked to deliver the transcript within a week. "From you, everything by December 8th. From us, everything by December 22nd," Board counsel told the parties. The Board will deliberate privately and return by Dec. 22, 2026.