

Imperial County Extends Data Center Moratorium to June 2028 Over Union Objections
Board of Supervisors • Imperial CountyNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Imperial County will keep its pause on data center approvals in place until June 16, 2028. Building trades unions argued that local workers are waiting for jobs, while residents and the county's advisory committee chair pushed for time to write siting rules. The Board of Supervisors adopted the interim ordinance extension on Nov. 17, 2026. In a long day, supervisors also sent a no-bid media contract back through purchasing, approved $20M in housing bonds and rejected a contractor's bid appeal.
- Data center moratorium extended to June 16, 2028, over objections from building trades unions
- $28,200 Beyond Borders Gazette contract sent back after it bypassed county purchasing
- Up to $20M in bonds approved for 48-unit Heber Del Sol; Kelley flags lost tax base
- Andrade Construction's bid protest appeal denied; IT server room project moves to next bidder
- Speakers on both sides of the data center fight allege harassment and demand security
Data Center Pause Stretches to June 2028
The basics: Under Government Code 65858, a county can adopt an interim moratorium that temporarily blocks a land use while it writes permanent rules. This ordinance bars approvals of data center facilities in unincorporated Imperial County. It does not stop staff from processing applications.
Why it matters: The county's first attempt failed in court. A judge set aside that moratorium, Ordinance 1616, which Ordinance 1618 had extended, in Imperial Valley Computer Manufacturing v. County of Imperial. The county returned the writ Oct. 13. Separately, a Sept. 10 Superior Court decision required California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review for the Imperial Data Center project.
Where things stand: The board adopted a second, 45-day moratorium, Ordinance 1621, on Oct. 6. County Counsel said a 4/5 vote was needed to extend it and that no general fund impact is expected.
Planning Director Jim Minnick said four proposals are pending, all in Mesquite Lake, including a pre-application from YK America. He said the moratorium limits how far they can advance. "Think of it as a pause to give us breathing space," said Minnick.
Supervisor John Hawk, District 5, asked why the extension runs 22 months. County Counsel answered that rescinding a moratorium is easy, but obtaining a new one is very difficult. Board Chair Peggy Price confirmed the board can revisit the ordinance earlier.
The county's Data Center Advisory Committee has met six times. During board reports, Price described its draft guidelines as including "land use and siting standards, which includes the elimination of by-right development." The draft also covers buffers, water disclosure, and noise and decommissioning standards. Supervisor Ryan E. Kelley, District 4, pledged $4,000 in discretionary funds to give the committee a budget and asked colleagues to contribute.
The other side: Labor led the opposition. Hector Mesa, a local union representative, said local apprentices and journeymen are waiting for projects, though he supported holding developers accountable. Andrew Schwartz, President of the Imperial County Building and Construction Trades Council and a member of International Union of Operating Engineers Local 12, said recently signed state laws already provide enough protection. He urged the county to adopt ordinances instead of a moratorium.
Supporters included Michelle Hollinger of Victoria Homes, who cited protection for Victoria Ranch homeowners and asked the county to cover similar uses to close a loophole. Christian Salgado, chair of the Data Center Advisory Committee, spoke as a member of the public and backed the full extension. Jake Tyson, a public commenter, reversed his earlier opposition so the committee would have time to work.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Supervisor Jesus Eduardo Escobar, District 1, moved the extension, and Supervisor Martha Cardenas-Singh, District 2, seconded. The chair declared it passed; individual votes were not announced. Mesquite Lake applicants can keep moving through review but cannot win approval. The trades lose near-term work, and nearby homeowners gain time for buffer and water rules.
"I'll support the motion, but I'm asking that staff provide a legislative analysis of the bills in a fact sheet white paper," said Kelley.
What's next: Staff will prepare that analysis of the new state laws for the committee and the public. The moratorium runs through June 16, 2028 unless the board lifts it sooner.
Data Center Tensions Spill Into Public Comment
Most general public comment came from people involved in the data center fight, and much of it was about safety. Idell Burden, a public commenter, said she was mocked, taunted and followed at the advisory committee's meeting the night before. She asked whether the board would provide security.
Maritza Hurtado agreed that more security is needed. She alleged she had been photographed and stalked, and she raised nepotism and funding concerns about a supervisor. Peter Rodriguez urged civil conduct at the committee.
Carlos Duran made allegations of intimidation against Tyson, prompting a warning from Price: "you must follow the decorum of this room." Tyson then argued that CEQA requirements and drying capital make data centers unviable. None of these allegations were substantiated or acted on by the board.
No-Bid Media Deal Exposes Purchasing Gaps
Why it matters: The item was a $28,200 annual media and strategic communications agreement with Beyond Borders Gazette. Supervisors found it had skipped the county's purchasing process entirely. That discovery opened a broader fight over how much spending authority staff should have.
Where things stand: Cardenas-Singh pulled the item from consent. She put on the record that the vendor had sent an email suggesting private meetings. She said she had never had a meeting, call or text with the people named in that email.
Asked whether the contract went out for proposals, a county staff member answered, "No, it did not." The staff member said the vendor was chosen "based on continuity of prior work with Beyond Borders Gazette." County Counsel said, "This contract I don't believe came to our office at all."
"As a centralized purchasing department, everything should go through the procurement process, the purchasing process, including this agreement," said the county's purchasing agent.
The other side: Kelley and Escobar argued that the rules are the problem. "We are not being very flexible in moving anything forward in the County of Imperial," said Kelley. "We shouldn't be strangling department heads," said Escobar.
Supervisors disagreed over whether the CEO's signing authority is $50,000 or the $100,000 some members remembered. The current rules require informal solicitation for purchases of $5,000 to $50,000 and formal solicitation above $50,000.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no vote. Price stated, "I think direction was to run it through the process." The contract will return through either informal solicitation or a sole-source justification. Kelley asked counsel to bring back the ordinances so the board can raise the thresholds. "We certainly need to revisit this so that we have a better pathway to deal with situations," said Price.
What's next: The Gazette contract and the threshold ordinances will return at a future meeting.
Heber Housing Bonds Pass, Tax Questions Linger
The basics: TEFRA is a federal rule requiring a local government to publicly approve tax-exempt bonds issued for a private project.
Where things stand: Heber Del Sol Family Apartments is a completed 48-unit affordable development in Heber. Its TEFRA financing was first approved in September 2023. The borrower, CRP Heber Del Sol Family Apartments LP, is now seeking a permanent financing adjustment of up to $20M, with the California Municipal Finance Authority (CMFA) as issuer.
"It is important to emphasize that the County of Imperial assumes no financial or legal responsibility for repayment of this debt," said county staff. No one spoke during public comment.
The other side: Kelley questioned the project's property-tax exemption. "It's an added burden on all of our public safety and all of our services because it's not contributing to the tax base," said Kelley. He also recalled developer talk of opening a road at a Pitzer Road roundabout and contributing to a retention basin or park. Cardenas-Singh said the roundabout is in engineering and the road remains closed. Staff confirmed a welfare exemption is in place.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Escobar moved and Cardenas-Singh seconded. The motion passed, and individual votes were not announced. Kelley supported the bonds but asked for follow-up and possibly a future policy on tax-exempt projects.
What's next: Staff were directed to report back on the tax exemption and the developer's commitments.
Board Holds Line on Bid-Bond Deadline
Where things stand: Andrade Construction submitted a bid Aug. 14 for County Project SR7327IS, which supports the county's IT server room. After a Sept. 16 notice of award, Andrade had 10 days to deliver original bid bonds but did not. The county rejected the bid as non-responsive Oct. 1. Andrade filed a protest Oct. 7, which arrived Oct. 13 and was denied as untimely.
"We feel that the appeal should be denied," said Deputy County Counsel Faye Winkler.
The other side: Mark Collinsworth, legal counsel for Andrade Construction, argued the company had substantially complied and gained no competitive advantage. He suggested possible retaliation tied to an earlier dispute over a Social Services project. He also noted the bid was about $50,000 lower and urged the board to waive the discrepancy.
Cecilia Lainez of LC Construction urged the board to uphold her company's award. She said LC met its deadlines and stressed equal treatment and prevailing wage compliance.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Public Works Deputy Daniel Campo said another re-bid would be the project's third and add about two months. Cardenas-Singh recused herself after exchanging emails on the matter. Escobar moved to deny the appeal and award the project to the next apparent lowest bidder, and Kelley seconded. The motion passed; individual votes were not announced.
Minor Items
- Desert Shores rezoning: Three unanimous-in-effect motions moved 27 Desert Shores Drive to General Commercial, allowing a tire shop. No one spoke against it.
- Farmworker Appreciation Week: The board proclaimed Dec. 1-5 Farmworker Appreciation Week. The 47th Annual Farmworker Breakfast is Dec. 4.
- Bridges: Hawk pressed for repairs to the Picacho Road, Indian Rock, Arnold Road, Evan Hewes and Drew Road bridges.
- Closed session: On a 5-0 roll call, the board added an urgent potential-litigation item to closed session. Closed session ended with no reportable action.
- Mining: Luis Plancarte of Equinox Gold's Western Mesquite Mines cited 40 years of production and an exploration project expected in early 2027.
Looking Ahead
Watch for three items at upcoming meetings: the staff white paper on new state data center laws, revised purchasing thresholds and the Gazette contract's return, and staff answers on Heber Del Sol's tax exemption and road commitments.