

Data Center Panel Fight Dominates Election Day Supervisors Meeting
Board of Supervisors • Imperial CountyNovember 3, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
On Election Day, Imperial County supervisors spent most of their Nov. 3, 2026, meeting absorbing sharp public criticism over the new Data Center Advisory Committee, a court ruling against the county and the Board's conduct. They also declared a storm emergency on Ogilby Road and fielded complaints that unincorporated communities keep getting left behind.
- Data center committee fight splits commenters; county counsel says court found procedural error, not illegality
- Supervisors plead for civility after decorum warnings, security requests and reports of threats
- Niland and Calipatria advocates say outreach, funding and heat planning fall short
- Ogilby Road emergency declared, lifting Public Works' $5,000 spending cap; Picacho Road result unannounced
- Term limits resurface as Election Day commenters urge voters to change the Board
Data Center Panel Becomes a Lightning Rod
Why it matters: The fallout from a rejected data center project and the county's new advisory committee is driving distrust, calls for a ballot measure and conduct complaints. These pressures are likely to shape how the county handles large-scale land use in unincorporated areas.
Where things stand: About 11 people spoke during general public comment, and the data center dispute drew the most heat. Jake Tyson, a public commenter, said residents forced accountability on the project. He accused the Board of lacking transparency and demanded a ballot measure on the future of the unincorporated county.
Idell Burden, a public commenter, argued the county had handed its own planning job to a volunteer committee. She called it the chair's advisory committee and said it is set up to fail. Kelly Jordan, a public commenter, said she was troubled by conduct at the committee's meeting the night before. She also faulted leadership, including the chair, for not intervening.
Setting the legal record straight: At the chair's request, county counsel addressed the court ruling. “The judgment found a CEQA procedural error,” said County Counsel. The ruling applied to the project's lot merger and road vacation, and the approvals were set aside pending environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act. Counsel also said “the court did not find that the board acted illegally.”
The other side: Not every commenter wanted the committee scrapped. Matt Tessert, a public commenter, defended the committee's mandate and told supervisors to stay the course. Joseph Guillén, a public commenter, said some committee members want a ban and the panel is wasting time. He urged the Board to answer questions directly to cut down on misinformation.
The chair responds: Board Chair Peggy Price, Supervisor, District 3, said the committee is on its fourth meeting and following its charge. She said “it almost feels as the goal is to delegitimize this advisory committee.” She also pushed back on personal attacks. “I was accused of breaking the law, which is not true,” said Price.
Supervisor, District 5, John Hawk defended Price's conduct at the committee meeting, saying “she was very careful not to speak up during the meeting last night.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken, because public comment and board reports are not voting items. The committee continues its work. Residents who want a ballot measure or an outright ban, and those who want the panel to keep studying the issue, are both organized and showing up. Supervisors now face pressure from both directions on any recommendation the committee produces.
What's next: The committee continues meeting. Residents who want to weigh in should attend its sessions and watch for its eventual recommendations to the Board.
Civility Breaks Down at the Podium
Why it matters: Heated rhetoric led to formal warnings, a call for security and a warning from supervisors about safety. These tensions could change how public comment is run.
Where things stand: Price warned Tyson and Burden during their remarks and reminded the audience not to speak during comments. Maritza Hurtado, a public commenter, recommended security at Board meetings. Some speakers, including Hurtado and Carlos Duran, made allegations against named individuals. None of those claims were substantiated at the meeting.
From the dais: During board reports, Supervisor, District 1, Jesus Eduardo Escobar said insults are overshadowing the Board's job. “But if we continue to insult and berate and lack the respect that we all deserve, we will get nowhere,” said Escobar. Supervisor, District 4, Ryan E. Kelley said demonizing elected officials has consequences. Price said Board members have received threats.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No rule changes were proposed. For now, the chair's decorum warnings and the existing public comment code of conduct remain the main tools for managing meetings.
Unincorporated Communities Say They're Overlooked
Why it matters: Communities such as Niland and Calipatria have no city council to lobby for them. Small community benefit grants and county outreach often decide whether residents can reach services at all.
Where things stand: William Cooper of the Becoming Project and April Ochoa, a public commenter, said unincorporated communities receive minimal donations. They also cited poor communication about services, including a behavioral health van. Veneranda Cooper, a public commenter, said the new county building in Calipatria is often closed, confusing to residents and unhelpful to unhoused visitors. Price directed staff to give her the facility's schedule and staffing information.
Heat plan dispute: William Cooper objected to county action on a Calipatria heat plan. Kelley raised his own concern about the funding. “But $530,000 came from the state in early 2025,” said Kelley. He said the heat emergency response plan the money was meant to fund has not been produced. He added that the Calipatria center had been open only three weeks. Price said the Board must spread limited discretionary funds across all five districts.
Recycling gap: Ochoa also spoke on consent item 36, a five-year access agreement with the Imperial Valley Resource Management Agency (IVRMA) for mobile recycling collection. She praised the program but said it appears limited to cities. She named Niland, Ocotillo, Seeley and Winterhaven as communities left out, and described residents of the Slabs and Niland traveling long distances to recycle cans.
Kelley said IVRMA is a joint powers authority of the county's seven cities, funded by CalRecycle. He said it can schedule pickups in places like Niland and Bombay Beach on request. Vice Chair Martha Cardenas-Singh, Supervisor, District 2, pointed Ochoa to the agency's own forum: “there's an actual commission that hears, and there is opportunity for you to attend.” Cardenas-Singh also offered to email Ochoa the information.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The IVRMA agreement passed as part of the consent calendar. Unincorporated residents can request pickups, but they will need to push for service through IVRMA's commission rather than the Board.
What's next: Residents seeking recycling stops can contact IVRMA or attend its commission meetings. Watch whether the heat response plan materializes.
Storm Damage Triggers Emergency Declarations
Why it matters: An emergency declaration lifts the Public Works director's spending cap so crews can repair damaged roads immediately. That matters for remote routes serving southeastern Imperial County.
Where things stand: Public Works Director David Dale said a Sept. 1 monsoon washed out Ogilby Road, County Route S34. Crews permanently fixed one wash: “we added 3 pipes so that wouldn't happen again,” said Dale. Hawk reported that weekend rain washed out the road again in the same spot. Dale said the road should reopen by Thursday, Nov. 5.
Dale explained why the declarations matter. “My spending limit is $5,000,” said Dale. A second resolution covered the unpaved segment of Picacho Road. That 18-mile dirt road serves Picacho State Recreation Area, where storms can strand state employees.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The Ogilby Road declaration passed on a motion by Escobar, seconded by Hawk; no tally was stated. The Picacho Road resolution was moved by Hawk and seconded by Escobar. The chair called the vote, but no result was announced, and official minutes will confirm the outcome.
Escobar asked staff for a red-yellow-green risk ranking of vulnerable roads and bridges. Tessert urged the Board to use public benefit funds to fix Picacho Road and the Drew Road bridges. Cardenas-Singh thanked fire and public works crews in Ocotillo, where “over 1,000 sandbags were readily available.” The consent calendar also extended existing bridge emergency declarations.
What's next: Watch for the risk ranking Escobar requested and for confirmation of the Picacho Road vote.
Term Limits Return on Election Day
Peter Rodriguez and William Cooper, both public commenters, criticized the Board's stance against term limits, and others urged voters to choose change. Rodriguez also faulted supervisors' conduct at the prior meeting. Tessert countered that elected officials must absorb criticism and urged supervisors to stay the course. No action was taken.
Minor Items
- National Adoption Month proclaimed (For: 5, Against: 0, Absent: 0); about 270 county youth are in foster care. “We have finalized about 19 adoptions, and we're looking at finalizing a total of 29 before the end of the year,” said Social Services Director Paula Yanez.
- Caregiver Appreciation Month honors more than 9,200 In-Home Supportive Services providers serving over 10,000 recipients; the District 5 roll call response was not clear.
- Closed session covered Alvarez v. County of Imperial, an anticipated-litigation matter and bargaining with 14 labor units; staff got direction, with no final action reported.
- Consent calendar and budget approved; Cody's Closet support for its Beds 4 Knowledge event rose to $1,000 after District 5 added $500.
- Oct. 27, 2026, proceedings approved; no items were pulled and no department announcements were made.