

Picacho Bridge Anger Meets Slow Repair Timeline; Tax Levy Stalls
Board of Supervisors • Imperial CountyOctober 27, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Residents told Imperial County supervisors on Oct. 27, 2026, that the county has let its bridges fail, and Public Works confirmed the scale of the problem: 12 closed bridges and a Picacho Road Bridge replacement more than a year away. The board also left its tax levy rates unratified after the elected auditor-controller refused to sign off. It declared a local emergency ahead of a strong El Niño winter and denied a power company's bid for remote testimony in a tax appeal.
- Picacho Road Bridge replacement is at least a year-plus away, with an $8M-plus cost and federal grants still pending
- Tax levy ratification stalls with no vote after Auditor-Controller Karina Alvarez refuses sign-off, and supervisors seek legal options
- Board denies remote witness, 4-1 with one recusal, in Hudson Ranch Power I LLC assessment case
- 160 duplicate ballots went to confidential voters, and first election-night results may not come until about 8:30 p.m. or later
- Local emergency proclaimed for El Niño storms and flooding
- Public comment turns heated over Supervisor John Hawk and a court ruling, days before the Nov. 3 election
Picacho Bridge: Residents Push, Public Works Explains
Two public commenters blamed the board for the closed Picacho Road Bridge. Public Works then laid out why a fix will take time.
Why it matters: The closure affects access and emergency response for the Kachan community. Public Works reported 12 closed bridges and about 130 aging county bridges.
Where things stand: David Dale of Imperial County Public Works said the Picacho bridge is more than 100 years old and partially collapsed into the Yuma Main Canal. Its replacement design is 95% complete and is estimated to cost more than $8M. Federal grant applications are pending, and permitting with multiple agencies has caused delays.
Drivers face a 3-mile detour over the Arnold Road Bridge, which itself needs about $500,000 in abutment repairs. Dale said about $5.5M of the county's lithium fund has been allocated to bridges.
Supervisor John Hawk (District 5) asked whether the Army Corps of Engineers could supply a bridge. Dale said the Picacho site needs a span bridge, and that option would not shorten the timeline.
The other side: Idell Burden, a public commenter, said the county has neglected its bridges for years. "You cannot operate as a reaction to crisis," she said.
Peter Rodriguez, a public commenter, urged an urgent repair and asked about federal help.
Board Chair Peggy Price said work and two grant applications are already in process. "We don't wait for a crisis," said Price.
What's next: Supervisors want a fuller public accounting. "I would just ask that we bring this back under a more formal presentation to our community and obviously to this board," said Jesus Eduardo Escobar, Supervisor, District 1.
Vice Chair Martha Cardenas-Singh (District 2) backed the request for an overall report with timelines. No date was set.
Tax Levy Rates Stall in Auditor-Controller Standoff
The county's FY 2026-2027 tax levy rates went unratified. The independently elected auditor-controller refused to certify them.
Why it matters: Levy rates fund county services. Officials warned that a prolonged dispute could cost the county grants, delay audits and lower its bond rating.
Where things stand: An Executive Office representative said staff had contacted the auditor-controller twice for an update. "We have yet to hear a response," the representative said.
Karina Alvarez, Auditor-Controller, said she was excluded from the process. She said the retrospective calculations include consultant adjustments she could not corroborate. "So I will not sign off on that based on the lack of information that I received," said Alvarez.
The other side: Peter Rodriguez alleged the county missed a statutory Oct. 10 deadline to adopt and submit the levies and bypassed Alvarez's office. That claim was not independently confirmed at the meeting.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. "We would not have a motion at this time as we do not have a document in front of us to take action," said the Clerk of the Board.
Supervisor Ryan E. Kelley (District 4) asked colleagues to consider "exploring legal options for requiring and delivering the auditor-controller's responsibility as the elected official." The clerk noted that direction.
The standoff pits the board and its executive office against a separately elected fiscal officer. Taxpayers and the agencies funded by the levy are caught in between.
What's next: Staff will explore legal options. No return date was announced.
Hudson Ranch Witness Must Appear in Person
Sitting as the Board of Equalization, supervisors denied Hudson Ranch Power I LLC's request to let one corporate witness testify remotely in its assessment appeal.
The basics: The Board of Equalization hears property tax assessment appeals. Staff stressed this item was procedural under Revenue and Taxation Code Section 1616. It was not a decision on assessed value.
Where things stand: "We're asking for leave to have one witness appear remotely," said Colin Fraser, attorney for the applicant, Greenberg Traurig. Fraser argued that brief testimony from a corporate representative did not justify cross-country travel. He said appearing remotely would not impair cross-examination.
The other side: Robin Thornton, counsel for the county in the Hudson Ranch matter, called the witness "in our view, a critical witness and one that we would be entitled as the county assessor to cross-examine." Thornton said the contracts at issue are critical and a lone remote witness is unusual.
Cardenas-Singh asked about California law on remote participation. "The board has discretion to permit the remote appearance, to deny the remote appearance, or to permit the remote appearance subject to reasonable rules and procedures," said County Counsel.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Escobar moved to deny and require in-person testimony, and Cardenas-Singh seconded. The motion passed 4-1, with one recusal: Kelley, who cited real property he owns nearby. (For: 4, Against: 1, Recused: 1.) Individual votes were not announced.
What's next: The witness must appear in person at the Nov. 9 hearing. On a separate calendar item, County Assessor Robert Minville said an Assessment Appeals Board hearing set for Nov. 9 could run up to three days and a time extension expires Nov. 29. He warned that "the board needs to render a decision by that date or the assessed values would default to the applicant's requested value."
Public Comment Clash Days Before Election
Public comment became a political fight over Supervisor Hawk and county leadership. Many of the claims were disputed.
Where things stand: Peter Rodriguez said a superior court ruling found the county acted illegally on a lot merger. He also criticized remarks made about the Kachan tribe.
Kelley pushed back, saying the judgment found a procedural error under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). "The word illegal does not appear anywhere in the final judgment," said Kelley.
Jake Tyson, a public commenter, made allegations about county officials and urged a recall. Kelley said Tyson violated the board's code of conduct, and Price reminded him of decorum rules. Tyson's claims were not verified.
The other side: Mel Rebek, Marty Ellett and Joseph Kueh, all public commenters, defended the supervisors, and Rebek singled out Hawk. Kueh called the criticism an election-timed "October surprise," saying "this whole outrage only became apparent right as October came around."
"You've been elected to do that, and you can be assured that your constituents are behind you and appreciate you," said Ellett.
Storm and Ballot Readiness for Residents
El Niño emergency: Supervisors proclaimed a local emergency for 2026-27 El Niño storms and flooding. The proclamation follows the state's September declaration. Kelley moved and Cardenas-Singh seconded; the motion passed, and no tally was announced.
Fire Protection Chief David Lantzer said there have been six comparably strong El Niños in the past. "Five of those did result in increased rainfall above average for Southern California," said Lantzer. He added that the timing and location of storms are uncertain.
Fire Protection has attended weekly National Weather Service briefings and is prepositioning flood-fight materials with the state Department of Water Resources at the airport station. Biweekly briefings at the county Emergency Operations Center begin in November. Forecasts point to above-average rain risk from December through early 2027.
Election week: The Registrar of Voters representative disclosed a mailing error. "Last week we identified 160 duplicate ballots that were sent to confidential voters due to a mailing error on our part," the representative said. The office responded with FAQs, public service announcements in English and Spanish, and media interviews.
The registrar said Senate Bill 884 could bar every county from releasing results if voting hours are extended anywhere in California. In the best case, first results would come out about 8:30 p.m.
Escobar asked about missing ballots and noted a half-hour delay during the June primary. The registrar said that delay "wasn't because of anything that was legislative or missing." With seven days left, remailing ballots is no longer advised, and voters missing a ballot should go to a vote center.
Minor Items
- Lithium Valley: The consent budget included Dudek Contract Modification #8 ($118,025) and a $188,025 budget amendment, bringing the contract to about $3.52M. Rodriguez called the spending wasteful, while Kelley said the plan is separate from the Controlled Thermal Resources case.
- Mining oversight: Benchmark Resources' Bruce Subing said the county has 30-plus mine sites. Forfeiture of about $85,000 in financial assurances for the abandoned Picacho Mine is expected next month, and consultant costs are paid by operators, not the general fund.
- Calendar: The board approved calendar changes, including no meeting on Nov. 24 while chambers are upgraded and changes to the Dec. 24 and Dec. 31 holidays (Escobar/Hawk; passed).
- Public Defender: Daniel Rosenberg becomes Chief Public Defender. Outgoing chief Ben Solorio, elected to the bench, said the office is fully staffed.
- Consent changes: The Winterhaven Community Advisory Committee bylaws (Item 28) and the Pistol Pete's Gun Shop item (Item 31) were pulled. United Way of Imperial County support (Item 24) rose to $750 with $500 from District 5.
Looking Ahead
The general election is Nov. 3. The Hudson Ranch hearing is Nov. 9, and the board will not meet Nov. 24. Watch for the requested bridge presentation and staff's legal options on the tax levy dispute.