

Asheville Historic Panel Tells Rosewood Owner to Shrink Addition
Historic Resources Commission • AshevilleNovember 18, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Asheville's Historic Resources Commission drew a firm line on scale Nov. 18, 2026, telling the owner of a small Montford cottage that a proposed 1,220-square-foot rear addition is far too big. The applicant asked to continue the case to January to redesign. The commission also approved four certificates of appropriateness by voice vote, two of them for storm-damaged or failing historic walls. The meeting closed with a sharp internal dispute over who controls the commission's agenda.
- 37 Rosewood Avenue addition continued to January after staff, commissioners and a neighbor called it out of scale
- Dry-laid boulder wall approved at 7 Cherokee Road to spare a large tulip poplar in Albemarle Park
- Backup stone-veneer method approved for the Montford Park wall, a Helene recovery project
- 121 Pearson Drive rear addition approved with staff-review conditions
- Commissioner challenges executive committee appointments; staff defends the process, and no action was taken
Rosewood Addition Hits a Wall on Scale
Why it matters: The design standards set no numeric size limits for additions. This hearing shows how the commission interprets "subordinate" and gives applicants a rough benchmark.
Where things stand: The owners propose removing an existing rear addition and decks. In their place, they would build a 1,220-square-foot addition, a 264-square-foot screened porch, and a 7-foot by 6-foot-6-inch landing and stair on the west elevation. Staff said the addition is larger than the historic house and would alter the character of a diminutive cottage.
"It's like putting a whole other house on the back of this house," said Alex Cole, Urban Planner III and HRC staff liaison.
Staff also flagged two other problems. The proposed lot lines would require a subdivision recombination, and no application for one is on file. Staff also objected to the large left-side landing.
Commissioner Robert A. Mays seized on the lot-line issue. "If you're having to change the lot lines to get your addition in, it's too big," Mays said.
The other side: Owner Michaela Schmidlin said the design had gone through several rounds, adding deeper insets and a lowered roof. Builder Jim Demos offered to eliminate the cross-gable and reduce the landing. "We can certainly shrink that down without having any major impact on the design," said Demos.
Neighbor David Farron, speaking with Elizabeth Brawley, opposed the plan. He said the addition roughly doubles a small cottage and consumes most of the backyard on a triangular lot. He also warned it would create a 30-plus-foot wall effect that blocks light and sets a precedent. "We would ask that this not be approved," said Farron, neighbor. He added that they would not object to an appropriately scaled addition.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioners largely agreed the scale was excessive. When the applicant asked for direction, staff offered a concrete benchmark. "A third of what you are proposing right now would be something I could start to consider," said Cole.
At the applicant's request, the commission continued the hearing to its January meeting by voice vote. No tally was announced. Owners in Montford now have a clear signal: an addition that rivals the original house is unlikely to pass.
What's next: The applicant returns in January with a redesign, which would need to shrink substantially to meet the subordinate-scale standard.
Boulder Wall Saves a Tulip Poplar
The basics: A timber retaining wall along the driveway at 7 Cherokee Road in the Albemarle Park Historic District collapsed. The case first came to the commission in September.
Where things stand: Staff said the original plan, a CMU (concrete block) wall with veneer, would have harmed a large tulip poplar. The applicant revised the plan to a 47-foot dry-laid boulder wall. Staff suggested using stone closer to what is found in the district and adding ground cover to soften the wall.
"What it says in the standards is it says native stone, dry laid native stone," said Cole. Cole noted the commission has always required applicants to specify a source.
Commissioners asked about engineering requirements for walls over 4 feet. Steve Berry, representative for homeowner Emma Kelly, said the wall would stay under 4 feet and that the contractor would handle permitting.
Why it matters: The case exposed a recurring problem. Historic walls are aging, the 4-foot engineering threshold constrains how they can be rebuilt, and the design standards lack material detail. Mays pushed for a broader look: "We need to understand what the options are for rebuilding those and maybe even look into lobbying the legislature for some kind of an exemption for historic walls."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A commissioner moved to approve with two conditions: staff must approve the stone type and source, and a landscaping plan to screen the wall. The chair announced the certificate granted by voice vote; no tally was stated. The owner can now stabilize an unsupported bank while saving the tree.
Montford Park Wall Gets a Plan B
Why it matters: This Helene recovery project, run by the city's Parks and Recreation Department, can now proceed without a second commission hearing if salvaged stone proves unusable.
Where things stand: Staff said the March approval covered a concrete wall at 345 Montford Avenue, with the existing stone reconstructed in front. The city sought approval for an alternative: poured concrete with Biltmore mosaic stone veneer.
Engineer Josh Blake of Ardura called the alternative a backup plan and corrected the record on the wall type. "It's not a CMU wall, it's a cast-in-place concrete wall," said Blake.
Mays pressed on tradition. "Is it possible for an engineer to stamp for structural strength a wall built the way this one was originally, just cobblestones and mortar?" he asked. Blake replied that a wall of about 7 feet cannot practically be stamped as traditional cobble and mortar.
Tracy Wyman, project manager for Parks and Recreation, said the wall is about 4 feet tall and the earth behind it is slumping. Wyman said the plans require varied stone, mortar joints and mockups. One commissioner pushed for visible mortar joints.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The commission approved the amendment to CA #25-10291PZ by voice vote; no tally was stated. The approval carries one condition: Parks must confirm with HRC staff that the alternative is needed before using it. This is the second wall case of the night in which engineering limits shaped how a historic wall gets rebuilt.
Pearson Drive Addition Clears the Bar
Where things stand: At 121 Pearson Drive, the owner will remove a rear porch and build a two-story, 500-square-foot addition with a 157-square-foot screened porch. Staff said the house belongs to Commissioner Cecil Holt, who was not present.
Staff said grade changes hide the addition's lower level and raised no design concerns beyond missing specifications. Architect Jerry Phillips described a 4-foot additional offset that creates a 6-foot setback, with HVAC equipment hidden in that space. He said trim and siding would match the house and the windows would be true divided light. True divided light windows use separate panes of glass, unlike simulated grids.
Why it matters: This case is a useful contrast with Rosewood. A smaller, offset rear addition judged compatible won approval the same night a much larger one stalled.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A commissioner moved approval with conditions. Staff must review the window, door, mechanical and roofing specifications and a tree protection plan. The chair announced the certificate granted by voice vote; no tally was stated.
Fight Over Who Sets the Agenda
Where things stand: After the hearings, members discussed vacancies and the chair's appointment of two new executive committee members. Mays argued the bylaws require a vote on those appointments. He also said rulings limiting how members can propose amendments to the design guidelines shut out most of the commission.
"Regular commission members who were not on the executive committee are powerless to affect those things," said Mays.
The other side: Staff and others said the process was followed and that legal advice was given. They also said Amy Moxley's experience provides needed continuity. "We do need some continuity on the Commission, especially right now," said Cole. Other members urged more transparency.
Why it matters: The executive committee controls which design-standard amendments reach a vote. That power shapes future rulings on cases like the ones heard that night.
What's next: No vote was taken. The presiding member said the commission would revisit its rules and provide written answers.
Minor Items
- 14 Lodge Street: The commission approved a new deep maroon awning, signage and movable outdoor dining furniture for a planned coffee shop and wine bar. The approval includes removable bollards that meet alcohol-service requirements.
- 32 Hendersonville Road: The hearing on a 20-by-10-foot painted mural over an existing ghost sign was continued to December before any testimony.
Looking Ahead
The agenda lists the commission's next meeting for Dec. 9, 2026, at 4 p.m., when the Hendersonville Road mural is due back. The Rosewood Avenue redesign returns in January.