Locunity — where decisions happen.
Commission Backs Quinn House Fence, but Variance Faces High Bar

Commission Backs Quinn House Fence, but Variance Faces High Bar

Historic Preservation Commission • San FranciscoNovember 4, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San Francisco's Historic Preservation Commission sided with a landmark homeowner's security argument on Nov. 4, 2026, approving a front-yard plan for the circa-1870 Quinn House on McKinnon Avenue 7-0. The Zoning Administrator, who decides the 8-foot fence's height separately, warned that requests like it are usually denied. The commission also approved rear alterations to a Beaver Street villa and cleared stalled plaster work at the Clay Theater, with no opposition on any item.


  • Quinn House front-yard plan approved 7-0, but the fence height variance remains undecided
  • Clay Theater plaster replacement cleared 6-0 after Commissioner Hans Baldauf's recusal, restarting work toward a 2027 reopening
  • 22 Beaver Street landmark alterations approved 7-0, and the Zoning Administrator says he will grant the rear-yard variance

Quinn House: Security Versus the Setback Rule

The basics: A Certificate of Appropriateness is the commission's sign-off on changes to a city landmark. A variance is a separate exception to Planning Code rules, and the Zoning Administrator, not the commission, decides it.

Why it matters: The case drew the meeting's longest debate, about 30 minutes. It tests whether security concerns at a landmark can override front-yard limits that city officials say they rarely waive.

Where things stand: The project at 1562 McKinnon Ave., Landmark No. 63, resolves a 2020 enforcement case over an unpermitted carport, landscaping, retaining wall and fencing at the Italianate house. The owners want to legalize an 8-foot, 1-inch wrought iron fence and add an 8-foot driveway gate and a new section of fence. Planning staffer Gretel Gunther recommended approval with modifications that would make the project code compliant without a variance.

Eric Jacobs, representing the project sponsors, cited a 19-foot setback, low windows, a prior break-in and 12 neighbor signatures of support. He said "this unusual historic property presents genuine security and preservation challenges and is located in an area of SF with a very high crime rate." In response to a question from Baldauf, Jacobs said the fence's existing metal mesh would be removed.

Commissioners were sympathetic. "I don't think what you're asking for is unreasonable, I guess is what I'm trying to say," said Vice President Chris Foley, citing his own experience with break-ins. Commissioner Gayle Tsern Strang argued that a code-compliant fence height "that would be considerably lower actually creates an attractant."

The other side: Zoning Administrator Teague asked whether the security argument would apply to any home with a front setback. "The vast majority that we have had, they have been denied," he said of front-fence height variances. "It is kind of a high bar for this type of request for a variance."

Commissioner Hans Baldauf asked how the pieces fit together: "I'm a little unclear on the conditions when you say code compliant." Gunther replied, "It just needs to be code compliant." She explained that the owners could either lower the fence or move it out of the setback.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: After Teague raised a process concern, the commissioner who made the motion added a condition allowing the design to be modified in consultation with preservation staff so it complies with the Planning Code. Deputy City Attorney Andrea Ruiz-Eskide agreed with the approach. The vote was For: 7 (Diane Matsuda, Chris Foley, Eleanor R. Cox, Gayle Tsern Strang, Hans Baldauf, Dan Baroni, Robert Vergara), Against: 0, Absent: 0.

The owners can now proceed on the landmark's front yard. If the variance is denied, they may still need a code-compliant design. Commissioner Eleanor R. Cox urged the commission to "make a broad recommendation to the homeowners to maybe build a relationship with a historic architect."

What's next: Teague took the variance under advisement. His decision will come later by letter.


Clay Theater Cleared to Resume Work

Why it matters: Restoration at the Upper Fillmore movie house has been stalled. The approval restarts work toward a 2027 reopening and moves future fixes from the dais to staff.

Where things stand: Early in the meeting, Baldauf announced, "I will be asking to recuse myself from 2261 Fillmore as our firm has worked for the client on Fillmore Street." The commission approved his recusal 7-0. Foley disclosed that he had spoken briefly with the project sponsor and with Carolyn Kiernat of Page and Turnbull.

Planning staffer Michelle Taylor described a revision to Motion No. 508 for Landmark No. 302, which opened in 1913. The revision allows in-kind replacement of the auditorium's egg-and-dart molding and second-floor ornamental plaster. It also allows bracing of the signage and replacement of the ticket booth and metal cladding as needed. Conditions require a qualified specialist and mockups. Staff reported 32 supportive letters, many of them form letters.

Cody Allen, executive director of the Upper Fillmore Revitalization Project, said the century-old gypsum molding is thin and brittle and cannot be safely reinstalled. "The only way for us to incorporate these character-defining features into active use is to replace them in kind," he said. He added that primary work had been paused for more than two and a half months. Allen said Page and Turnbull and a conservator agreed on in-kind replacement, and he asked that staff be given discretion over later findings.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioners praised the sponsor's cooperation. "A lot less drama than the Castro Theater," said Foley. Commissioner Dan Baroni urged the team to "continue to work with staff and Page and Turnbull" rather than return to the commission. One commissioner asked that future revised certificates restate the key provisions of earlier approvals.

On a motion by Cox, the commission voted For: 6 (Matsuda, Foley, Cox, Tsern Strang, Baroni, Vergara), Against: 0, Recused: 1 (Baldauf). The sponsor gains administrative flexibility over the remaining exterior repairs. Neighborhood supporters gain a clearer path to a reopened theater.


Beaver Street Villa Clears Review, Barely

Why it matters: The changes affect only rear elements of a Corona Heights-area landmark that had already been altered. The variance cleared the minimum bar by the Zoning Administrator's own account.

Where things stand: At 22 Beaver St., the Benedict Geeling House (Landmark No. 284) is a 2.5-story Italianate villa on a lot with two buildings. The Kopp family plans to expand an attic dormer, raise a second-floor ceiling, swap a gabled kitchen roof for a flat roof, add rear roof decks and remove exterior stairs. Taylor found the project consistent with Article 10 and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards. Staff received one letter of support and none in opposition. The project needs a Section 134 rear-yard variance.

Architect Riad Ghanem argued that the request is small once Section 136 projections are counted. He said "we have a very imposing front setback in the range of 700%, more than what's required by the code." Commissioners confirmed that the rear gable is a 1933 addition, and the stair being removed dates to the 1970s. "I don't see this portion of the building being a contributing factor that would necessitate our extensive review," said Baroni.

The other side: Teague questioned the privacy and massing between the new decks and the rear carriage house. No commissioner raised privacy concerns.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The commission approved the certificate with conditions. The vote was For: 7 (Matsuda, Foley, Cox, Tsern Strang, Baldauf, Baroni, Vergara), Against: 0, Absent: 0. "I think just barely this project meets the minimum requirements for the variance, and I intend to grant with standard conditions," Teague said.

What's next: Teague's written variance determination is still to come.


Minor Items

  • Church demolition alert: Catherine Petrin of San Francisco Heritage flagged an emergency demolition application for the 1892 Seventh-day Adventist Church at Broderick and California streets. The Richardsonian Romanesque church cannot be landmarked as a religious building, and Petrin noted that "It's now zoned for up to 8 stories."
  • Landmarks advance: Planning staff said the Board of Supervisors' land use committee forwarded landmarks from Districts 2 and 3. Staff said "you will have another 20-plus landmarks," though a couple dropped out over owner opposition.
  • Historic districts initiated: Supervisors started the North Beach and Castro historic districts through the Article 10 process.
  • Minutes adopted: Commissioners approved the Oct. 21, 2026, minutes 7-0.

Looking Ahead

The North Beach and Castro historic district proposals will come before the commission before heading to the Board of Supervisors. The McKinnon Avenue fence variance decision will arrive by letter from the Zoning Administrator.