

Parents, Principal Press City for Lasting Fixes Outside Mission Schools
Government Audit & Oversight Committee • San FranciscoNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Needles, human waste and open drug use outside Marshall Elementary drove a roughly 90-minute hearing at San Francisco's Government Audit & Oversight Committee on Nov. 19, 2026. Parents told supervisors the city's cleanup is real but temporary. The committee filed the hearing 3-0 without binding action, so the follow-ups to watch are a single city point person and a 311 school flag. The panel also advanced a Port fuel dock lease, a Mills Act contract, a Twin Peaks land donation and nine settlements, and continued a self-checkout staffing ordinance to Dec. 3.
- School-area hazards hearing filed 3-0 as the principal and parents seek a long-term plan
- $12.25M from CrankStart and the state funds ambassadors, lighting and Marshall fencing
- Self-checkout staffing rule narrowed to stores of 15,000 square feet or more and continued to Dec. 3
- Sole-source Port fuel dock lease advances 3-0 with police and fire backing
- Mills Act deal for 100 McAllister and $8.3M Twin Peaks land gift head to full Board
Mission Schools Hearing Exposes Uneven City Response
Why it matters: SFUSD is shifting to neighborhood school assignment, and families ranked safety among their top three priorities. That ties street conditions outside campuses directly to enrollment and child safety.
Where things stand: Jackie Fielder, Supervisor, District 9, and the committee's vice chair, called the hearing after repeated complaints near Marshall, Bryant, Flynn and Cesar Chavez elementary schools and John O'Connell High School. She said Districts 5, 6 and 10 hear similar complaints. "This is an example of where we are failing," said Fielder.
Noah Engber, Principal, Marshall Elementary School, described needles, human waste, open drug use, objects thrown over the fence and secondhand smoke. He said the city's responses feel temporary and inconsistent. "We're not here to call anyone out. We're here to call everybody in," said Engber. He asked for a multi-department action plan with measurable goals, regular check-ins and a designated city point person.
Public Works cleans around Marshall every morning, six days a week. "Unfortunately, during this time, we're really short-staffed at Public Works," said DiJaida Durden, Deputy Director for Operations, Department of Public Works. Durden said schools and hospitals already get priority in DPW's 311 system. The Department of Public Health said it is working on a similar flag. DPH also described street teams whose daily rounds start at Marshall and said it plans to use Prop C funding to expand shelter transportation.
"School safety and the sense of safety around schools emerged as one of the top 3 priorities as we heard from families," said Hong Mei Pang, Chief of Staff, San Francisco Unified School District. Pang cited a fall survey with almost 3,000 responses. The district described its 311/911 protocols for principals and a Joint Information Center. It could not say whether teachers are trained on encampments and promised to follow up.
The other side: Parents welcomed the progress but called it localized. Marshall parent Daphne said a man was smoking fentanyl near the school that morning. Leonard Flynn parent Amanda Staveley asked how the city can expect children to be safe and respectful if it does not provide that. Two Paul Revere parents pushed back on policing. Robbie Schreffler said police shot an unhoused man with beanbag rounds in front of the school, and Kevin urged shifting police spending to housing and schools. Sarah Berger, a Moms Demand Action volunteer, said unsafe campuses hurt enrollment and called for long-term investment.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion to file passed. For: 3 (Sherrill, Fielder, Wong), Against: 0, Absent: 0. No policy was adopted, so families have only commitments, not mandates.
What's next: Fielder's closing notes named three follow-ups: a point person, a 311 school flag with DPH and a future survey with SFUSD.
The $12.25M Behind the Marshall Response
Where things stand: "We secured $12.25 million in total investments, including $9.25 million from CrankStart and $3 million state funding," said Rafael Moreno, Senior Program Manager, Office of Economic and Workforce Development.
The money pays for:
- Ambassador coverage and lighting
- Public safety technology
- Fencing, murals and landscaping at Marshall
- BART plaza activations
Moreno also cited:
- A multi-agency effort running since June 2026
- Monthly Third Saturday events with Mission Lotería that draw about 400 people
- A memorandum of understanding with BART
- A $1M procurement for plaza programming
The other side: Stephen Sherrill, Supervisor, District 2, and the committee chair, said the blank, unused walls around the school invite bad uses. He questioned whether $1M goes far enough and whether the DMACC model has run its course. "I'd just like to see something more comprehensive," said Sherrill.
Sherrill also asked about finding tenants for the former Walgreens site. Moreno said that site is tied to a Mission Housing development and pointed to SF Shines and lighting work. Engber noted the city's long-term urban planning teams were not at the table. "What's missing is long-term planning," he said.
Why it matters: Philanthropy is now the largest new resource behind the Marshall response. The unresolved question is whether temporary services can fix a physical streetscape.
Self-Checkout Staffing Rule Narrowed, Held to Dec. 3
The basics: The Labor and Employment Code amendment comes from Supervisor Mandelman's office and targets larger food and drug retailers. "It says there will be 1 attendant for every 3 self-checkout stations in operation," said Sophie Marie, Chief of Staff to Supervisor Mandelman.
Where things stand: Marie said the ordinance aims to protect jobs, preserve human interaction and curb retail theft. She cited similar laws in Costa Mesa, Long Beach and Santa Ana. The ordinance also requires stores to open a staffed lane first. The Office of Labor Standards Enforcement would enforce it, and stores would get a 15-day cure period to fix violations.
The amendments:
- Count all self-checkouts in a store as one unit
- Raise the size threshold from 10,000 to 15,000 square feet
- Apply the rule only from 8 a.m. to 10 p.m.
- Extend implementation from 30 to 90 days
- Drop the private right of action, so workers cannot sue directly
- Allow attendants to do incidental work and cover manager breaks
- Remove the 15-item limit as a legal mandate
"I ultimately do think that this is something that will help us retain working-class jobs," said Supervisor Wong, who asked to be added as a co-sponsor. Sherrill also spoke in support and thanked UFCW.
Public voices: Retail worker Gabriel D'Ambrosio described safety and theft problems when one attendant covers six machines. Nancy, a longtime retail worker, said self-checkout works when it is staffed. Norm Dagelman, a Haight-Ashbury Neighborhood Council member, said the machines take jobs. John Ellis backed staffing for accessibility and urged tracking of wait times, assistance requests and accessibility complaints.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The committee adopted the amendments and continued the item. For: 3 (Sherrill, Fielder, Wong), Against: 0, Absent: 0. Smaller stores and late-night hours now fall outside the rule. Without a private right of action, enforcement rests with the city.
What's next: The ordinance returns to committee Dec. 3.
Port Fuel Dock Lease Skips Bidding for Emergency Boats
Why it matters: Police, fire and Coast Guard boats rely on fueling in the bay. The Gas House Cove fuel dock is set to close in 2027 for a marina rebuild.
Where things stand: The resolution waives competitive bidding for a lease with Pilot Thomas Logistics LLC at Seawall Lot 303 near Hyde Street. Port staff said that dock has been closed since April 2021 for cleanup of an oil seep.
Lease terms:
- Five years, plus a five-year option
- Monthly base rent of about $10,683
- Adds gasoline to the existing diesel service
- $25,000 environmental oversight deposit
- $4.5M environmental line of credit
Officials argued that a competitive process would push reopening past the planned July 1 target.
"Our emergency services need fuel. It's that simple to me," said Sherrill. He said the waiver is not a "Wild West" but an existing operator adding a fuel type. Sgt. Mike Bushnell of the SFPD Marine Unit said losing a central station would force police boats to fuel outside county waters. Patrick Rabbit, Deputy Chief of Operations, San Francisco Fire Department, called the dock critical infrastructure for marine fire suppression and rescue. Pilot Thomas operations manager Todd Zondler said the company is ready.
The other side: A bay sailor opposed giving Pilot Thomas the lease after the fuel leak. Wong asked about mitigation. The Port pointed to new tank and pipe systems and to response provisions in the lease.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The committee forwarded the lease to the full Board with a positive recommendation. For: 3 (Sherrill, Fielder, Wong), Against: 0, Absent: 0.
UC Law Tower Gets Mills Act Nod
The basics: The Mills Act gives owners of qualified historic properties a property tax reduction in exchange for rehabilitating them. Contracts run 10 years and renew each year. 100 McAllister is an Article 11 Category 1 landmark building.
Where things stand: Elizabeth Gordon-Jonckheer of the Planning Department cited an estimated $90M rehabilitation cost plus a maintenance plan. The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval Oct. 21.
The property is already tax-exempt under state law. "Right now we have zero valuation," said Robert Spencer of the Assessor-Recorder's Office. Spencer said the applicant wants the contract in case ownership changes to accommodate federal tax credits. He added that costs could reach $270M.
David Seward, Chief Financial Officer, UC Law San Francisco, said the contract supports financing that would pass savings on to student rents. UC Law already has 656 units at 198 McAllister. "This project will add another 75 beds," said Seward.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Raynell Cooper, aide to Supervisor Bilal Mahmood, requested an amendment replacing the Hastings College of the Law name with the school's current name. The amendment and the motion to forward each passed 3-0 (Sherrill, Fielder, Wong).
Neighbors Carry Twin Peaks Land Donation
Where things stand: The Recreation and Park Department would accept four steep, vacant parcels at 1230-1240 Twin Peaks Boulevard from Bill Mandel's Twin Peaks Boulevard LLC. The 0.24-acre site is valued at about $8.3M, and the donation includes a $50,000 grant. A geotechnical analysis found no soil contamination, and the Rec and Park Commission recommended acceptance in September. Staff plan to remove invasive species and plant natives. "It's a minimal addition to our operational load," said Brian Stokel of Recreation and Park.
The other side: Sherrill pressed staff on a long-term vision and the maintenance burden, and those questions remained open. Landscape architect Glenn Rogers raised traffic and slope concerns. He noted a native plant garden would not add traffic the way housing would.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: George Wooding, President, Midtown Terrace, cited a petition signed by more than 525 neighbors. Deborah Murphy, President, Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, also backed the gift. "The thing that has made me comfortable with this is the residents," said Sherrill. "It's not every day that we get a donation like this, so absolutely support it," said Wong. The committee forwarded it 3-0 (Sherrill, Fielder, Wong).
Minor Items
- Nine settlements forwarded 3-0: Items 6-14, seven ordinances and two resolutions, passed as a block without questions; amounts were not stated. One public commenter urged the committee to review why the incidents happened.
Looking Ahead
Forwarded items head to the full Board's Dec. 1 agenda. The self-checkout ordinance returns to committee Dec. 3.