Locunity — where decisions happen.
Ethics Commission Hears Calls to Hold Line on Behested Payment Waivers

Ethics Commission Hears Calls to Hold Line on Behested Payment Waivers

Ethics Commission • San FranciscoNovember 13, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San Francisco's Ethics Commission spent most of its brief Nov. 13, 2026, meeting listening, not acting, as public commenters pressed it on contractor gifts, its complaint process and its oversight reach. A District 3 resident asked commissioners to resist a Board of Supervisors proposal that he said would let supervisors waive their own behested payment rules. With three of five commissioners present, the panel also approved a $200 settlement with a Fine Arts Museums trustee and delayed an official misconduct case to January.

  • Caller urges the commission to oppose waivers in File 250947 on behested payments
  • Contractor gifts and city grants pitched as an audit and enforcement priority
  • Speakers accuse the commission of mishandling complaints and seek social services oversight
  • $200 settlement approved 3-0 with Fine Arts Museums trustee Carl Pascarella

Public Pushes Commission on Contractors, Complaints

Why it matters: The longest stretch of the meeting was public comment. Speakers asked the commission to police how city money flows to contractors and nonprofits, and how the commission treats people who file complaints.

The basics: A behested payment is a payment made at an official's request to a third party, such as a nonprofit. Bo Redfern, a public commenter from District 3, said Proposition E (2022) bars supervisors from soliciting behested payments from city contractors.

Where things stand: Redfern said a pending board measure would undo that protection. "File 250947 would let the board waive those rules for itself," said Redfern. He asked the commission to hold the line on the amended July version of the measure, which carries a June 2029 sunset.

Redfern linked the waiver fight to a series of findings on city-funded groups, and the claims are his. He cited:

  • A September 2025 Controller finding on Human Rights Commission spending
  • A City Attorney finding that grantee Collective Impact gave prohibited gifts to a department head
  • The announced closure of Home Rise
  • A civil grand jury report on oversight of homelessness nonprofit contracts

He urged the commission to make contractor gifts and conflicts of interest in city grants an audit and enforcement priority.

The other side: Two speakers took aim at the commission itself. James Chaffee, a public commenter, said his ethics complaint was dismissed after a long delay in acknowledging it. He described a lawsuit against the city in federal court and alleged the commission blocked his access to public comment and minutes. "Not only is the Ethics Commission a farce, but the Ethics Commission has sent a message that it's a farce," said Chaffee.

A second public commenter, who did not give a name, asked the commission to review how County Adult Assistance Program (CAP) staff handled a case, alleging failures to accommodate disabilities and provide hearing access. "Seems there's a pattern or practice within CAP of ignoring ADA reasonable accommodation requests," the commenter said. The speaker asked that the matter go to another city office if it falls outside the commission's jurisdiction.

The same speaker returned during the Items for Future Meetings segment to raise accountability at the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH). The speaker said he keeps pressing the Human Services Agency and other agencies for data on permanent supportive housing.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioners did not respond to any speaker, which is typical for general public comment. No commissioner proposed a future agenda item. That means neither File 250947 nor the complaint-handling concerns are formally on the commission's calendar. Nonprofits holding city grants, contractors and supervisors are the parties most directly affected if the commission later takes up Redfern's call.

What's next: The commission has not scheduled any action. Residents who want the commission to weigh in on File 250947 can raise it again at the next regular meeting.


Museum Trustee Settles Sunshine Lapses for $200

Why it matters: The case shows how the commission handles low-harm filing and training violations. Its Streamlined Administrative Resolution Program (SARP) is a fast-track settlement process that skips full enforcement proceedings.

Where things stand: Investigator Eric Willett said staff reviewed 2025 Form 700 filings. Form 700 is the statement of economic interests that public officials file each year. That review found that Carl Pascarella, a member of the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco Board of Trustees, failed to complete the annual Sunshine training and file the required declaration form. It also found he acted while disqualified, SFEC Case No. 26-1150.

Willett said Pascarella completed corrective action on time and entered the agreement within the required timeline. Staff found no aggravating factors and "applied the first-tier penalty under SARP, resulting in a total penalty of $200 across 2 counts," said Willett.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Commissioner Kevin Yeh moved to approve the stipulation, decision and order, and Commissioner Karen Bell Francois seconded. Commissioners asked no questions, and no one offered public comment. The motion passed on a roll call: For: 3 (Vice Chair Yaman Salahi, Yeh, Francois), Against: 0.

For appointees on city boards and commissions, the outcome signals that missed training and paperwork can be resolved quickly and cheaply when corrected promptly. It also shows the commission is reviewing Form 700 filings for these lapses.


Minor Items

  • Consent calendar adopted 3-0: The commission approved Sept. 11, 2026, minutes, the Executive Director's report and the quarterly Electronic Disclosure and Data Analysis report. Yeh moved, Francois seconded, and no one discussed the items.
  • Thin quorum: Only Salahi, Yeh and Francois answered roll call, the minimum needed to act.

Looking Ahead

Before roll call, Salahi announced a delay in the William Palmer official misconduct case. "We are continuing item 7, discussion and possible action regarding preliminary matters for official misconduct proceeding in the matter of William Palmer, to our January 2027 meeting," said Vice Chair Salahi. No reason was given, and the commission took no vote on the delay. Official misconduct proceedings can lead to removal from office, so watch for the item's return in January 2027.