

Council Pushes Emergency Aid After Roof Failure Red-Tags 52 O'Keefe Units
City Council • East Palo AltoNovember 18, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
A roof replacement left open before the rain forced the city to red-tag every unit at 430 East O'Keefe, and displaced tenants told the East Palo Alto City Council on Nov. 17, 2026, that the help so far has been thin. No vote was taken, but a four-member council directed City Manager Melvin E. Gaines to reshape Measure JJ contracts for emergency aid and to pursue costs from the parties responsible. The same late-night session adopted the city's environmental justice plan, introduced a 72-hour parking fix and deadlocked on a Planning Commission seat.
- All 52 units red-tagged at 430 East O'Keefe. Council directs staff to speed Measure JJ aid and plan cost recovery.
- Health and Equity Element adopted by voice vote, with rent registry and homeless youth policies added.
- Flood prep: Shelter bedding for about 75 so far as Nov. 24–26 king tides approach.
- No consensus on defining commercial vehicles. LAZ Parking reports about 18,700 citations since April 15.
- 72-hour parking ordinance introduced, barring a return to the same spot for 24 hours.
- Planning Commission seat ties 2–2 and carries to a later meeting.
Roof Failure Exposes Thin Tenant Protections
Why it matters: East Palo Alto's municipal code does not require landlords to pay displaced tenants a per diem, cover transportation or replace belongings. The city must now decide how much of its own money to front while it seeks repayment from the parties responsible.
Where things stand: Staff said a roof replacement permitted in October was left uncovered before rain. "My staff ended up red tagging the building and all 52 units," said Don Jeppson, Chief Building Official.
Tenants disputed the city's account. Edward Simpson, a displaced tenant, called the staff presentation only semi-true. He said reimbursement requires receipts, his apartment is not ready and he has received no per diem.
Esmeralda Abrego said she slept in her car with her 5-year-old after a hotel had no reservation. She said she was told to return home without asbestos documentation and received only $100. Roberto Arias, a leader of the East O'Keefe Tenant Association, cited texts promising $92 a day. He also asked why redevelopment permits get approved while buildings go unrepaired.
Several Woodland Park residents described wider problems. Angelica disputed that tenants could return the next day, citing a neighbor with a pacemaker. Juan Magaña described unanswered maintenance requests and children with asthma. Giovanni Brown urged the council to put teeth into tenant protections, and Luis Rosas called for a rent freeze.
Who pays: "It's an act of negligence," said Councilmember Mark Dinan.
Mayor Webster Lincoln said it "seems kind of misleading that the tenants would have to have renters insurance in order to get their damaged property replaced." He also said, "The person who should be paying is the property owner or the contractor."
Councilmember Carlos Romero questioned why Sand Hill Properties was absent. "I would love to have Sand Hill before us," he said. He pushed colleagues to pursue the company rather than only the contractor: "Stop protecting this bad landlord."
Vice Mayor Ruben Abrica urged that "we declare an emergency, that we release funds immediately." Dinan backed moving Measure JJ money quickly and seeking recovery from the contractor.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No formal vote was taken. Gaines said he has authority to negotiate scope changes with existing Measure JJ providers. "My recommendation would be for this council to give direction," he said, and members gave general direction to proceed. Displaced tenants could get faster aid before any legal recovery. The contractor and property owner face potential cost recovery, and existing Measure JJ providers could see their contracts amended.
What's next: Gaines is to return with contract amendments and a cost-recovery plan. Romero urged reduction-in-services petitions and asked for a report on code changes. Public commenter Sean Ripley asked for a future update with the property owner present.
Environmental Justice Plan Adopted with Late Additions
The basics: The Health and Equity Element is Chapter 7 of the Vista 2035 General Plan. It serves as the city's environmental justice plan under SB 1000. The update identifies five disadvantaged communities using CalEnviroScreen-based mapping.
Why it matters: The element guides city policy on housing conditions, air quality, food access and community engagement.
Where things stand: Consultants from Placeworks and CRC described outreach to hundreds of residents. Dinan pressed for accurate life-expectancy data and a focus on homes. "What we do is we have a real problem with indoor air quality," he said, tying it to asthma rates. A CRC representative said local air is not as clean as assumed, citing PM2.5 and gaps in outdoor monitoring. The representative offered to bring Bay Area agency data to the council.
Romero proposed a rent registry, a review of the private water company's viability and new language on youth. "I'd like to see something in here that specifically addresses homeless youth," he said. Abrica favored a broad plan: "I think it's better to have more potential goals that the city can work on rather than less."
The other side: Lincoln questioned the scope of the water-company proposal and raised a possible conflict of interest. "That's something I'd have to look into," said the City Attorney. Gaines suggested language to "ensure that all East Palo Alto residents have safe and clean drinking water." The water item was ultimately dropped as already covered by Goal HE14.
Public commenter Rovneel welcomed the Willow Woodland designation but urged measurable implementation, timelines and reporting. Rovneel also called displacement at Woodland Park an environmental justice issue. Michael Mashak said residents face environmental hazards they did not choose.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Romero moved and Dinan seconded. The element passed by voice vote; no tally was announced, and Councilmember Martha Barragan was absent. Renters gain a rent-registry policy hook, and homeless youth gain explicit mention. The water company avoids a formal viability review.
Flood Prep Races a King Tide
Why it matters: A strong El Niño and Nov. 24–26 king tides raise flood risk on the west side near San Francisquito Creek. Staff counted about 3,000 parcels in the FEMA 100-year floodplain.
Where things stand: Public Works and the city manager's office reported 8 tons of debris removed, outfalls cleared and creek monitoring underway. Staff also reported 2,000 sandbags at the 150 Tara Road corp yard and 20 staff trained to run a YMCA shelter. The YMCA can hold 600 people for gathering and about 300 overnight.
"What is our capacity for emergency shelter right now at the YMCA?" Dinan asked. "Not 300. We are looking at closer to 75," said Denise Garcia, Assistant to the City Manager, describing bedding on hand.
West-side residents lack a second sandbag station. "We did have several instances of theft of the sandbags," said Hamza Javed, Public Works Director. Abrica proposed working with Sand Hill Properties on secured sandbag storage. He also pledged to recruit volunteers "ready to go anytime, day or night." Lincoln, pressing on alerts, said, "I've lived through the creek overflowing more than once." Members also floated a live phone line.
Community offers: Violet Sayana of CRC said CRC and One Shoreline will offer $1,000 flood supply grants to up to 25 families. She also suggested church parking lots for cars and PG&E medical baseline vouchers. James Hein of the East O'Keefe Tenant Association urged a local emergency declaration for safe parking and fair relocation support. A public commenter asked how residents can volunteer during emergencies.
Parking Fights: No Truck Definition, New 72-Hour Rule
Where things stand: LAZ Parking reported about 18,700 citations since April 15, more than 800 vehicles red-tagged and over 90 tows. "We have red-tagged over 800 vehicles for suspected abandonment," said Edgar Cruz, LAZ's on-site supervisor. The municipal code does not define a commercial vehicle, so enforcement defaults to the state Vehicle Code, which staff called vague. Staff offered three local definitions.
The split: "I think a lot of our streets are being taken advantage of by some businesses who park fleets of vehicles on our streets," Lincoln said. Romero pushed back: "I am very, very leery of expanding this commercial vehicle definition."
Abrica opposed any change: "What I said was keep doing what you're doing." Dinan backed ticketing egregious cases but said, "I think the exclusive focus on street sweeping is kind of a problem."
Public commenter Dylan said a red-tagged car on Cooley sat about three days without a tow. Juan Mendez asked how many citations are actually paid.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "I don't think we're going to come up with a consensus on a definition," Lincoln said, and LAZ will continue enforcing as is. Small-business vehicle owners avoid broader ticketing, while residents seeking parking relief get no change.
The 72-hour fix: Staff recommended a Mountain View-style ordinance with a Lompoc-style 150-foot buffer. Cars parked 72 hours must move and cannot return to the same spot for 24 hours. Owners get a 36-hour warning before a tow. Staff called it "a narrow fix that we hope stays within state law."
"I think as it's currently written, it's unenforceable," Lincoln said of the current rule. Romero said, "I'm not comfortable with the 1,000 feet." That move requirement is already in code. The ordinance was introduced by voice vote with audible ayes from Abrica, Lincoln and Romero. Dinan's vote was not audible, and Barragan was absent. No adoption date was set.
Planning Commission Seat Stuck at 2–2
Where things stand: Ballots for a vacant regular seat split evenly. Romero and one other member voted for Luis Rosas, who earlier urged ending the Flock camera contract during public comment. Lincoln and Dinan voted for alternate Isabel Ismael. The code requires three votes, so the seat stays empty. During interviews, Romero framed the choice around displacement, warning about failing to recognize that "this community is being gentrified out."
"It's called a stalemate, then we can bring this back up when there are 5 council members present," Gaines said. Lincoln proposed Dec. 1 for all applicants.
Related: The council let Planning Commission approvals of the West Bayshore-Newell and O'Keefe-Manhattan projects stand. Lincoln had sought to pull both reviews "because the applicant is not interested in appealing the decision from the Planning Commission." Abrica objected: "I don't think we should remove them from the agenda." The agenda stayed intact, but both items were skipped without objection.
Minor Items
- Consent calendar: Approved an on-call economic development contract with Good City Company capped at $500,000, an $80,000 GIS assessment with Geographic Technologies Group, a work plan update dropping a centralized grants project, and the Nov. 10 minutes.
- Corp yard lease: Extended after Romero questioned financing roof repairs at 5.5% interest; staff said paying upfront would save roughly $1,000.
- Public comment: Street vendors losing their St. Francis of Assisi Parish site asked where to sell, and Rosas urged ending the roughly $500,000 Flock contract, citing ICE detentions.
- Ethics requests: Commenters sought an investigation of Dinan's ex parte contacts, and Romero asked to agendize his allegations and the mayor's city seal use; Lincoln referred both to the mayor–vice mayor meeting.
- Library: San Mateo County Libraries reported 1.8 million visits systemwide, and members praised the new Measure O-funded library, expected to be two to three times the current space.
Looking Ahead
Performance evaluations for the city manager and city attorney were continued because of the late hour. Gaines said Dec. 1 "could potentially work" and that he would confirm, with a special meeting also floated.