Locunity — where decisions happen.
East Bay MUD Approves 5% Manager Pay Adjustments Over Union Objections

East Bay MUD Approves 5% Manager Pay Adjustments Over Union Objections

Board of Directors • East Bay Municipal Utility DistrictNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

East Bay MUD's Board of Directors approved 5% equity adjustments for four management classifications after two unions said managers are held to a lighter standard than rank-and-file workers. The vote was 6-0, with Director April Chan abstaining. The board also ratified an emergency at Pardee Reservoir and heard how the district would handle requests to serve water-hungry data centers.


  • 5% equity adjustments for four management jobs pass 6-0-1 over Local 444 and Local 2019 objections
  • New Manager of Distribution Services role consolidates three manager posts, 7-0
  • Pardee spillway emergency ratified 7-0; debris removal could start as soon as Monday
  • Data center briefing: no new applications in seven years; Richmond and Oakland have moratoriums
  • Customer survey: 75% rate the district good or excellent as affordability worries grow

Pay Equity Fight: Unions Question a Double Standard

The basics: An equity adjustment raises the pay grade of a job classification to correct a misalignment. It is separate from negotiated across-the-board raises.

Why it matters: The dollar cost is small, about $4,900 per month. The dispute is about trust. Union leaders argued the district applies equity standards differently to management than to represented employees.

Where things stand: Item 14 raised pay for four non-represented management classifications. They include the managers of Facilities Maintenance and Construction, Fisheries and Wildlife, and Laboratory and Technical Services. General Manager Chan said the evaluation began alongside union contract negotiations. In February, the board asked staff to wait until union adjustments were finished.

Senior management recommended 40 of more than 70 management classifications for adjustments. Staff brought forward only four. On the union side, staff cited 42 requests covering 698 employees, with adjustments approved for 150.

“The same 4 criteria that we use for the unions, we use for the managers,” said General Manager Chan.

The other side: Kevin Omdahl, First Vice President of Local 444, asked why managers would get 5% when Raker B employees were denied a 2.5% adjustment. He cited records obtained through a public records request and asked the board to postpone action and apply consistent standards.

Justin Young, President of Local 2019, walked through the justification process unions must follow. He noted that equity adjustments were moved out of negotiations and recommended the board not adopt the item.

The opening round: The fight began one item earlier. Item 13 created a Manager of Distribution Services classification. It merges Pipeline Construction, Pipeline Maintenance and Maintenance Support management functions after a July reorganization of Maintenance and Construction.

Michael Morgan, Chief Steward of Local 444, did not oppose the merger. He noted the resolution lists step 88, while union records show step 86, and asked whether an equity adjustment was involved. Local 2019's Justin Young backed the new classification but objected to the 5% increase. General Manager Chan said the move from step 86 to step 88 is a 5% increase, evaluated under the same four criteria.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts:
- Item 13 was moved by Director Marguerite Young and seconded by Director April Chan.
- For: 7 (Gómez, Katz, Chan, Smith, Young, Lewis, Odeh). Against: 0. Absent: 0.
- Item 14 was moved by Director Marguerite Young and seconded by Board President Luz Gómez.
- For: 6 (Gómez, Katz, Smith, Young, Lewis, Odeh). Against: 0. Abstain: 1 (Chan). Absent: 0.

Managers in the four classifications gain. Union members, especially Raker B employees, see their denied request as evidence of uneven treatment. Ratepayers absorb a modest added cost.

What's next: No follow-up action was scheduled. Labor watchers may want to ask whether any of the other 36 management classifications that senior management recommended will return to the board.


Data Centers: The District Gets Ahead of the Question

Why it matters: Neighboring cities are already restricting data centers. Directors made clear that existing ratepayers should not pay for infrastructure built to serve them.

Where things stand: Alice Tuohy, Director of Water and Natural Resources, put the local picture plainly: “East Bay MUD has not received an application for a new data center in 7 years.”

Tuohy cited a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory estimate for U.S. AI data centers:
- About 48 million gallons per day of direct water use
- About 578 million gallons per day of indirect use

She noted that Richmond and Oakland have moratoriums on data centers. Recycled water is often suggested as an alternative, but she said the district's recycled water systems are mostly built for irrigation, can be interrupted and may be corrosive.

Tuohy also summarized three state bills on water supply planning for these projects: AB 2469, AB 2619 and SB 1085, which the district sponsored.

Directors' questions:
- “Are there any potential customer price cost impacts as people decide to pursue this?” asked Director Lewis. Staff said new development pays for any needed extensions, and AB 2469 includes a full-cost principle.
- Director Marguerite Young asked how hydropower and other indirect water use are counted in the estimates.
- “I understand that there's PFAS discharge from data centers,” said Director Andy Katz. PFAS are long-lasting synthetic "forever chemicals." Staff did not have an answer and said they would research the issue.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The item was informational, so no vote was taken. The discussion signals that the board wants any future data center to cover its full cost of service. That position protects residential ratepayers and puts the burden on developers.

What's next: Staff will research PFAS discharge and report back to the board.


Pardee Emergency: Clearing Debris Before El Niño

Why it matters: Debris built up below the Pardee Reservoir spillway outfall could cause water to back up and flood the Pardee Powerhouse during forecast El Niño storms. An emergency declaration speeds up permitting.

Where things stand: General Manager Chan said the emergency was declared Oct. 29, together with the board president, following a declaration by the governor. Roberto Cortez, Manager of Water Operations, said the work is preventive.

“There's nothing wrong with the Pardee Dam, there's nothing wrong with Pardee Powerhouse, there's nothing wrong with the spillway,” said Cortez.

Cortez pointed to two past high-flow events:
- 1986: about 35,000 cubic yards of material were removed.
- 1997: flows exceeded 26,000 cubic feet per second.

Contractors estimated about three weeks of work, starting as soon as Monday.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Items 15.1–15.3 declared the emergency, ratified it and authorized spending "as needed." No specific dollar cap was stated. The motion was moved by Director Odeh and seconded by Director Lewis.
- For: 7. Against: 0. Absent: 0.

No one spoke during public comment.


Survey: High Trust, Rising Bill Anxiety

Why it matters: The results will shape how the district talks to customers about rates and earthquake preparedness.

Where things stand: Adam Przybylski of Przybylski Research surveyed 1,200 respondents across multiple channels and languages. Key findings:
- 75% rate the district's performance excellent or good.
- 82% rate their tap water excellent or good.
- 87% agree the district delivers reliable, safe water.
- 57% trust the district.

Affordability is the weak spot. Without context, 52% said their bills are too high. Answers shifted when respondents learned that water costs about 2 cents a gallon. Messages about earthquakes strongly motivated people to store emergency water.

Separately, staff reported that water sales are down 2.6% year to date, though revenue is roughly on budget.

What's next: Directors asked for results broken down by geography and by director district. Staff said they would provide them.


Minor Items

  • Litigation authorized: In closed session, all seven directors voted to have the general counsel file a lawsuit in one matter. “All directors voted by roll call to authorize the general counsel to initiate the litigation,” said Board President Luz Gómez. The parties and details will be disclosed on request once the case is filed.
  • Wastewater treatment turns 75: A commemorative resolution passed 7-0. The plant serves over 740,000 customers in nine cities, and a Sept. 26 open house drew more than 800 visitors.
  • Native American Heritage Month: “This year marks the first time that East Bay MUD's Board of Directors is formally recognizing Native American History Month,” said Gómez. Employee Gary Walters II thanked the board for the recognition.
  • Awards and veterans: The district won its 21st straight financial reporting award from the Government Finance Officers Association. Staff also honored about 80 employees who have self-identified as veterans.
  • Comanche Trails: The Planning Committee recommended continuing the study of allowing bikes on the trails, with a focus on regular bikes rather than e-bikes.

Looking Ahead

The district will hold a Native American Heritage Month event in the boardroom on Nov. 18. Debris removal at Pardee could begin as soon as Monday. Staff still owe the board survey breakdowns by district and research on PFAS discharge from data centers.