

Wild Europe Director Targets Forest Bioenergy Subsidies at COP31 Side Event
COP 31 Side Events • United NationsNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
A European conservation leader told a COP31 side event on Nov. 19, 2026, that burning forests for energy is a costly, high-emitting bet that taxpayers are underwriting. The panel, "Breathing Through Fire: Boreal Forests, Permafrost Methane, and the Climate-Health Nexus," took no formal action. Instead, speakers made the case that boreal wildfires, permafrost thaw and public health are one problem, not three.
- Wild Europe's Toby Aykroyd urges ending forest bioenergy subsidies and conserving primary forests
- Carbon markets draw skepticism from audience questioners and panelists alike
- EcoAccord proposes three COP31 priorities tying wildfire smoke and permafrost thaw to health
- Fire strips permafrost's insulating layer, but methane outcomes vary, Andrei Laletin says
- Armenia's forests face illegal logging and an inventory dating to 1994
The Bioenergy Bill Lands on Taxpayers
The basics: BECCS, or bioenergy with carbon capture and storage, generates power from biomass such as wood and aims to capture and store the resulting carbon dioxide.
Why it matters: Toby Aykroyd, Director, Wild Europe, argued that forest industries contribute little to GDP while their costs fall on taxpayers. That framing turns forestry's usual economic case on its head.
Where things stand: Aykroyd walked through climate impacts, wildfire costs and declines in national carbon sinks in Sweden and Finland. He called forest bioenergy paired with BECCS both costly and high-emitting.
He laid out six actions. Two were central: ending bioenergy subsidies and conserving primary forests. He also urged protection of old-growth forests.
His alternative is to make standing forests pay. "There is a need to monetize non-extractive ecosystem services," said Aykroyd. Non-extractive services are the value forests provide without being cut down.
The other side: The tension surfaced in the room itself. Audience members pressed the panel on carbon markets, and Aykroyd cautioned against relying on offsets. That raises an open question for his own proposal: how forests can be monetized without the market pitfalls he warned about.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken; the session was informational. His agenda would hit subsidized forest-bioenergy operators and the forest industries he says shift costs to the public. Conservation groups and taxpayers would gain from it.
What's next: No follow-up action was announced. His six-point list is an advocacy position, not a negotiated text.
Skepticism Over Carbon Markets
Why it matters: The Q&A showed that forest advocates are wary of carbon markets. Their concern is who controls forests and who gets locked out of them.
Where things stand: Kwame, of the Global Forest Coalition, asked how carbon markets affect forests. He argued that living forests are better than privatized projects.
Caroline, of Econac in Kenya, asked about African alliances on wildfires. She also raised concerns about what carbon markets mean for forested communities.
Kwame returned with a sharper question. He asked for examples of how communities use forest medicine and how carbon projects could block that access.
The other side: Responses were mixed in tone. Aykroyd cautioned on offsets. A Russian panelist described a blunt reality in Russia's fire policy: fires burning far from settlements are left to burn. Responses also pointed to the loss of Indigenous forest medicine knowledge.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken. Indigenous and forest-dependent communities have the most at stake, since panelists flagged their knowledge and access as at risk. Carbon-project developers face growing scrutiny from civil-society groups like those in the room.
What's next: No formal follow-up on an African wildfire alliance was announced.
Smoke Crosses Borders, and So Does Harm
Why it matters: Transboundary wildfire smoke is estimated to cause premature deaths far from where fires burn. That makes boreal wildfire a global public health issue, not a regional land-management one.
Where things stand: Olga Ponizova, Director, EcoAccord, built her case on concrete episodes and pathways:
- The 2010 Moscow smoke episode
- Respiratory impacts on children
- Methylmercury released into the environment
- Pathogens and thawing waste sites as permafrost degrades
- Long-range smoke deaths as far away as China
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: She proposed three COP31 recommendations:
- Bridge the forest and health agendas
- Embed smoke and permafrost risk in national adaptation plans
- Share data regionally
Public health agencies and communities downwind of fire regions stand to benefit most if adaptation planning absorbs these risks. Governments would bear new planning and data-sharing obligations.
What's next: The recommendations are aimed at the COP31 process. No timeline or sponsoring delegation was identified.
Fire Speeds the Thaw
Why it matters: Methane is a potent short-term greenhouse gas. The feedback between fire, thaw and emissions remains uncertain in climate models.
Where things stand: Andrei Laletin, Membership Coordinator, Global Forest Coalition, also with Friends of the Siberian Forests, described boreal forests in Siberia and Russia's Far East that sit on permafrost. Fires strip away the moss and organic layers that insulate frozen ground, which deepens the thaw.
He added an important caveat: thaw does not automatically raise methane. Outcomes depend on moisture, oxygen and vegetation.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Laletin called for integrated monitoring, greater use of satellite data and refined models. Climate scientists and modelers are the immediate audience. Policymakers relying on emissions projections inherit the uncertainty in the meantime.
Armenia's Thin Green Line
Why it matters: Armenia's forest cover target was described as unrealistic given gaps in enforcement.
Where things stand: Nazeli, Director, Armenian Forests, said forest cover has fallen to about 6% to 8%. She cited weak governance, fuelwood demand driven by poverty, and illegal logging. The country's forest inventory dates to 1994.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Her priorities included:
- A new national inventory
- Enforcement of the forest code
- Fire prevention
- Natural regeneration and monitoring
- Community participation
Rural households that rely on fuelwood are caught between energy needs and forest protection. Stricter enforcement without alternatives would weigh on them most.
Looking Ahead
The panel produced recommendations, not decisions. The moderator closed with a call to action aimed squarely at the negotiating halls: "We really have to make a political issue out of this," said the moderator.