

CIDCE Pitches Legal Indicators to Test Whether Climate Laws Work
COP 31 Side Events • United NationsNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Governments have adopted many climate and environmental laws, but no one systematically measures whether those laws are actually implemented. At a Nov. 19, 2026, COP 31 side event hosted by the Reevaluation Foundation and CIDCE, legal scholars proposed a fix: legal indicators that score states on implementation. CIDCE also said it plans a voluntary study of these indicators for the next COP in Addis Ababa.
- No legal indicators exist among the hundreds of environmental metrics UN bodies track, CIDCE argues
- Six families of criteria form the backbone of CIDCE's proposed scoring method
- Study planned for Addis Ababa would test legal indicators against the 59 Belém adaptation indicators
- Shipping emissions as a test case: the IMO Net Zero Framework is still not binding
- Audience pushes back on differentiation for developing countries, vague laws and responsibility
A Missing Yardstick: Measuring Law, Not Just Outcomes
Michel Prieur, Professor Emeritus, University of Limoges, and President, CIDCE, opened the substantive presentations. He argued that the international system measures environmental results but ignores the legal machinery meant to deliver them.
The basics: Prieur separated effectiveness, meaning real-world results, from effectivity, meaning the legal process of implementing a law. Today, he said, only scientific and economic indicators exist.
Why it matters: Without legal metrics, an implementation gap can show up in emissions or biodiversity data without any explanation of why. Legal indicators would show whether a law exists, whether it is enforced and where it breaks down.
Where things stand: Prieur traced institutional support for the idea through the UN Environment Programme (UNEP), the Escazú Convention, the Barcelona Convention and IUCN Resolution 50, which he said 83 states backed. He blamed the gap partly on who builds the UN's metrics. The UN's statistical work is driven by "only specialists of statistics. And they ignore law," said Prieur.
How the method works: CIDCE's approach uses a questionnaire. Answers are scored across six families of criteria, including some non-legal ones. The goal is to turn a qualitative question, whether a country is implementing its law, into comparable data.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was taken at the side event. If the method is adopted, national governments would face a new form of scrutiny, and ministries would be scored on legal follow-through rather than on pledges alone. Advocates and courts could gain a standardized evidence base. Statistical agencies would need legal expertise they currently lack, by Prieur's account.
Adaptation Targets Meet Legal Scrutiny
Laurent Vassalo, Professor of Law, Montpellier University, and Administrator, CIDCE, connected the proposal to the Paris Agreement's Global Goal on Adaptation. He focused on the 59 voluntary adaptation indicators linked to Belém.
Why it matters: Adaptation plans often lack funding or public participation. Legal indicators could show whether adaptation commitments are actually carried out or stay on paper.
Where things stand: Vassalo proposed testing legal indicators in specific sectors: adaptation planning, health care facilities and infrastructure. He drew on examples from France. Hospitals are a pointed choice, because they are the facilities communities rely on most when climate shocks hit.
What's next: Vassalo said CIDCE wants to produce a study on these indicators and present it at the next COP in Addis Ababa. The study is voluntary. It is CIDCE's attempt to add a legal layer to adaptation tracking, not a negotiated mandate.
From Climate Justice to the High Seas
Two presenters applied the framework to harder cases.
Julien Prieur, Legal Expert and Trainer, CIDCE, addressed unequal historical emissions, loss and damage, and the protection of Indigenous peoples. He argued that legal indicators could measure climate justice itself, beyond technical compliance.
Lucy Brower, Professor, International Trade Schema Business School, walked through all six indicator families using maritime transport as the example. She cited Articles 192, 194 and 217 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), along with MARPOL Annex VI, the international rules on air pollution from ships.
Why it matters: Shipping shows the gap between proposals and enforceable law. Brower pointed to the delayed International Maritime Organization (IMO) Net Zero Framework. Brower said the framework "has therefore not yet become binding international law."
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Under Brower's approach, flag and coastal states would be scored on whether they turn treaty duties into domestic enforcement. The shipping sector would face a clearer record of which governments regulate it and which do not. For communities facing loss and damage, Julien Prieur's framing could give a measurable basis for claims that now rest mostly on moral arguments.
Audience Tests the Method's Limits
The question-and-answer session raised the toughest objections of the day.
The other side: An audience member, a PhD student from China, asked how uniform legal indicators would handle differentiated standards for developing countries. Gabriela Merla, Partner, CMS Francis Lefebvre, asked whether indicators should target nationally determined contributions (NDCs) and national laws rather than the Paris Agreement. She also asked how the method handles programmatic laws, meaning statutes that set goals without concrete obligations. Another audience member asked how scientific and social indicators relate to legal ones. Merla later raised how to allocate proportional responsibility for historical emissions, and noted how difficult it is to access climate justice.
Where things stand: Panelists said the tools adapt to each country's national regulations. Answers to the legal questions are scored in binary terms. For programmatic laws, scoring turns on whether the legal provision exists. On responsibility, panelists said it rests with states. They argued that legal indicators can reveal whether a law is merely performative.
Why it matters: The differentiation question goes to the heart of climate diplomacy. Any scoring system seen as penalizing developing countries would face resistance in UN negotiations.
Looking Ahead
CIDCE plans to bring a voluntary study on legal indicators for adaptation to the next COP in Addis Ababa. Watch whether any states or UN bodies sign on to test the methodology before then.