

EU Insists CBAM Is No Tax as Verification, Fairness Questions Mount
COP 31 Side Events • United NationsNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Europe's carbon border adjustment mechanism, or CBAM, is now in its definitive phase, and the European Commission used a COP 31 side event on Nov. 17, 2026, to defend it as climate policy rather than a trade tool. The panel took no votes. Instead, it showed where the pressure is: verifier shortages, data burdens for importers, and whether poorer countries end up paying for Europe's decarbonization.
- Commission rejects the "tax" label, calling CBAM an environmental measure that regulates goods, not countries
- Verifier shortages are the top business concern as the 2027 certificate deadline approaches
- Developing-country fairness splits the panel, with the Commission citing a 0.01% impact on least developed countries
- No subnational default values, and Scope 2 stays limited to fertilizers and cement for now
- Co-hosts tout a carbon pricing "flywheel," saying 11 other countries are considering border mechanisms
Commission Defends CBAM, Concedes Rollout Strains
The basics: CBAM puts a carbon price on certain imports entering the European Union, matching the cost that EU producers pay under the bloc's Emissions Trading System. "Default values" are standard emissions figures used when importers lack verified data from their suppliers.
Why it matters: Verification capacity and default values will largely determine what importers pay to comply. That cost flows to foreign producers, EU buyers, and the trading partners deciding whether to build their own carbon prices.
Where things stand: Maria Elena Scoppio, Director, European Commission, DG TAXUD, said the definitive phase began in 2026 and that certificates are due in 2027. She named verifier shortages as businesses' main concern.
Scoppio walked through how CBAM handles default values and how it recognizes carbon prices already paid in exporting countries. She also pointed to changes made in trilogue, the EU's three-way negotiation among the Commission, Parliament and Council, that would allow mutual recognition of verifiers. That change could ease the bottleneck if outside verifiers can be accepted.
When panelists pressed on how CBAM is characterized, Scoppio was direct. "It's not a tax. A tax is something else. This is an environmental measure," said Scoppio.
The industry view: A Baker Hughes representative said the company is in full compliance. The representative urged "measure once, report many" interoperability, meaning a single set of emissions data accepted across multiple regimes. The company also asked for simplified treatment of low-value goods.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The panel took no action. Its signals still matter for importers. Large firms such as Baker Hughes say they can comply, but they want less duplicate reporting. Exporters in countries without accredited verifiers face the most immediate risk. The Commission's openness to mutual recognition of verifiers is the clearest sign of possible relief.
What's next: CBAM certificates come due in 2027. Watch whether the trilogue changes on verifier recognition take effect before then.
Fairness Fight: Who Pays for Europe's Border Carbon Price?
Why it matters: Concerns about least developed countries, or LDCs, and pressure to extend CBAM to downstream products could shape the next round of revisions. Both issues determine whether the mechanism is seen as climate policy or protectionism.
Where things stand: Faizal Ismail, co-chair, Integrated Forum on Climate Change and Trade, raised three critiques. He questioned the lack of differentiation for developing countries, the unilateral way the EU designed the measure, and how CBAM revenue is used.
Scoppio replied that CBAM regulates goods, not countries. She cited analysis by the Joint Research Centre, the Commission's in-house science service, and said the measure's impact on LDCs is 0.01%.
Katherine Wolfram, one of the event's co-host presenters, offered a different defense. She argued that green premiums paid by European consumers benefit exporters in countries such as Mozambique.
The other side: Cecilia Trazi, program lead, ECCO, an Italian climate think tank, asked what the ideal is for developing countries. She laid out three options: no CBAM, an undifferentiated CBAM, or a more granular version that counts electricity emissions.
Other audience members asked about Scope 2 emissions, which are indirect emissions from purchased electricity. They also asked about subnational default values and the burden on downstream products. Scoppio said default values are set only at the national level. She said Scope 2 covers only fertilizers and cement for now.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Nothing changed, but the answers carry weight for exporters. Producers in regions with cleaner grids than their national average gain nothing from a national-only default value. Fertilizer and cement makers remain the only sectors where electricity emissions count. Developing-country governments heard the Commission hold firm on its framing, though questions about revenue use and differentiation went unresolved.
What's next: Watch for any Commission move on downstream products or broader Scope 2 coverage. Both would widen the set of exporters affected.
Co-Hosts Pitch a Carbon Pricing 'Flywheel'
Why it matters: Presenters said the Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets has 13 members covering almost half of global emissions. If border adjustments spread, more exporters will face carbon costs regardless of where they sell.
Where things stand: The event opened with Billy Pizer, president, Resources for the Future, and was moderated by Milan Elkerbout. Wolfram described a virtuous circle in which carbon pricing leads to border adjustments, which in turn prompt trading partners to price carbon. She cited Turkey and China and said 11 other countries are considering border mechanisms.
"The ideal carbon border adjustment mechanism is one you never have to enforce because every country has adopted carbon pricing," said Wolfram.
Frank Jotzo, a co-host presenter, said border adjustments should encourage new green investment. He also argued they should help energy-intensive industry relocate closer to cheap renewable power.
The other side: Mihnea Cătuți, a co-host presenter, said Europe cannot decarbonize alone and needs trade. He also flagged practical problems with verifier accreditation and steel quotas, echoing the implementation concerns the Commission later acknowledged.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The co-hosts framed CBAM as a lever for global climate policy rather than a wall around Europe. Countries with abundant renewables stand to gain under Jotzo's view. Heavy industry in Europe faces pressure to rely on cleaner imported inputs. Steel importers face the most immediate friction.
Looking Ahead
The next hard date is 2027, when CBAM certificates come due. The open questions for importers and trading partners are the same ones raised on this panel: how verifiers are accredited, whether default values become more granular, and whether CBAM's scope expands downstream.