Locunity — where decisions happen.
Researchers Say First Global Stocktake Diluted Science, Urge Fixes for GST2

Researchers Say First Global Stocktake Diluted Science, Urge Fixes for GST2

COP 31 Side Events • United NationsNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

A research panel at a COP31 side event on Nov. 17, 2026, argued that the climate science feeding the first Global Stocktake was watered down before it reached the final political text, with language on waste, transport, equity and fossil fuels shrinking along the way. No formal action was taken. Presenters instead offered design fixes for GST2, the second stocktake launched at COP31, while a pointed audience debate over the IPCC's report timeline showed how unsettled the science-to-policy pipeline remains.


  • GST-1 lost key mitigation messages between technical dialogue and the political outcome, a keyword analysis found
  • Recommendations for GST2: more political-phase time, wider sharing of findings and a list of urgent issues
  • Unresolved IPCC AR7 timeline splits researchers over whether science will reach GST2 on schedule
  • Malaysian cities anchor low-carbon blueprints in statutory plans, offering a local implementation model
  • UK's richest emit 2.7 times more than poorest, an early Tyndall Centre finding shows

What Got Lost on the Way to the Deal

The basics: The Global Stocktake (GST) is the Paris Agreement's periodic check on collective climate progress. It runs in two phases: a technical dialogue that gathers evidence, then a political phase where negotiators agree on outcome text.

Why it matters: Presenters said the evidence was weakened between those two phases. Without changes, GST2 could repeat that pattern, and the gap would carry through to the national and local climate plans that follow from the stocktake.

Where things stand: Oliver Herrera, a researcher at Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, counted keywords across the technical dialogue documents and the final GST-1 outcome. Waste disappeared from the text entirely. References to equity and ambition dropped, and nuclear appeared in the outcome. More broadly, presenters said language on waste, transport and equity was diluted between the two stages, along with the specifics on fossil fuels.

Herrera's recommendations were procedural rather than ideological:
1. Give negotiators more time in the political phase.
2. Disseminate technical findings more widely.
3. Produce a list of urgent issues for negotiators to address.

A second panelist took the analysis forward in time. That presenter mapped about 1,600 paragraphs of later decisions against the GST outcome, tracking whether stocktake findings actually shaped subsequent negotiations through COP28, COP29 and COP30.

The other side: No panelist defended the GST-1 text. In Q&A, Wolfgang Obergassel of the Wuppertal Institute pressed on the practical questions. He asked who could realistically track technical findings through the process, and whether feasibility is considered when recommendations are drafted.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The session took no formal action. The findings point at process design, specifically time allocation and tracking. That puts responsibility on negotiators and the UNFCCC secretariat more than on scientists. Researchers and civil society groups who invest in the technical phase have the most to gain if political-phase dilution is curbed.

What's next: GST2 is now underway. Whether its political phase gets more time or a formal urgent-issues list was not settled at this session.


Fight Over the IPCC Clock

Why it matters: The IPCC's Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) is meant to be a core scientific input to GST2. If its working group reports arrive late, the political phase could proceed without the latest science.

Where things stand: Bart Verheggen, acting IPCC focal point for the Netherlands at the Dutch Meteorological Institute, urged that the AR7 working group reports be completed in time to inform GST2's political phase. "There's still no agreement on the timeline of AR7," said Verheggen.

The other side: Others questioned whether racing to the GST deadline serves all countries equally. Gautam, a researcher from India, said IPCC working groups carry normative assumptions and that the debate can seem racist. He warned that reviewer capacity in developing countries is already strained. "Because we are limited, and that is for the country of the size of India," said Gautam.

Gaurav Garg of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research also raised concerns about normative assumptions and the burden on developing-country reviewers. Another panelist cited a past Inter-Academy Council recommendation against aligning IPCC and UNFCCC timelines. That recommendation cuts against the push to sync AR7 with GST2. Yingying Zhen asked a broader question about the limits of science in the stocktake.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The exchange exposed a real split. Delivering on time favors a science-informed GST2. A slower pace favors fuller participation from Global South reviewers. Developing-country scientists bear the capacity strain either way. No resolution emerged.

What's next: The AR7 timeline remains unagreed. Watch for IPCC decisions on working group schedules ahead of GST2's political phase.


Malaysia's Model: Put the Plan in the Zoning

Why it matters: Presenters offered the Malaysian approach as a replicable way to turn global stocktake findings into street-level implementation. That is where most emissions decisions are actually made, through land use, transit and building rules.

Where things stand: Presenters from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia described two practices:
1. Embedding policymakers directly in research teams, so officials help shape the work rather than just receive it.
2. Anchoring low-carbon blueprints in statutory planning, meaning the plans for Iskandar Malaysia and Kuala Lumpur were written into the legally binding planning framework rather than left as voluntary documents.

The presenters said co-benefits drove local buy-in. Clean air, transit equity and green jobs proved more persuasive than emissions targets alone. They also suggested that city-level measurement, reporting and verification (MRV) could feed into nationally determined contributions (NDCs), the national climate pledges under the Paris Agreement. That would link neighborhood data to national commitments.

The other side: Audience questions focused on replicability. One attendee asked what equity tools exist for municipalities. Obergassel asked how the policymakers came to join the research team.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: For city planners and local officials, the takeaway is structural. Statutory anchoring gives climate plans staying power beyond a single political term. Residents gain through cleaner air and transit access. National governments gain verified subnational data for their NDCs.

What's next: Presenters framed the model as a possible input to GST2's focus on locally grounded implementation.


Wealthy Nations, Wealthy Consumers

Why it matters: Two Tyndall Centre researchers argued that the lead mitigation lever sits with developed countries. They pointed specifically to wealthy consumers and to policies that still expand fossil fuel supply.

Where things stand: Alice Larkin of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research reviewed 25 years of UK energy scenarios. She said those scenarios overstated both future energy demand and the role of carbon capture, even as the UK continues to approve new oil and gas. Her conclusion was that wealthy nations must move faster and that demand reduction needs more emphasis.

Garg introduced "From Net Zero to Fair Zero," a project mapping discretionary emissions in developed countries. Its early finding is that the richest emit 2.7 times more than the poorest. Garg said he expects that gap to rise once aviation data is added. The project is seeking partners for an emergency plan for the UK.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The research shifts attention from aggregate national targets to who is emitting within a country. High-income consumers and frequent flyers face the most scrutiny. Lower-income households stand to benefit from a fairness-based framing.

What's next: Garg's team is recruiting partners for the UK emergency plan. Aviation data is still to be incorporated.


Minor Items

  • Niklas Wagner, postdoctoral researcher at the University of Geneva, chaired the session and presented on visa, linguistic and epistemic exclusion in GST-1.
  • The session was split into two blocks: GST-1 lessons, then equitable, locally grounded GST2 design and open discussion.

Looking Ahead

GST2 is now in motion. The open questions from this session are whether negotiators give the political phase more time, whether AR7's timeline gets settled, and whether city-level models like Malaysia's feed into the process.

Researchers Say First Global Stocktake Diluted Science, Urge Fixes for GST2 | COP 31 Side Events | Locunity