

Contra Costa Supervisors Strengthen ICE Policy but Stop Short of Ordinance
Board of Supervisors • Contra Costa CountyNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Contra Costa County supervisors spent nearly four hours on Nov. 17, 2026, debating how far the county can go to keep federal immigration agents off its property. They unanimously adopted Resolution 2026-427 with a slate of tougher amendments, but kept it a policy rather than the binding ordinance that dozens of advocates demanded. The board also authorized subpoenas against its own elected Assessor and approved 46 new benefits-eligibility jobs on one-time money.
- Immigration policy adopted unanimously with added contractor remedies, state-law "staging" definitions and Sheriff reporting
- About 30 in-person speakers and many Zoom callers pressed for an ordinance; the board kept a policy
- Subpoenas authorized for Assessor Gus Kramer and his staff after auditors say records were withheld
- $4.47M in one-time revenue funds 46 new eligibility positions as federal HR 1 rules strain CalFresh and Medi-Cal
Board Adopts SB 580 Immigration Policy With New Teeth
Why it matters: Senate Bill 580 requires local agencies to adopt the California attorney general's model immigration policies, or their equivalent, by Jan. 1, 2027. Contra Costa now has rules covering how ICE can access county facilities, records and property.
"By January 1st, 2027, state and local agencies are required to adopt these model policies or their equivalent," said Kendra Carr, Co-Director, Office of Racial Equity and Social Justice.
Where things stand: Staff described a yearlong process that began in August 2025. The policy covers:
- ICE access to county facilities and records
- Designated staff and protection of sensitive information
- Access to services regardless of immigration status
- A ban on using county property for staging, processing or an operational base
Under Section 13, County Counsel said, future contracts, renewals and amendments involving sensitive information will require written data-use agreements.
The parking-lot problem: The sharpest debate centered on enforcement. ICE vehicles near the Martinez jail and courthouse had prompted a letter from the presiding judge. Supervisor John Gioia, District 1, read the letter and asked who would interpret and enforce the staging ban. County Counsel said ICE may lawfully park in individual public spaces and that the Sheriff enforces county lots. He noted that Santa Clara County closed a jail lot with barriers.
Supervisor Ken Carlson, District 4, argued that an unmarked car with no plates, blacked-out windows and four occupants who never enter a county building makes its purpose "pretty self-evident." Supervisor Candace Andersen, District 2, urged caution.
"But we also don't want to create false expectations of safety," said Andersen.
The Assistant Sheriff said deputies had asked ICE agents to leave reserved spots and would enforce lots as they do for the public. Asked about suspected tips to ICE on jail releases, he said booking fingerprints go to the state Department of Justice, which federal agencies can access.
"We do not communicate with ICE outside the guardrails of SB 54," said Assistant Sheriff Beltran, Contra Costa County Sheriff's Office.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Carlson moved and Supervisor Shanelle Scales-Preston, District 5, seconded a package of amendments:
- "Staging" definition drawn from AB 1807, plus Alameda County's processing-location and operation-base language
- Physical barriers, coordinated with the County Administrator
- Contractor remedies, including termination and breach of contract
- Policy changes allowed only by majority board vote
- The Sheriff's existing quarterly reporting, written into the policy
- Resources posted on the county website
The board also directed staff to explore locked lots, cameras and signage, draft a cease-and-desist letter to DHS and ICE, and refer remaining issues to the Equity Committee. Board Chair Diane Burgis declared the motion passed unanimously on a voice vote. Individual votes were not called.
"I know we have said it a million times, but ICE is not welcome here," said Scales-Preston.
What's next: Implementation work remains on training, designated personnel, facility protocols, signage and compliance. Follow-up will run through the Equity Committee.
Advocates Push for Ordinance, Board Holds Line
Why it matters: A broad coalition of food, faith, civic and legal groups argued the draft was weaker than earlier versions. They kept pressure on a board that voted 3-2 in September to pursue a policy rather than an ordinance.
Where things stand: Speakers came from:
- Brian Espinoza, Food Bank of Contra Costa and Solano, who said fear keeps families from food and CalFresh
- Rabbi Aaron Torop, Temple Isaiah, and Rev. Dr. Rodney Limmery, Mount Diablo UU Church
- Joni Grassi, League of Women Voters Diablo Valley, who asked the board not to pass the draft
- Jesus Ruiz, Contra Costa Immigrant Rights Alliance, who cited Santa Clara's jail-lot restriction
- Joanna Gudino, Healthy Contra Costa, who objected to the draft's late posting
An Immigrant Legal Resource Center attorney listed gaps in contractor remedies, Sheriff reporting, training, data retention and AI. Jeff Hearns asked to restore the Sheriff reporting section. Dr. Jessica Standish, a physician at the Martinez jail, described ICE presence at the release area. Brianne Zorn, Mayor of Martinez, asked the county to adopt the SB 580 model policies in full to align with her city.
The other side: A smaller set of speakers cautioned the board. Joseph, a Martinez resident, cited a local killing by an undocumented immigrant. One caller urged the county to let ICE wait for jail releases.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: County Counsel said an ordinance would add little.
"It would be an administrative ordinance that applied only to staff. So in terms of enforceability and the strength of it, there really is no meaningful difference," said Tom Geiger, County Counsel.
Gioia compared the county's approach with a neighbor's.
"I just pulled up Sonoma. We have a lot more in our policy than Sonoma has in their ordinance," said Gioia.
Several advocate requests made it into the final policy, including contractor remedies, Sheriff reporting and website resources. The ordinance itself did not.
Supervisors Authorize Subpoenas Against the Assessor
Why it matters: Outside auditors cannot finish the county's FY2025-26 financial statements, due at the end of December, without records and interviews from the Assessor's Office.
Where things stand: The County Administrator said auditors Macias Giannini O'Connell (MGO) have not received all requested documents and interviews. He cited Government Code sections 25303 and 25170 and Revenue and Taxation Code section 408.
Assessor Gus Kramer asked the board to provide him outside counsel. He challenged MGO's qualifications and scope and asked for time to get a State Board of Equalization opinion.
"I'm not going to give up these confidential documents," said Kramer, County Assessor.
Supervisors pointed to delayed supplemental taxes. Kramer countered: "Well, the state law says I have up to 4 years to do the supplemental tax roll."
The other side: Andersen tied the scrutiny to broader concerns about the office.
"You also had a raid by the FBI. And that's what raised the concern for us and heightened our concern about what is going on in that office," said Andersen.
A public commenter named Liz cautioned against subpoenaing material the Assessor said his office is not responsible for.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Carlson moved and Andersen seconded. The motion authorizes one or more subpoenas to Kramer and his employees, with timing to follow County Counsel's outreach to the Board of Equalization. Burgis declared it unanimous on a voice vote. Scales-Preston voted yes.
The chair signs the subpoenas and the Sheriff serves them. Testimony will be given to the auditors, not at a board meeting. Kramer has threatened to challenge the subpoenas.
What's next: County Counsel will contact the Board of Equalization before the subpoenas issue.
46 New Eligibility Workers as HR 1 Hits Caseloads
Why it matters: The county serves roughly 104,000 CalFresh and nearly 300,000 Medi-Cal recipients. Federal HR 1 rules are causing procedural discontinuances and CalFresh losses tied to work requirements.
"The final allocations we received for CalFresh and Medi-Cal administration is $131 million. $14 million less than we projected," said Marla Stuart, Director, Employment and Human Services Department.
Where things stand: The board accepted $4,467,249 in one-time revenue and authorized 46 new positions:
- A 42-person trainee cohort, costing about $4.7M a year
- A four-person mobile EDGE team, with two vans at about $700,000 one-time each and $735,000 in recurring costs
The plan builds on Measure X-funded Empowered to Enroll contracts. A Zoom caller named Anna backed the hires after helping her daughter apply for Medi-Cal and CalFresh.
The other side: Stuart flagged the risk of funding permanent jobs with one-time money. "The reason I am raising it today is because I am asking for 42 permanent FTEs," she said. A supervisor noted that any Measure X reallocation is a separate board decision.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The item passed unanimously, per the chair. Enrollees gain capacity for renewals and outreach. Future budgets may need a Measure X subsidy.
What's next: The Measure X reallocation is expected before the board next month.
Minor Items
- Closed session: Supervisors voted to file a cross appeal in Duong Estuary Cove LLC v. County (For: 5, Against: 0).
- Consent calendar: Items C.1 through C.118 passed unanimously with none pulled. They include a $4.7M SAFE Center immigrant services contract, design of Byron Airport's unleaded fuel tank and the Homelessness Awareness Month resolution.
- Head Start: Enrollment sits at 90%, below the 97% federal mandate. Four months below target triggers a corrective action plan, and a pay-parity rule was rescinded.
- Juvenile justice: State realignment funding fell about $2M below projections. Gioia pressed on a rising hall population and racial disparities; no vote result was announced.
- Public comment: USW Local 5 Chair Chris Reyes cited a six-month Marathon refinery dispute, OSHA citations and flaring. Callers also urged action on data centers.
Looking Ahead: The SB 580 deadline is Jan. 1, 2027. Equity Committee follow-up and a Measure X decision are pending, and the audit is due at the end of December. Federal Head Start funding runs through Dec. 11. The board adjourned in memory of Michael French Metcalf, a former Moraga mayor, councilmember and planning commissioner.