

3-3 Tie Sinks AI Consultant Deal; AI Policy Heads Back to Committee
Board of Education • Coachella Valley Unified School DistrictNovember 19, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The Coachella Valley Unified School District Board of Education deadlocked 3-3 on Nov. 19, 2026, killing a professional services agreement with Designing Schools for an artificial intelligence plan. Earlier that night, trustees and residents criticized the district's draft AI policy, and it returned to committee. Residents also pressed the board on asthma care, contractor bills and dust from a nearby power plant demolition.
- AI consultant agreement fails 3-3 after a first-reading AI policy is criticized as too thin
- AI Board Policy 0441 returns to the Policy Committee and bargaining units for rework
- Asthma policy would stock two albuterol inhalers at every site; advocates urge a CalRx application
- Advocates ask district to warn families about Desert View Power Plant demolition dust
- Public commenters allege errors in ServPro invoices of about $4.5M
- Substitute pay raises pass 5-0-1 as the classified union calls its increase uncompetitive
AI Deal Dies on a Tie
Why it matters: The district still has no AI rules for students and staff. Trustees split evenly on whether outside consultants should help write them.
Where things stand: The board heard a first reading of Board Policy 0441, Artificial Intelligence. A staff presenter said the policy's guiding principle is that “we need to make sure that whenever AI is used, people always come first.” Staff described the draft as a baseline informed by committee work and a review by the California School Boards Association (CSBA). Staff said it will go back to the Policy Committee and bargaining units before a second reading.
Board Vice President Valerie Garcia, a Policy Committee member, said the draft fell short of the committee's earlier work. “This seems to be CSBA language, and we actually had more comprehensive language over a year ago,” she said. That earlier draft included fuller expectations for employees and students.
Trustee Alena Callimanis argued that students will use AI regardless and that a consultant could help the district write a responsible policy. “If it's taught responsibly, it enhances critical thinking,” she said. Trustee Jesus Gonzalez moved the Designing Schools agreement, saying, “This is the beginning of a process.”
The other side: Four public commenters opposed the contract. Public commenters put its cost at $54,000, though one cited $45,000, and the board did not state a figure.
- Public commenter Loretta Perez cited cognitive offloading, a New York City pause on AI use below eighth grade and a lawsuit over a chatbot. “They want to spend the money first and then write the rules later for you,” she said.
- Ray, vice president of CSEA Chapter 109, criticized edits that removed "should" and "ensure" language from the policy. He asked the board to pull the item, train all staff including classified employees, and “keep your admin responsible for this technology.”
- Ash, a community member with CV United for a Better Environment, cited cognitive and environmental harms and said “LAUSD did adopt a moratorium on AI.”
- Public commenter Stephanie Embriz cited the California Federation of Teachers' call for a three-year pause, Brookings Institution research and the district's budget deficit. “Absolutely no AI for students,” she said.
Garcia said a policy is still needed even though “AI is never going to be safe for our students.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Gonzalez moved the agreement and Callimanis seconded it. The motion failed (For: 3, Board President Thomas Tortez, Callimanis, Gonzalez; Against: 3, Garcia, Board Clerk Trinidad Arredondo, Trustee Jocelyn Vargas; Absent: 1, Trustee Joey Acuña Jr.). “Not a majority vote, motion does not carry,” the chair said. Teachers, classified staff and families will now see the policy shaped in-house through the committee and bargaining process.
What's next: Policy 0441 returns to the Policy Committee and bargaining units ahead of a second reading.
Free Inhalers, With a 2029 Catch
Why it matters: Free medication will run out, and the district will have to pay for it after that.
Where things stand: Staff presented a first reading of revised Board Policy 5141.23 and its administrative regulation on asthma management. Staff cited Education Code 49414.7. Each site would keep two stock albuterol inhalers with spacers. Supply would come from the AAIR Foundation through June and then from a state program. “We can get medication through 2029 for free,” a staff presenter said, after which district funding would be needed.
Superintendent Frances Esparza said the mandate is coming regardless. “This is something that's going to be required by all districts in 2029,” she said.
The other side: Perez and Cecilia Lemus, program coordinator with the Youth Leadership Institute, said the nonprofit RESCUE program had offered free inhalers and training. They said Desert Sands and Palm Springs adopted that program. Lemus cited high respiratory illness rates and urged the district to apply to CalRx, the state program. Both commenters said post-2029 costs should not be an excuse for delay.
What's next: This was a first reading only, and no vote was recorded. The policy is expected back for adoption.
Power Plant Dust: A Call to Warn Families
Why it matters: Students near Mecca could face dust exposure while a plant with a record of federal air violations is torn down.
Where things stand: Krystal Otworth of the Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability and Lemus asked the district to use its communication channels during the Desert View Power Plant demolition. They want the district to share demolition updates, dust-reporting steps and protective recommendations by social media, email and text. Otworth cited an EPA notice of violation for exceeding federal air quality limits more than 2,702 times between 2017 and 2021. She said a federal investigation is ongoing and that demolition could finish by mid-January 2027.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Garcia compared the request to the district sharing "red card" immigration information and asked staff to look into it. “It's just being a good community partner,” she said. The board took no formal action.
What's next: Garcia's request is with staff. No date for a response was set.
Spending Scrutiny: ServPro Bills and Marquees
Why it matters: Residents questioned how millions in public funds are spent while basic school repairs wait.
Where things stand: Perez said “the board tonight will be asked to pay out $4.5 million into ServPro contracts.” She alleged wrong school names, double charges and a crime-scene cleanup fee for vomit. Ray put the district's cleaning spending at almost $2.2M. He said district staff could have done much of the work, and he cited a sewage-pipe odor job and lodging charges. Commenters described the invoices as nearly 150 days past due. These are commenters' allegations, and no board response or vote on ServPro payments was recorded.
Perez also questioned a roughly $43,000 marquee at a school whose families had already raised money. She asked that the money go instead to fences, playgrounds and restoration work. Staff said the signs would carry emergency messages. Staff also said data and power upgrades are planned and existing wind-load footprints would be reused. Gonzalez urged quality displays: “I would make sure that when we buy new boards that we're buying a nice board.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The district-wide marquee and digital display initiative passed (For: 6, Against: 0, Absent: 1, Acuña) on a motion by Arredondo. A separate authorization to solicit bids for the sign infrastructure also passed 6-0, moved by Gonzalez and seconded by Vargas.
What's next: The district can now seek bids for the marquee infrastructure.
Substitute Pay Rises, Union Says Not Enough
Why it matters: The district competes with Desert Sands Unified for substitutes, which affects classroom coverage and technology support.
Where things stand: Ray told trustees that “our negotiations continues to kind of tumble along.” He said a diaper stipend is resolved, but salary and an insurance cap remain open. He also said discipline concerns are holding up the rollout of RTA transportation software. On substitute pay, he said, “teachers seem to be getting a $3.75 raise on that while we're getting $1.50 in classified.”
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The revised classified substitute salary schedule and the revised substitute teacher rates each passed (For: 5, Against: 0, Abstain: 1, Arredondo; Absent: 1, Acuña). Vargas moved both and Gonzalez seconded. “I abstain. My mom's a substitute in the district at times,” Arredondo said.
What's next: Bargaining with CSEA Chapter 109 continues, with salary and insurance unresolved.
Minor Items
- Dashboard gains: Staff said “Since 2024, our graduation rate has increased nearly 8 percentage points.” College and career readiness rose more than 16 points, and 14 schools earned 21 green indicators.
- Closed session: The board approved settlements OAH 2026090713 and OAH 2026071087 and stipulated expulsions 2627-002 and 2627-003, with Acuña absent.
- Consent calendar: The calendar passed 6-0. Item N1, pulled by Garcia, passed 4-2 with Garcia and Arredondo opposed. Its subject was not stated.
- Job description: The revised Coordinator for State and Federal Accountability role passed 6-0.
- Recognitions: The board honored Clave Efectiva students Isaac Medina and Julio Mora, who are headed to the Coachella festival. Employees of the month were Sarita Hernandez, Linda Hernandez and Blanca Ramirez.
Looking Ahead
Garcia made her second request for an update on the Mountain Vista playground. Tortez floated time limits for trustees, saying, “I think we need to have a limit on the speech time for the board members.” Callimanis disclosed she was asked to step back from Read With Me volunteering over a perceived conflict of interest.