

Board Weighs Operations Overhaul, Advances Forester Exam Fee Hike
California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection • CaliforniaNovember 5, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection spent its longest stretch on Nov. 5, 2026, debating how it should run itself. The debate came as new state laws pile on rulemaking deadlines and a key CAL FIRE landowner grant program runs dry. Its only substantive vote advanced a plan to more than double the application fee for professional foresters, on a 5-0 vote with four members absent.
- Board Forward framework floats fewer meetings and committee changes; no decision until December
- Forester application fee would jump from $200 to $450 after a 5-0 vote for a 15-day notice
- CAL FIRE's forest improvement program has no landowner funding for the first time in over 12 years
- Statewide assessment finds 2.5 million acres in a zone of imminent tree mortality
- Four new laws set Board rulemaking deadlines that stretch to about mid-2030
Board Forward: Rethinking How the Board Works
The basics: Executive Officer Tony Andersen presented Board Forward, a menu of operational changes drawn from board conversations, stakeholder feedback and a staff retreat. It was informational only, and no vote was taken.
Why it matters: The proposals could change how often the Board meets, how its committees are built and how the public weighs in. That matters most to the landowners, advocates and agencies who track forest rules closely.
Where things stand: The recommendations include annual priority setting and a committee refresh, possibly with a new Forest Policy Committee. They also add a standing agenda item for board member communications, assign board leads, set criteria for when to hold meetings, and expand federal coordination and field engagement.
"Continuous improvement is at the core of the board's mission," said Andersen. He relayed blunt staff feedback about routine updates: "Could that meeting have been an email?"
Board Member Elicia Goldsworthy picked up the thread. "Maybe there's some opportunity there to really ask the question of whether or not we need a full board meeting," she said, referring to lighter agendas.
Board Member Ryan Hilburn wants a policy committee. He also said "the EMC needs direction from the board of exactly what they should be considering for research," referring to the Effectiveness Monitoring Committee.
Board Member Williams proposed pairing members on initiatives. "We have Bagley Keene buddies where you can basically pair up," Williams said. Bagley-Keene is California's open meeting law for state bodies, and it limits how many members can confer outside public meetings.
Board Chair Terrence O'Brien backed field travel, more interaction with the U.S. Forest Service and putting at least two members on each initiative. "Board is most effective when the committees are most effective," he said.
The other side: Not everyone embraced the scope. Board Member Katie Delbar stressed public participation. "I don't also know if consolidation is the best use of our time," she said of merging committees.
Paul Mason of Pacific Forest Trust supported the review but warned of "a high likelihood of eyes bigger than stomach." He said assigning leads does not add capacity, and he urged workshop-style public engagement and more staff support.
Richard Gienger of Forest Forever went further. "The Board of Forestry has resisted every positive change," he said, adding that public participation is difficult.
What's next: Staff will fold the feedback into a revised memo for December. Members asked for periodic check-ins and a draft 2027 calendar.
Forester Fee Hike Clears First Hurdle
The basics: The Board authorized a 15-day public notice of changes to "Exam Fee Amendments 2026." The notice opens the revised regulatory text to public comment before final adoption. The changes amend six sections of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
Where things stand: Regulations Program Supervisor Tyler Hullquist presented the revised text. It raises the Registered Professional Forester (RPF) application fee from $200 to $450 and adds new pathways for qualifying work experience. It also defines supervision, allows hazard-tree work to count for up to two years of experience, and removes an arboriculture-for-public-safety provision.
Assistant Executive Officer Dan Stapleton explained the dual-grading process behind the exam. He said "the fee structure has not changed since 1994." Even at $450, the fee falls short of the program's cost: "It costs about $460 to $480 in total for all of that," he said.
The other side: Members supported moving forward but balked at the size of the jump.
"$450 on the back of a professional forester in a down market is really a lot of money," said Goldsworthy.
"$450 is a lot of money for the chance to fail the test," said Hilburn, pointing to young foresters.
Williams suggested indexing future increases to the Consumer Price Index and spreading the fees out instead of imposing sticker shock. "Industry prefers predictability," Williams said.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Goldsworthy asked whether the motion should be modified. Board counsel said the concern could be worked out later. On Goldsworthy's motion, the notice passed. The vote was For: 5 (Delbar, Goldsworthy, Hilburn, Williams, O'Brien), Against: 0, Absent: 4 (J. Lopez, Member King, Dawn Blake, Vice Chair Elizabeth Forsburg-Pardi). Early-career foresters and the companies that employ them face higher costs unless staff find offsetting funds.
What's next: O'Brien asked staff to return promptly with options.
Forest Improvement Program Runs Out of Money
Why it matters: The California Forest Improvement Program (CFIP) helps private landowners pay for forest work, and it is now out of money. "This marks the first time in over 12 years that the program does not have a funding source for landowner assistance," said Chief Huff, Deputy Director of Natural Resource Management Programs, CAL FIRE.
Where things stand: CAL FIRE delivered its final CFIP project selection in October and has halted applications. Huff tied the lapse to shrinking Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund money flowing through California Climate Investments. "CFIP is probably the first recognizable casualty," he said. He added that a 2006 law excluded state forest revenue as a funding source.
O'Brien and Goldsworthy offered the Board's help in advocating for funding. Gienger urged the Board to examine AB 1492 revenues as a way to keep the program alive.
Other updates: Huff presented in place of Director Joe Tyler, who retires at the end of December. He reported these items:
- A second study of how forest practice rules are implemented and whether they work is 71% complete.
- A $117M forest health award recommendation is pending.
- The Jackson Demonstration State Forest has faced delays. Its management plan has cleared executive review and will be scheduled with the Executive Officer.
Prescribed fire friction: O'Brien pressed for better coordination between state agencies on air quality. Huff said CAL FIRE is working to help people distinguish nuisance smoke from catastrophic smoke.
Asked by Hilburn about landowner liability, Huff said earlier agreement language was too restrictive. Templates are being updated for both small and large landowners. Both noted that using prescribed fire in timber harvests, such as the FireBerry Timber Harvesting Plan, lacks a clear mechanism and may require Board action.
"Can we track EPP-specific projects within the FT-ER," Williams asked, referring to the fuels treatment effectiveness reports.
Delbar described rescuing cattle during the Feliz Creek fire near Hopland and the fire on her family's ranch. She urged crews to ask landowners about roads and access, and she called for easier permitting of off-stream water storage. "It would be really nice if agencies could work together," she said. Huff pledged to take her comments back to CAL FIRE.
Assessment Paints Stark Picture of Forests
Where things stand: Chris Keithley, chief of CAL FIRE's Fire and Resource Assessment Program, noted that "we have been doing assessment reports on the health of forest and rangelands since 1979." This edition spans 13 chapters and 52 indicators. The first chapters are already released, and a second tranche is expected within weeks.
"Many forests are overly dense due to a legacy of fire exclusion and a lack of management," said Jamie Lydersen, the report's lead.
The report's findings include:
- 2.5 million acres in a zone of imminent mortality
- Declining sawmills and sparse biomass plants
- Rising temperatures and vapor pressure deficit, a measure of how dry the air is
- Growth in high-severity fire
- A net decline in forest carbon in recent years
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "Those were some scary slides," said O'Brien. He stressed the need for infrastructure and wants the Board to use the data to build urgency among elected leaders. Goldsworthy asked to draw on the assessment for AB 706 work. Delbar urged more rangeland content, including UC Berkeley ecosystem research and the loss of open space.
What's next: A public dashboard is planned for December.
New Laws Stack Up the Workload
Why it matters: O'Brien warned that new mandates strain Board resources. "We're going to have to make some probably difficult decisions," he said.
Where things stand: Goldsworthy briefed members on four new laws:
- SB 1370 directs a certified regulatory program for vegetation management on non-timberland. A legislative report is due by June 2027, emergency regulations by July 2028 and permanent regulations around mid-2030.
- AB 706 creates a biomass program, with at least 60% of feedstock coming from designated high-hazard zones. "This is a waste disposal program," she said, not a new market for cutting trees.
- AB 2075 requires emergency rulemakings on fire safety equipment for timber and rangeland operations.
- AB 442 raises acreage limits for Nonindustrial Timber Management Plans to 4,000 acres and for working forest management plans to 15,000 acres.
The Board's annual call for regulatory review drew 16 individual submissions plus input from agencies and organizations. Gienger said the review still has not addressed cumulative effects or rule 916.4.
Minor Items
- Consent calendar passed 5-0: It approved September minutes and three Effectiveness Monitoring Committee studies on spotted owls, post-fire coastal redwoods and Sierra Nevada riparian zones.
- Staff turnover: Stapleton retires Dec. 24. Recruitment for an assistant executive officer is live, and a new scientist will take over CalVTP update work.
- Fire hazard maps: A 60-day comment period on State Responsibility Area fire hazard severity zone maps opens Nov. 9 and runs through Jan. 8.
- Firewise growth: Hilburn reported "there's 1,808 communities in good standing."
- Licensing pipeline: RPF numbers are nearly flat since 2019, while certified range managers fell from 84 to 68. "We need to take a look at why our numbers are going down," said Delbar.
Looking Ahead: The Board meets Dec. 9 for a regular session followed by a three-hour facilitated strategic planning session. Staff will deliver a short transition report for the incoming administration by the end of November, and priority-setting decisions are expected in December and January.