Locunity — where decisions happen.
Trustees Grill Benito Juárez Charter, Set Jan. 13 Renewal Decision

Trustees Grill Benito Juárez Charter, Set Jan. 13 Renewal Decision

Board of Education • West Contra Costa Unified School DistrictNovember 20, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

A Richmond charter school serving about 471 elementary students made its case for a five-year renewal, and West Contra Costa Unified trustees answered with pointed questions on teacher credentials, a $982,000 management fee and stalled attendance. The board took no action and set a decision for Jan. 13, 2027. It also advanced a student-first public comment policy and approved three action items by unanimous roll call.


  • Benito Juárez Elementary charter renewal decision set for Jan. 13, 2027 after a public hearing with strong support from families and staff
  • $982,000 management fee, credentials and 28% attendance figure draw trustee scrutiny
  • Students would speak first at public comment under Board Policy 9322; adult education students to be added before Dec. 9 vote
  • Kennedy High vapor mitigation change order approved 7-0 as Kennedy and Stege completion dates slip into 2028
  • Superintendent reports Measure V's 75.49% win while speakers press the district on communication, repairs and school climate

Charter Renewal: Support in the Room, Questions on the Dais

A-Method Public Schools is seeking a five-year renewal for Benito Juárez Elementary in Richmond. Chief Executive Officer Adrienne Barnes and school staff presented gains in audit results, English learner progress, attendance efforts and anti-racist work. They asked the board to decide in December.

Why it matters: The decision affects roughly 471 Richmond students in kindergarten through fifth grade, more than half of them English learners. Trustees flagged credentialing, the management fee and gaps in results for student subgroups before deciding the school's future.

Where things stand: The hearing drew a wide coalition of supporters. Luis Moreira, a parent of a kindergartner with autism, said the school had supported his son. Hashim Khan, a fifth-grade teacher, cited student growth and stability. Fernando Ramos, a founding staff member, said the school launched his career. Coach Michael Evans urged the board to want the school open as part of its own strategic plan.

The California Charter Schools Association also weighed in. Kyra Armani Moore, associate director of local advocacy (Bay Area), California Charter Schools Association, urged approval and cited the school's English language arts, math and English learner results.

The other side: Trustees pressed on staffing and money. Teacher credentials led the questioning. The board discussed teachers working on intern credentials and emergency permits.

"18% of your teachers were fully credentialed," said Trustee Demetrio Gonzalez Hoy.

He then turned to the fee the school pays its charter management organization (CMO), the nonprofit that runs A-Method's central operations. "The school pays $982,000 to the CMO," said Gonzalez Hoy.

Barnes said the fee covers central services. "Our CMO fee includes our home office, our back office," said Barnes.

Gonzalez Hoy also noted that the school had stalled on one attendance measure. "Last year you did not make any progress at 28%," he said.

Trustee Leslie Reckler questioned how the petitioners framed their results. "Why did you not use California dashboard data for your presentation?" she asked. The California School Dashboard is the state's public accountability report for schools.

Trustees also asked about the recent enrollment dip, outcomes for student subgroups, and special education services delivered through individualized education programs, or IEPs. The petitioners promised written follow-ups to several questions.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board took no action. Families who chose the school, its staff and A-Method's central office now wait more than seven weeks for an answer. The petitioners' written responses on credentials, fees and subgroup outcomes will likely shape how trustees weigh broad community support against performance and governance concerns.

What's next: The board is scheduled to decide on Jan. 13, 2027.


Students First: Policy 9322 Gets Its First Read

Student Trustee Brooke Miles proposed Board Policy 9322, which would let students speak first during public comment. She cited more than 20 Kennedy High students who stayed at a board meeting until 10 p.m. the night before Advanced Placement exams.

The basics: Comment cards would add a student checkbox. Zoom participants would rename themselves "student" so the chair can call on them first. Student-focused agenda items could also move earlier on the agenda.

Why it matters: Late meetings can shut out students with school the next day. The policy aims to keep their access without the late nights.

"Our students' voices should always come first, no matter what," said Miles.

Where things stand: Trustees debated whether adult education students should be included. They agreed to add them now, at first reading, and leave the details to the superintendent. Reckler pointed to a nearby district as a model. "Oakland definitely prioritizes their students first," she said.

The board also reordered its agenda so the policy item came before the student trustee's usual departure time.

Both public commenters supported the policy. Caitlin Markensky praised Miles' advocacy, including founding a leadership class at Vista High. A commenter identified as Marie backed adding adult education students and asked the board to consider limiting how long closed sessions run.

What's next: The final vote is set for Dec. 9, alongside 125 policy updates driven by CSBA.


Kennedy, Stege Timelines Slip Into 2028

The board approved two bond construction actions with no board discussion and no public comment. Each passed 7-0 on a roll call that included both student trustees (For: 7, Against: 0, Absent: 0).

Where things stand: The first action ratified negotiated change orders at Kennedy High and Shannon Elementary. Ellen Mejia-Hooper, director of facilities planning and construction, said the Kennedy changes came solely from contingency and allowances. She said Shannon's were final change orders. Gonzalez Hoy moved the item and Trustee Cinthia Hernandez seconded it.

The second action approved a Kennedy change order adding a below-slab vapor intrusion mitigation system under new Buildings A and B. The system is designed to keep vapors from entering the buildings. "Tonight we are seeking approval of the negotiated change order for the Kennedy High School Project," said Mejia-Hooper. Gonzalez Hoy moved the item and Miles seconded it.

Why it matters: The vapor work protects people in the new buildings, but it also contributes to schedule delays. Later in the meeting, Mejia-Hooper's quarterly update laid out the timelines:

  • Kennedy High (Phase 1.3): Structural steel procurement problems hit Building A. "We are expanding the schedule to the winter of '28," said Mejia-Hooper.
  • Stege Elementary (Phase 2): Completion has moved to summer 2028. A community meeting is set for Dec. 1 at 7 p.m.
  • Richmond High (Phase 2.1): The project remains on track for a summer move-in, with extra money used to protect against winter rain.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Kennedy and Stege families face longer construction timelines. Bond dollars are absorbing the changes through contingency and allowances rather than new appropriations.

What's next: Staff invited residents to apply for the Citizens Bond Oversight Committee, the panel that monitors bond spending.


Superintendent's Report and a Restless Public Comment

The superintendent tabled the strategic plan update and said a full draft will come in December. The district has engaged more than 1,200 students, and the 2027-2030 strategic plan will be aligned with the district's Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP).

Where things stand: The superintendent celebrated a ballot win. "Measure V won by a phenomenal 75.49% yes vote," the superintendent said.

The report also addressed school safety. "We are addressing and dealing with a very serious issue around hazing at one of our high schools," the superintendent said. The district has held hazing trainings and formed partnerships with the Office of Neighborhood Safety and the RISE Center. The superintendent also described the district's response to a hate crime at Kensington Elementary.

The other side: Public commenters described communication and service gaps:

  • Maria Naim said a ParentSquare message should have gone out after the El Cerrito High incident. She urged cameras and GPS on special education buses and a working PA system.
  • Crystal Leftwich, a preschool special education teacher at Dover Elementary, described a classroom ceiling leak lasting a year and unanswered emails. The problem has led to fire marshal involvement and a Williams complaint, a state complaint process over school facilities and conditions.
  • Crystal Bannigan, a parent, accused staff of stonewalling parents on records and special education, especially African American parents.
  • Nick Crescenzi said the State of the District breakfast location was missing from the district website.
  • Francisco Ortiz, president of United Teachers of Richmond, thanked voters for Measure V and shared a survey of more than 129 members at four high schools rating staff support. "Pinole Valley ranked in last," said Ortiz.
  • Julie Harris, a member of Jewish Voice for Peace, urged the board to protect ethnic studies amid a lawsuit filed by the Brandeis Center and StandWithUs.

Why it matters: The complaints tie back to the strategic plan's promise of better engagement. Families and teachers are testing whether that promise reaches their classrooms and inboxes.


Minor Items

  • Closed session: The board unanimously rejected a personal injury claim and appointed Brandon Chapman director of maintenance.
  • Teacher assignments: The board approved teacher consent authorizations 7-0, letting credentialed teachers teach outside their credential areas.
  • Recognition: The district honored a Richmond High engineering teacher as the 2026-27 Project Lead The Way Outstanding Teacher.
  • Consent calendar: No items were pulled, and the board accepted the remaining consent items as posted.

Looking Ahead

The board's next meeting is Dec. 9, when trustees will take the final vote on the student-priority policy and receive the full strategic plan draft. The Benito Juárez Elementary renewal decision follows on Jan. 13, 2027.