

Council Members Back ICE Inquiry Letter After Burlingame Avenue Arrest
City Council • BurlingameNovember 17, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
A morning immigration arrest on Burlingame Avenue brought residents, Faith in Action volunteers and a judge to the Burlingame City Council on Nov. 16, 2026. Council members agreed to send a formal letter of inquiry to federal immigration authorities, though the city manager warned the letter will likely be ignored. The council also moved toward a new Arts Commission and declared a local El Niño emergency.
- Council members back a letter of inquiry to ICE after a Nov. 6 arrest; no formal vote was taken.
- About eight public commenters pressed for the letter, outreach and a hotline link on the city website.
- Consensus to create an Arts Commission, with an ordinance expected in early 2027.
- $50,000 to $100,000 in annual arts funding discussed; council members favored keeping developer fees out of it.
- Local El Niño emergency declared 5-0, speeding storm contracting; renewal required every 60 days.
A Street Arrest Tests the Limits of Local Power
The basics: SB 54, the California Values Act, bars local police from participating in federal immigration enforcement. Burlingame's Police Department Policy 427 says the same.
Why it matters: Residents described fear in immigrant families and disruption at local businesses. The city has little authority over federal agents, so a letter is the main concrete step.
Where things stand: The Police Chief reported that federal agents believed to be ICE detained a person near Burlingame Avenue and Lorton around 7 a.m. on Nov. 6. He said the city receives no notification of these operations.
“Under California law, local police departments are not involved in immigration enforcement,” said the Police Chief. He directed families to San Mateo County resources, adding, “There is no way for us to get verification of who they're detaining.”
Mayor Michael Brownrigg pressed for answers: “How can we find out who this is and why he's being detained.”
Council members described the toll. Councilmember Peter Stevenson called the arrest “a very conspicuous assault to grab this person on the street.” Councilmember Donna Colson said a restaurateur told her “over half their staff was not going to come to work the next day.” A councilmember also cited data from Faith in Action Bay Area.
An organized community push: Public commenters spoke at length, many tied to Faith in Action.
- Judge Balanos, a public commenter, urged a letter to ICE offices and elected officials asking about warrant type, detainee location, access to counsel, masked officers and prior notice to local police. He agreed to forward his questions.
- Melody Carnejo, a Faith in Action volunteer, described an arrest near Washington School and agents in vests reading "police" or "sheriff," and offered informational cards for city distribution.
- Sheila Peralta Lopez, emotional, said she fears for her community and asked council to do more than point people to the hotline.
- Mackenzie Pedroza urged barring local resources from use by ICE.
- Berta Schultz asked the city to post a Faith in Action link on its website. Yesenia, a lifelong resident, called for better outreach to workers.
The other side: One unnamed online commenter disputed the framing, blamed border policy, called the arrests targeted rather than indiscriminate, and defended agents wearing masks.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: “I think we have a responsibility to send that letter and ask those questions,” said Colson. Councilmember Desiree Thayer agreed: “I would be in favor of sending a letter.” Thayer also asked about a policy or ordinance limiting ICE use of city property, as she said other county cities have done. The City Attorney pointed to existing California law and adopted city policy.
City Manager Lisa K. Goldman set expectations: “They're going to ignore us, but that doesn't mean we don't put our best foot forward.”
What's next: Brownrigg will draft the letter with Thayer. “I think the idea of running a draft by Faith in Action before the proofreader makes sense, and so we will do that,” he said.
Arts Commission Gets a Green Light in Principle
Why it matters: Volunteers say they cannot raise money or issue requests for proposals as a task force. That gap stalled a planned town square mural.
Where things stand: “We want to respectfully make a formal ask to the council to support the Burlingame Arts Commission,” said an Arts Task Force member at a study session before the regular meeting. The task force recommended five voting members, possibly two nonvoting youth members aged 16 to 18, and library staff support.
Colson questioned the structure: “I really want to understand and make sure that we're comfortable with this being a commission as opposed to a council or something else.” The concern is the Brown Act, California's open-meeting law, which brings noticing and public-meeting obligations.
The City Attorney said function matters more than label. He suggested an ad hoc formation committee with a fixed end date, such as March 31, 2027. He also warned that a seven-member body with two nonvoting seats still has a quorum of four.
Money fight: Colson floated a first-year budget: “You're going to need a minimum of 50, probably up to 100, somewhere in there.” The task force said it could use that responsibly, and a councilmember suggested $100,000 as a baseline. Mural estimates ran from $50,000 up.
Colson suggested routing donations through the Burlingame Parks Forever Foundation, since Library Foundation bylaws would not allow it. Stevenson cautioned against relying only on donors: “I do get concerned if that is the only level of funding, because we will be in the same boat that we're currently in.”
Brownrigg backed public money, preferably from the general budget or hotel tax. He proposed that on each project, “half would come from public money and half needs to come from donations.”
Developers and art: The City Attorney explained that percent-for-art rules must let developers install art or pay an in-lieu fee, limiting city control. Community Development staff noted public art is already a community benefit option and appears in the North Rollins Road specific plan with an in-lieu fee. “I would propose just divorcing development from art,” Brownrigg said.
The Hillsborough question: Council members raised concern about Hillsborough members directing Burlingame money. Options included nonvoting seats, foundation roles or a joint powers agreement, which the attorney called one option among several.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Brownrigg reported thumbs-up consensus to create a commission. He favored seating the three task-force members — “why not lean on the people who've been doing all of the thinking and the work” — with staggered three-year terms and possibly up to seven seats. No budget action was taken.
What's next: Staff will prepare an ordinance in early 2027, followed by council appointments and operating procedures.
El Niño Emergency Clears Path for Fast Storm Work
Why it matters: The declaration lets the city move quickly on storm contracts and positions it for FEMA cost recovery without calling a special meeting.
Where things stand: Public Works Director Chris Lamb said the state declared an emergency Sept. 21 and San Mateo County followed in October. He flagged king tides and bayfront vulnerabilities near Old Bayshore and Rollins Road.
Preparations include creek cleaning, material stockpiles, pump station work, emergency operations meetings with the fire district and a sandbag station. The declaration “helps us expedite procurement so we can bypass some of the city's procurement rules,” Lamb said.
Colson pointed residents to One Shoreline flood resources: “We need to be flood ready.” Stevenson asked whether pump stations were ready. Lamb said they were as ready as they will be.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Thayer moved and Vice Mayor Andrea Pappajohn seconded. The resolution passed (For: 5 — Brownrigg, Pappajohn, Colson, Stevenson, Thayer; Against: 0; Absent: 0).
What's next: The declaration must return for renewal every 60 days.
Minor Items
- Tourism district grows: Council adopted the ordinance second reading and a resolution of modification adding Daly City to the San Francisco Peninsula Tourism Marketing District, both 5-0.
- Public Financing Authority formed: Council approved the joint powers agreement 5-0 on consent, and the Industrial Development Authority followed 5-0. Colson's bond refinancing question goes to bond counsel when the agreement returns.
- Bike lanes closed out: Council accepted the $599,291.08 Murchison, Trousdale and Davis bike lane project by Redgwick Construction Co. on consent, 5-0.
- Personal letter disclosed: Colson said she wrote the State Lands Commission as a resident and council member, not on behalf of colleagues.
Looking Ahead
Light Up the Square/Winterfest is Dec. 4. Some city fields remain closed until Feb. 27. The council adjourned in memory of Thayna Park.