Locunity — where decisions happen.
Supervisors Weigh Moving Hall of Justice to Mid-Market

Supervisors Weigh Moving Hall of Justice to Mid-Market

Budget & Finance Committee • San FranciscoNovember 18, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

San Francisco's crumbling Hall of Justice could become a tool for reviving Market Street. At a Nov. 18, 2026 hearing, the Budget & Finance Committee heard from city departments, consultants and a law school on relocating justice functions to Mid-Market, then unanimously advanced 13 items, including a $1.6B airport lease and a $15.8M loan for survivor housing.


  • Hall of Justice relocation floated as a Mid-Market anchor; no site was chosen
  • $15.8M survivor housing loan advances despite the sponsor's Tier 2 flag and a late audit
  • 25-year, $1.6B private aviation lease at SFO heads to the full Board
  • Custom city software would lose its bidding exemption under a reform backed by labor
  • Free city rooms for recovery groups clear committee under the chair's Sober Spaces ordinance

A Courthouse as Downtown Anchor

Why it matters: The city's capital plan lists a $367M need for the Hall of Justice. Where that building goes could shape both the court system and Market Street's recovery.

Where things stand: Matt Dorsey, Supervisor, District 6, chairs the committee and convened the hearing. He cited the seismic hazard at 850 Bryant St., the Civic Center Area Plan, and the possibility of an alternative to a replacement courthouse at 820 Bryant.

"The Hall of Justice has been waiting to be replaced for more than 30 years," said Supervisor Dorsey.

The city already has a large presence on the corridor. Sally Orth, Director, Real Estate Division, said the city leases about 630,000 square feet there. That footprint will rise past 1 million square feet once 1455 Market St. comes online. The Office of Economic and Workforce Development opened the presentations.

The outside view: DJ Allison, San Francisco Bay Area Regional Executive, AECOM, described courthouses as economic anchors. He also discussed adaptive reuse and public-private delivery models.

"Applying this case study's findings suggests potential economic benefits in the range of maybe $10 million a year annually in incidental local spending and incidental activity," said Allison.

Lisa Follmann, architect and adaptive reuse lead at Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, tested three candidate sites against a need of roughly 550,000 square feet: 50 United Nations Plaza, the Hotel Whitcomb and 1455 Market St. She also made a broader cost case for reuse.

"A new construction residential building is currently about $1.1 million per key, whereas a residential conversion is at $750,000," said Follmann.

Who's lining up: David Seward, Chief Financial Officer, UC Law San Francisco, supported relocating near Civic Center. He said the move would complement the school's academic village and its student placements with the public defender and district attorney.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The hearing was heard and filed. For: 3 (Chan, Sauter, Dorsey), Against: 0, Absent: 0. No relocation proposal is pending.

Dorsey closed on the hearing's thesis: "The city's real estate decisions are economic development decisions." Mid-Market property owners, the courts, justice agencies and nearby institutions all have a stake in what comes next.

What's next: No follow-up action or timeline was set.


Survivor Housing Loan Moves Despite Audit Flag

Why it matters: The $15.8M Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) loan would create 23 transitional units at 101 Gough St. for survivors of trafficking and violence and their children. The money comes from the Proposition A set-aside. The sponsor, San Francisco Safe House Holdings LLC, says it turns away about three survivors for every one it can house.

Where things stand: The item was continued from the Nov. 4 meeting so members could review audit concerns. Total development cost is $20.8M.

Benjamin McCloskey, Deputy Director of Finance, MOHCD, outlined the city's protections on the loan:

  • A deed of trust
  • A 99-year affordability restriction
  • Required reserves
  • Ongoing monitoring

The other side: Nick Menard of the Budget and Legislative Analyst's Office said the sponsor holds Tier 2 status, a city designation that flags concerns about a nonprofit's financial condition. The flag stems from a late audit and an employee theft of roughly $30,000. Menard reviewed the audit, found it healthy, and suggested follow-up.

"I do think it's worth the department kind of reporting back to this committee in 12 months about the status of the project and whether it's on track," said Menard.

Toni Eby, CEO of San Francisco Network Ministries Housing Corporation/San Francisco Safe House, apologized for the late audit. She noted how few women-specific supportive housing sites exist and described the units' trauma-informed design.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Both Connie Chan, Supervisor, District 1, the committee's vice chair, and Supervisor Dorsey praised the project. The loan was forwarded with a positive recommendation. For: 3 (Chan, Sauter, Dorsey), Against: 0, Absent: 0. The Tier 2 status remains a watch point.

Related homelessness actions: Three Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing items also advanced, each 3-0.

  • Homekey Plus at 835 Turk St.: A corrected acceptance of the full $17.3M grant, about $13.7M for rehab and $3.5M for operations. The state now routes the whole grant through the city to the operator, Five Keys. Emily Cohen, Deputy Director, said the change is administrative and no changes have been made to the project.
  • Abode Services: Its rental-assistance contract is extended to 2029, up to $29M. Abode served 368 households in fiscal year 2025-26 and paid 100% of assistance within 48 hours. Compliance manager Genesis Morales spoke in support.
  • Episcopal Community Services: Its housing navigation contract is extended to 2028, up to $22.7M. Cohen said "the program moved approximately 541 people into permanent housing."

SFO Locks In Long-Term Lease Revenue

Why it matters: Two airport votes advanced leases worth about $1.6B to SFO, with a slice going to the city's general fund.

Where things stand: The largest deal is a 25-year lease with Signature Flight Support, SFO's sole fixed base operator, the firm that services private and corporate aircraft. Its terms:

  • A $42.5M first-year minimum annual guarantee
  • About $52.6M in tenant-funded improvements, well above the $20M minimum set in the request for proposals
  • Revenue goes entirely to the airport

Supervisor Dorsey asked about the competitive bidding process.

Hudson Group won the Terminal 3 West newsstand lease. It carries a $2,352,457 minimum annual guarantee plus tiered percentage rent.

"We expect that the airport would get at least $33 million over the 14-year initial term of this lease, and then 15% of that is shared with the city's general fund," said Menard, who called both leases good deals for the airport.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The committee also forwarded termination of RAKH Inc.'s Harvey Milk Terminal 1 eyewear lease. The shop closed in May 2026 and will repay $54,000 over 18 months. Both votes: For: 3, Against: 0, Absent: 0.


Closing a 1999 Software Loophole

Why it matters: Custom-built city software could no longer bypass competitive bidding, giving the city more leverage on price.

Where things stand: Administrative Code Section 21.30 dates to 1999 and does not distinguish between software types. The ordinance from Supervisor Jackie Fielder makes four changes:

  • Limits the waiver to commercial off-the-shelf software
  • Codifies review by the Office of Contract Administration
  • Restricts bundled support to setup and configuration
  • Preserves exemptions from some code requirements

Molly Peterson, Deputy City Purchaser, presented the changes. Supervisor Chan is a co-sponsor.

"This legislation closed a very small loophole," said Chan.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Jessica Nuti, lead organizer, San Francisco team, IFPTE Local 21, thanked the sponsors and cited the city's OpenGov contract. She urged continued work with public sector unions on procurement. Supervisor Dorsey voiced support for competitive bidding.

Chan moved the ordinance to the full Board. For: 3, Against: 0, Absent: 0.


Free Rooms for Recovery Meetings

Why it matters: Dorsey, the ordinance's author, said many newer neighborhoods lack churches with basements, the traditional home of recovery meetings.

Where things stand: "This legislation will require San Francisco's Recreation and Park Department and Police Department to make their community rooms available any day of the year at no cost to meeting participants," said Dorsey. The ordinance also creates a Sober Spaces Fund and MOHCD grants.

The Budget and Legislative Analyst estimated the costs at 25 weekly meetings per department:

  • About $65,000 in police staffing
  • About $20,000 in Rec & Park staffing
  • About $15,000 a year in waived Rec & Park fees

For scale, the city hosts about 500 Alcoholics Anonymous meetings citywide. Menard said "we consider approval to be a policy matter for the board."

What's next: Departments are to report back during the budget process. The committee forwarded the ordinance 3-0.


Minor Items

  • World Cup security: Retroactive $2,737,002 FEMA-sourced grant reimburses police, fire and sheriff costs for the World Cup; no general fund match; 3-0.
  • Methadone contract: Bayview Hunters Point Foundation gets a six-month extension through June 30, 2027, adding $2.3M, though its financial audits since fiscal year 2022-23 remain overdue; 3-0.
  • Public health gifts: Accepted $118,800 in newborn care boxes and a $50,000 rapid hepatitis C testing machine for jail health, amended to add "retroactive" language; 3-0.
  • 25 Van Ness fire: Emergency declaration for cleanup after the Sept. 7 fire; costs expected near $250,000, paid from a Real Estate Division reserve; 3-0.

Looking Ahead

All 13 forwarded items are expected before the full Board of Supervisors on Dec. 1. Watch for the Safe House report-back and the Sober Spaces cost review at budget time.