Locunity — where decisions happen.
Brisbane Council Reserves December Dates to Finish Baylands Under State Pressure

Brisbane Council Reserves December Dates to Finish Baylands Under State Pressure

City Council • BrisbaneNovember 20, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Brisbane is out of compliance with state housing law, and the City Council spent nearly five hours on Nov. 19, 2026, working toward a December vote on the Baylands Specific Plan. Through informal direction, not formal votes, members settled on an 1,800-unit base, tightened water rules for construction and moved to block permits until developer BDI pays what it owes the city. The hearing continues Monday, Nov. 23.


  • December adoption path: Council reserved Dec. 10, 14 and 17 after learning of a state housing letter requesting a schedule by Dec. 2.
  • 1,800 units as the base: Council reached informal consensus, with reduced building heights as the preferred way to get there.
  • Proof of water before earth-moving: Council moved toward requiring adequate water for any earth-disturbing activity.
  • BDI still owes about $6.2M: Lentz secured legal confirmation that the plan can bar permits until the city is paid.
  • Recycling plant stays: Council kept the water recycling facility and declined to pause for a full treatment plant study.

Racing a State Clock Toward December

Why it matters: Brisbane lacks a compliant housing element, the state-required plan showing where a city will accommodate new housing. That exposes the city to builder's remedy projects, a state-law route that lets developers bypass local zoning when a city is out of compliance.

“We are out of compliance with our housing element right now,” said Councilmember Frank Kern.

Where things stand: City staff said the full package could be ready by Dec. 3 for a Dec. 7 decision. That package includes a redlined plan, EIR errata, findings, a statement of overriding considerations, resolutions and an ordinance. Staff called the timeline a push but said it was achievable: “If it's a council priority, we can make that push and make it happen.”

The city attorney summarized a letter from the state Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). It asks the city for a written response by Dec. 2, 2026, with hearing dates and an adoption schedule. “Our interpretation of that line is that HCD is asking the city to provide by December 2nd a schedule on which it plans to adopt,” the city attorney said. In the city's reading, the letter does not set an adoption deadline.

Mayor Pro Tem Madison Davis said the risk is already concrete: “There has been an inquiry into a 50 to 60 unit development under builder's remedy in the HCP.” She said such a project could vest by January and that adopting the plan protects the city. “My fear is that we let perfection be the enemy of the good,” she added.

Staff also confirmed a specific plan can be adopted without a development agreement. Staff estimated that moving the city's housing sites elsewhere would take about a year and a half.

The other side: Speed has its critics. Michael Barnes, a public commenter, criticized the council's process and the shortened time for public comment. Michelle Salmon, chair of No on Measure JJ, took the opposite view. She said the council is dragging its feet and urged it to act now rather than wait for perfection.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Councilmember Terry O'Connell said “it is important that this gets done this year,” and Councilmember Cliff Lentz also backed finishing by year-end. Kern urged working backward from a fixed date. “I think we have to back into a date and we bring as high of a quality of product as we can by that date,” he said.

Mayor Coleen Mackin proposed extra dates. Council agreed to hold Dec. 10, 14 and 17 in reserve.

What's next: The hearing resumes Monday, Nov. 23, 2026, at 5:30 p.m., a session held firm for finance and the peer review. The FEIR alternatives and public safety were not reached and remain pending.


Council Settles on 1,800 Units, Not 2,200

Why it matters: Base density drives building types and affordable housing. Measure JJ, Brisbane's voter-approved Baylands measure, frames a range of 1,800 to 2,200 units.

Where things stand: Former mayors, led by spokesperson Clark Conway, argued that Measure JJ makes 1,800 the base, with any density bonus on top. Conway said the 2.25 million cubic yards of dirt on the site equals about 75,000 truck trips. He urged Alternative 7 as the environmentally responsible choice.

Staff outlined two paths: lower zoning, or performance zoning that allows up to 2,200 units if objective standards are met. Staff noted that Housing Element Program 2.8.2 requires objective standards to reach 2,200 units.

“1,800 it is, base foundation,” Mackin declared.

Davis said her “strategy number 1 and preferred method is to reduce building height,” while giving staff flexibility to propose fallbacks. “It might be more palatable to both our public and to the developer to take some of that density out of those high-rise buildings,” O'Connell said.

The other side: Lentz suggested FEIR Alternative 7. Davis and Mackin opposed adopting it without knowing the implications. Staff said Alternative 7 would mean redoing land use and development standards. “I think the consultant team would need another month to bring you back those changes so that you could look at them and adopt them,” staff said.

Line by line: Council first split over how to give direction. “I actually think going right to a redline is a very bad idea,” Mackin said, arguing the public was being cut out. “I think we do need to start giving direction to the staff,” O'Connell countered.

Council ultimately went line by line through staff's 28-item follow-up table. Members backed:
- No occupancy until cleanup is complete in each operable unit, the separate zones the site is divided into for remediation.
- Phasing tied to infrastructure and amenities.
- A performance standard for the Geneva Avenue extension.
- Private streets with enforceable public access easements.
- Financial assurance and stabilization plans.
- Removing language implying public financing.
- A companion infrastructure financing plan.

Revenue-positive requirements and childcare go to the development agreement or a nexus study, an analysis that ties fees to a project's demonstrated impacts. Members also asked for stronger energy self-sufficiency. Staff will return on collector roads such as Tunnel Avenue.

What's next: These directions feed the redlined plan staff is drafting for a possible December adoption.


No Water, No Grading

Why it matters: Measure JJ requires water “prior to site development” but never defines the term. That definition decides when the developer must prove it has water for dust control and grading.

Where things stand: Lentz noted the plan said Brisbane potable water would serve grading. Staff acknowledged those references will change to reflect council direction that no Brisbane potable water be used. Lentz proposed a broad definition: “Site development is defined as any major component of construction that will enable development to occur, such as remediation, grading, and the installation of infrastructure.”

Mackin asked whether the plan could require written evidence that the SFPUC, the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, will allocate water for dust mitigation. She also asked for generic “permits” language rather than “building permits.” Staff said that without a water source, “they would not be able to do the grading efforts.”

Members converged on language requiring a demonstrated adequate water supply before any earth-disturbing activity. That supply is separate from the permanent drinking water for future residents. O'Connell cautioned against tying a full water agreement to remediation. Public commenter Paul Pascal proposed non-potable “purple pipe” and a non-potable tank built first.

Recycling over a full plant: Kern asked staff to “evaluate the strategic feasibility of sizing the planned Baylands wastewater facility to also serve Central Brisbane and the Ridge.” SFPUC sewer treatment charges are rising for residents.

Staff said the EIR analyzed a recycling plant of about 1 million gallons, with excess flows still going to the SFPUC. A feasibility study would take about 12 weeks.

Shilan Patel, Chief Business Development Officer, California Water Service, said Cal Water has not studied a full treatment plant. “The cost, though, especially from a municipal end, just doesn't pencil out,” Patel said of closed-loop systems. Cal Water is “hoping to get the facility online by 2030,” Patel said. Construction would take 20 to 24 months, and the plant would likely be infeasible without Brisbane's effluent.

Davis said “I think we definitely should study it” but questioned the timing. Lentz said of Cal Water's term sheet that “we need to do better.” Mackin proposed proceeding with the recycling facility, and members agreed. A full treatment plant could return through a later amendment or the development agreement.


Developer Still Owes the City $6.2M

Why it matters: Unpaid plan and EIR costs have pushed the city to draw on reserves. “The city has to use reserves to pay for services,” Lentz said, noting the city runs a deficit.

Where things stand: Staff reported that BDI paid another $1M, leaving about $6.2M outstanding, with more consultant bills possible. Don Gamblin, Chief Operating Officer, BDI, declined to explain why the company pays in partial installments. “My attorney is working with the city's attorney very collaboratively at this point,” he said. Gamblin said BDI's controller would not attend that evening, but that he would attend the finance meeting himself.

Lentz asked whether council “could give direction to staff to write into the specific plan that no permits would be issued prior to the city being paid in full.” The city's legal counsel confirmed it can.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Council added the no-permits-until-paid provision to its list of changes, and staff will return on consultant costs. Conway, citing about $7M owed, urged the same condition. Public commenters Doris Storz-Hohen and Mary Rogers also said BDI should pay its bills.


Minor Items

  • Drainage: Lentz flagged a deteriorated brick sewer arch and timber box culvert on Bayshore Boulevard. Staff said “you can't require the developer to mitigate preexisting issues.”
  • Labor: Bart Panchuhub, Business Manager and Secretary-Treasurer, Building Trades Council, cited a “long-standing commitment with BDI to utilize a union workforce.”
  • Schools and sites: Pascal noted Baylands students would attend Bayshore School District schools and urged considering Sierra Point for housing.
  • Late night: Voice votes extended the meeting to 9:30 p.m. and then to 10:30 p.m. The second result was not formally declared, but the meeting continued.

Looking Ahead

Kern moved to continue the hearing to Monday, Nov. 23, 2026, at 5:30 p.m., and the motion carried by voice vote with no tally recorded. Finance and the peer review come first. The FEIR alternatives and public safety follow on the reserved December dates.

Brisbane Council Reserves December Dates to Finish Baylands Under State Pressure | City Council | Locunity