

Brentwood Board Taps Leadership Associates to Find Next Superintendent
Board of Education • Brentwood Union School DistrictNovember 18, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The Brentwood Union School District Board of Education started the search for its next leader on Nov. 18, 2026, choosing Leadership Associates 4-0 to recruit a successor to Superintendent Dana Eaton, who is leaving for a county role after more than a decade in the district. Before the vote, four teachers pressed trustees on a pay gap that they say leaves veteran transferred teachers earning less than new hires with the same experience. That issue could resurface at the bargaining table.
- Leadership Associates hired 4-0 to run the superintendent search after three firms pitched
- Four teachers seek pay parity for transferred staff under Article 8 of their contract
- District's opening CSEA bargaining proposal approved 4-0, putting vacation, salary and benefits on the table
- Mid-year LCAP report: math sits 19.6 points below standard as county support ends
- Parent flags classroom disruptions; staff point to a behavior task force meeting in January
Three Firms, Six Minutes Each, One Unanimous Pick
Why it matters: The firm will help choose the district's first new superintendent in more than a decade. Superintendent Dana Eaton is leaving for a county role, so this search will shape district leadership for years.
Where things stand: Three firms answered the district's request for proposals: HYA, Leadership Associates and McPherson and Jacobson. Eaton told trustees that each firm would get six minutes to present.
- HYA stressed its track record. "HYA reports a client satisfaction rating of 9.4 out of 10, and 94% of recruited leaders remain through the length of their contracts," said Dr. Rob Martinez, lead associate, HYA.
- Leadership Associates, represented by consultant Dr. Janet Schultz, cited:
- firm-wide search meetings every two weeks
- periodic updates to the board
- California ties
- ownership by equity partners
- 85% retention of placed leaders at five years
- McPherson and Jacobson promised personalized service, integration with board governance and a free repeat search if a placement fails within two years. "We are available to you from start to finish," said Nicole Anderson, lead consultant, McPherson and Jacobson.
The other side: No trustee opposed the choice. Several said the decision was hard because the firms were similar. HYA's satisfaction and retention numbers and McPherson and Jacobson's free repeat search were the strongest competing offers.
Board President Scott Dudek pointed to the meeting schedule as the deciding factor. "I like the fact that they meet every 2 weeks with us," said Dudek. Other trustees cited the firm's history with districts comparable to Brentwood.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion to accept Leadership Associates passed. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Trustee Thornhill). The vote hands an outside firm a central role in recruiting candidates for the district's top job. The firm's promise of regular check-ins gives trustees a steady view into its progress. Teachers, classified staff and parents have a stake in who emerges. Several of them used public comment to raise pay, labor and classroom-behavior issues that a new superintendent will inherit.
What's next: The board did not announce a search timeline or plans for community input. Residents should watch upcoming agendas for both.
Transferred Teachers Press for Pay Parity
Why it matters: Four teachers say the district's salary rules pay veteran transferred teachers less than new hires with equal experience. Because pay steps build on each other, they say the gap grows over a career and lowers their CalSTRS pensions. CalSTRS is the state teachers' retirement system.
The basics: Under Article 8, Section 2B of the teachers' contract, teachers who transferred into Brentwood were credited for no more than seven years of prior experience. Speakers said that starting July 1, 2026, new hires may receive full credit, but current staff are not covered.
Where things stand: Leah, a sixth-grade teacher with 28 years in the classroom, said she is paid like a 14-year teacher. She noted that Mount Diablo and San Ramon Valley recognized prior experience for their current staff too. "I'm not asking for special treatment, I'm asking for equitable treatment," said Leah, public commenter.
Gabriella, an educator with more than 13 years of experience, asked the board and the teachers union, BTA, to:
- "please re-examine Article 8, Section 2B, and address the disparity affecting teachers who transferred into the district"
- study the retirement effects
- review comparable districts
- set timelines
Tanya Manfredi, a transferred teacher, cited Education Code 45028. She asked for a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with BTA to restore step parity. "We have not been shown any cost analysis or impact study," said Manfredi, public commenter.
Jill Schodeen of Edna Hill Middle School backed the Article 8 speakers.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Trustees did not respond. They cited the rule against discussing items that are not on the agenda. The coordinated comments signal that a group of mid-career transferred teachers is organizing. A fix would require bargaining with BTA and a cost estimate that speakers say has not been shared.
What's next: Speakers want the issue addressed through an MOU. Watch for it in future negotiations or on a future agenda.
Opening Moves in Classified Staff Bargaining
Why it matters: Opening proposals in public sector bargaining, known as "Sunshine" proposals, set the public agenda for talks. These talks will reopen the contract covering classified employees, the district's non-teaching staff.
The basics: Government Code 3547 requires districts to make initial bargaining proposals public before negotiations begin. The board held the required hearing, opening and closing it with 4-0 votes.
Where things stand: CSEA Chapter 894's proposal was presented as information only. It adds an association rights article, along with the standard reopeners on pay and health and welfare benefits. The district's proposal opens the vacation article plus the standard salary and health and welfare provisions.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The board approved the district's proposal. For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Trustee Thornhill). Classified workers will bargain over pay and benefits. The two sides differ on the rest of the table: the union wants association rights, while the district wants to revisit vacation.
What's next: Formal negotiations with CSEA can now proceed.
LCAP Check-In: Math Remains the Weak Spot
Why it matters: The Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP) is the state-required plan that ties district spending to student outcomes. Lagging results determine where those dollars go.
Where things stand: Staff said this mid-year report was the earliest the district had ever delivered it. On state SBAC tests:
- Language arts was 8.2 points above standard.
- Math was 19.6 points below standard.
- Progress was described as slow.
- English learner metrics dipped.
- Attendance improved, though progress on chronic absenteeism was slow.
The district will exit differentiated assistance, the county's targeted support program, in December.
Spending highlights included:
- professional learning, release time and stipends
- English language development (ELD) and Read 180 class sections
- funding for attendance efforts and busing
- site spending on culture and belonging, cited at about $3.9M and $4.11M
The other side: A board member said the district was not relying on curriculum changes to fix math. Staff agreed that instructional practice matters and acknowledged an achievement gap. "I won't sugarcoat our math scores. They're not great, right?" said a district staff presenter.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The report was informational, and no vote was taken. With county support ending, the district must close the math gap on its own.
Classroom Disruptions Meet a Task Force
Where things stand: A parent of a fifth grader said repeated disruptions by one or two students halt teaching for about 30 classmates. The parent asked the board to review its policies. "We can't have policies, even unintentionally, that end up punishing 30 kids because of the behavior of 1 or 2," said the public commenter.
Later in the meeting, staff said principals had raised the same concern during strategic planning. "So we developed this task force. We met for the first time in September," said a district staff presenter. The volunteer group met again in October, created a survey and focuses on Tier 1 and Tier 2 supports, the schoolwide and small-group levels of behavior intervention.
The other side: Staff said the parent's example sounded like Tier 3, the most intensive level of behavior support, which the task force is not yet addressing. Dudek said he hoped the county would be more involved at Tier 3. Another speaker called classroom disruption a nationwide trend.
What's next: The task force meets again in January.
- Consent calendar: Items 9.1 through 9.10 approved 4-0 without discussion.
- Closed session: Two student reinstatements reported, each approved 4-0.
- Title I: A motion to approve school-wide Title I programs drew audible ayes, but no result was declared. School-wide status lets federal funds serve all students at qualifying schools. School plans return in June.
- Promotion ceremonies: Two Edna Hill teachers raised concerns about eighth-grade promotion ceremonies.
- "Where I take issue is calling it a promotion and the ceremony itself mimicking a graduation," said Caroline Fee, eighth-grade language arts teacher, Edna Hill Middle School.
- Schodeen asked the board to rotate ceremony dates among the three middle schools.
- Honors: Eaton announced the district's 2026 California Honor Roll designation and said 170 English learners were reclassified. Edna Hill students showcased new art sections funded by Prop 28, including 3D Design and Art Journaling. "He's recovering from surgery and he's doing well," Eaton said of Trustee Thornhill, who is expected back in December.
Looking ahead: Trustees will attend a conference in early December. The board's next regular meeting is Dec. 16, 2026.