Boulder Lost 118 Officers Since 2021 as Council Digs Into Public Safety

Boulder's police chief told the City Council on Sept. 24, 2026, that the department has lost 118 officers since 2021, and he named an aging headquarters and local housing costs as reasons officers leave. The three-part public safety study session also covered police oversight and the municipal court. It closed with a non-binding 8-hand straw poll backing a new council committee to oversee the city's sister city alliances.

---

• Police are 12 short of 190 authorized officers, with nearly 30 more not yet able to patrol solo.
• Property crime is down through August, but assaults are rising. Directed patrols are up 17% and traffic stops up 27%.
• Oversight panel leaders say new complaint "gateways" left them one review in six months. Code changes are expected after an October report.
• The municipal judge defended community court and said state law and a court ruling limit jail time for repeat campers.
• An 8-hand straw poll backed two-member committee oversight of sister cities, with annual reports and a 30-day cure period.

---

Police Retention: A Building and Housing Problem

Why it matters: Short staffing limits how quickly police can respond. Half of Boulder's patrol officers have under five years on the job.

Where things stand: Police Chief Steve Redfern said nearly 30 of the 178 filled sworn positions belong to recruits in training, academy attendees or officers on injury leave. Dispatch has about 24 of 30 positions filled. Seventeen officers have left so far in 2026, with an average of nine years' experience.

"We have since 2021 lost 118 police officers, which is a staggering number," said Redfern.

Councilmember Rob Kaplan pressed for a fix: "Seriously, what is the recipe that you need from us, from staff, from the community to prevent this 118 loss since 2021?"

Redfern called 2021 an anomaly, citing COVID and the King Soopers shooting. He said exit interviews rarely cite internal culture and that union contract talks went better this year. He was blunt about the headquarters, a 1950s building never designed as a police station, as neighboring Broomfield and Erie build new ones.

"I will be very open about it because it's no secret this building is part of it," Redfern said. He described windowless rooms, HVAC failures, scalding showers, and bats, bees and mice.

Councilmember Ryan noted that housing and cost of living were missing from that list. Redfern pointed to an officer who left for Grand Junction to afford a single-family home. Deputy Chief Barry Hartkopf said his own son, a Boulder officer for seven or eight years, lives about 45 minutes away.

Crime and tools: Property crime and most crimes against people are down, but assaults and drug charges are up, the latter because of a push downtown. Redfern said calls are more complex and that Boulder still sees 20 to 30 fatal overdoses a year. He pitched Boulder Community Connect, a program that lets residents and businesses voluntarily link private cameras to police through an Axon system. He acknowledged privacy concerns and said: "It's not a— we don't watch them proactively. It's only when there's a need for us to do so."

The other side: Councilmember Tara relayed complaints about open drug use. Redfern said a 2017 state law made public use of hard drugs a summons rather than an arrest. Councilmember Tina asked about the CARE team, the city's non-police crisis response, which was restructured in last year's budget. Kurt Fernhaber of Housing and Human Services said clinicians still take some calls without police. "Our intent is when we're fully staffed, which we're close to right now, that we'll be able to increase the opportunities to go on some of those calls without PD," he said.

What's next: Staff agreed to send council race-disaggregated policing data and CARE outcome data before budget season.

---

Oversight Panel Says It's Being Starved of Cases

The basics: Boulder's civilian oversight system pairs an Independent Police Monitor with an 11-member Police Oversight Panel.

Where things stand: Independent Police Monitor Sherry Dawn reported 149 allegations in 2025. Eighteen were sustained, and the chief and oversight disagreed on eight. A new 2025 "performance and conduct" category sends some complaints to frontline supervisors instead.

Panel co-chairs say that routing has sidelined them. "We've only completed one panel review in the last 6 months," said Lizzie Friend, Co-Chair, Police Oversight Panel.

Turnover is heavy. Only three panel members from 2024 remain.

Co-Chair Bill de la Cruz blamed conflicting readings of the city ordinance. He asked for monitor involvement at each decision point, transparency for complainants routed to supervisors, and "panel involvement in proposed changes to the complaint process as problem solvers versus reacting to a solution that was created for us." Both co-chairs acknowledged deep frustration among some members.

The other side: Councilmember Taisha cited concerns from the Boulder Reporting Lab and Boulder Progressives that city code says the monitor shall receive and process complaints. "I am concerned that the attorney hasn't been brought in and there hasn't been more public comment or review of that process," she said.

Dawn said progressive discipline has led to a termination. Taisha asked whether the 19 or 20 officers who left in 2025, some of whom reportedly cited the panel, had complaint histories. Redfern agreed to provide them.

What's next: City Manager Nuria Rivera VanderMeide said the consultant leading the 5-year review, Akron's independent police auditor, will report in mid-to-late October. "We will likely be coming to you with some specific code changes in particular," she said. Panel recruitment runs from mid-December through the end of January 2027.

---

Judge: Community Court Works, but Penalties Are Capped

Why it matters: Council members hear constant complaints about repeat campers and downtown disorder. The judge explained what the city's court can control.

Where things stand: Presiding Judge Jeff Kahn stressed that felonies, drug offenses, harassment, shoplifting and theft go to state court, not municipal court. In voluntary community court, 271 camping cases were dismissed over two years after defendants completed alternative sanctions such as counseling. The court issued more than 800 warrants in 2025.

The other side: Councilmember Tara pressed for consequences for campers who repeatedly move tents. "Just being concerned is not really, in my opinion, probably good enough," she said.

Kahn said the jail won't book someone until three warrants are outstanding, and state law makes defendants eligible for personal recognizance bonds, meaning release without posting money. He said a Supreme Court ruling cut his maximum sentence for petty offenses: "They've cut my authority from 90 to 10 days on these things." He said recidivism falls to zero when people are housed. "So for those who think the program is not succeeding, they're absolutely wrong," he said. Tara said she supports the program.

Hill parties: Kahn warned about staged parties near the University of Colorado with DJs and bands drawing up to 1,000 people, which he said must be sanctioned. Mayor Aaron Brockett relayed student claims of a crackdown. Kahn said he sees none among prosecutors, and Redfern said police philosophy is unchanged. Hartkopf said noncompliance with the party registry rose this year: "If they don't do that, next step is enforcement. They are going to get a ticket."

Downtown: Kaplan relayed business complaints about harassment and blocked entrances. Kahn agreed to provide traffic versus non-traffic case outcome data. Court Administrator Devon Kissick-Kelly warned that comparison is "kind of apples and oranges."

---

Council Backs Committee to Police Sister Cities

Why it matters: Boulder has no application process for sister cities, no consequence for skipped annual reports and no way to end dormant alliances.

Where things stand: Updating Resolution 631 was a 2026 council retreat priority. Deputy City Clerk Emily Richardson said Colorado Springs was the only peer city staff contacted with a formal deactivation process. Staff confirmed the budget line mainly funds the annual dinner and that missing a report currently carries no penalty.

Councilmember Nicole proposed replacing individual council liaisons with a two-member council committee. It would use a public rubric and track annual reports. "If they don't cure it, like they don't submit a report within 30 days of receiving notice, then the committee would make a recommendation to Council to end that relationship," she said. She noted her own assigned sister city has been silent for five years.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A non-binding show of hands backed folding Nicole's model into the draft (For: 8, Against: 0). Individual hands were not recorded, and the presiding Councilmember Matt Benjamin said it looked like everybody. Kaplan called it "our Title IX reform of the sister cities."

The other side: Members split on a cap.

• Tina supported one and asked staff to consult recent Ukraine applicants.
• Brockett, who has been involved with six sister city groups, backed the direction but not necessarily a cap, citing permanent features in the sister city plaza.
• Taisha proposed nine, "because there are 9 council members." She also sought a grace period for 501(c) certification.
• Tara, who sits on the Israeli sister city board, wants an exit option and a 2016 non-political agreement extended to all sister cities. "If you start one and then 5 years later you're tired of it, there's no way out," she said.
• Taisha questioned what "political" means in that agreement.
• Benjamin preferred "sunset" to "revoke" and floated five-year renewable terms.

What's next: The committee will recommend any cap. City Clerk Alicia Johnson said the revised resolution is expected on the consent agenda unless council says otherwise.

---

Minor Items

• BVSD school closures: City staff are discussing possible city uses of closed Boulder Valley School District buildings, such as a police substation or training center.
• Bike theft: Police expect a study session on bike theft in October.
• Alcohol enforcement: A new officer is targeting businesses tied to underage drinking and fake IDs.
• Survey: Police reported 85% satisfaction among roughly 6,500 people surveyed by text.
• E-motos: Police say many youth e-motos are legally motorcycles and are tagging them and educating parents.

---

Looking ahead: Council's next regular meeting is Oct. 1. The oversight review report is due in mid-to-late October.