

Appeals Board Splits 3-1, Keeps Full Stop on 25th Street Rebuild
Board of Appeals • San FranciscoNovember 4, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
The San Francisco Board of Appeals on Nov. 4, 2026, refused to partially lift a permit suspension at 3829 25th Street, where crews removed far more of the house than the city approved. The 3-1 vote sends the project to a Planning Commission conditional use hearing before major work resumes. Commissioners urged the owners and neighbors to use separate permits to protect the exposed structure from winter weather.
- 3-1 vote keeps full suspension at 3829 25th Street after more than two hours of testimony.
- Neighbors back weather protection but want Planning Commission review before any roof goes up.
- Wilder Street retaining wall permit upheld 4-0. DBI will verify drainage in the field.
Over-Demolition Keeps 25th Street Project Frozen
Why it matters: Planning and the Department of Building Inspection (DBI) called partial suspensions rare and hard to administer. With the appeal denied, no construction resumes until the project wins a conditional use authorization. That is a Planning Commission approval required when a project exceeds its demolition limits.
Where things stand: Planning requested suspension of permit 2025-0603 after a site visit found crews had removed east wall framing and more than 90% of the front facade framing. The approved limit was 62%.
The owners did not contest the violation. "During construction, a subcontractor made an honest mistake that we neither knew about nor authorized," said Pajita Mathur, owner. General contractor Daniel Casorla conceded that "framing designated to remain was removed beyond the approved demolition limits. That was a mistake." Asked by Commissioner Jose Lopez how the case surfaced, Casorla said "it came from an anonymous complaint."
Project architect Troy Kishanipour asked for "a limited removal of the stop work order so that the contractor can stabilize the building up to the roof level." That would allow framing to the roof, a roof and flashing, and neighbor protection before winter storms. He cited a similar case at 649 28th Street.
The basics: Asked by Commissioner Robin Abad Ocubillo why the demolition thresholds exist, Zoning Administrator Corey Teague said they began as Planning Commission policy. The Board of Supervisors later wrote them into the Planning Code. "The root issue is housing affordability," Teague said. He also cited tenant and occupancy concerns. The project would add one unit on net.
The other side: Teague and Senior Building Inspector Kerry McElroy of DBI recommended keeping the full suspension. Both offered to take a week to draft a partial suspension if the board wanted one. Teague said Planning "always supports any additional permitting that may be necessary in the meantime to ensure safety, structural safety, as well as weather protection."
The two officials gave different timelines. Teague put the earliest restart in early 2027. McElroy estimated "it'd probably be mid-January."
Commissioner Lopez was the lone dissenter. "I do think that a partial suspension is appropriate here," he said, adding that a full suspension "just feels draconian to me personally." He proposed sending the requested scope of work to the departments for review.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "I would deny the appeal and uphold the suspension," said Board President John Trasviña. He also opposed a continuance, pointing to the departments' consistent recommendation. Commissioner Lily Wong said "it sounds like it's actually faster for them to get a separate permit." Abad Ocubillo, while sympathetic to the owners, said crafting a partial suspension "introduces a lot more risk."
The motion found that the zoning administrator did not err or abuse his discretion. It also encouraged the parties to obtain permits addressing safety and weather. Vote: For: 3 (Trasviña, Wong, Abad Ocubillo), Against: 1 (Lopez), Absent: 1 (Vice President Rebecca Saroyan).
The Mathur family stays out of its home longer. Neighbors get the full Planning Commission review they asked for.
What's next: The owners can apply for separate safety and weatherproofing permits, which Planning and DBI said they would support. The project then heads to a conditional use hearing.
Neighbors Want Protection Now, Planning Review First
Why it matters: Neighbors said a revision permit issued the day before the hearing added a rooftop hot tub and a third-floor balcony. They feared the roof would be built before they ever got a hearing.
Where things stand: Michael Demetrius, a neighbor across the street for 28 years, urged denial. He asked the board to allow only protective permits until the Planning Commission hears the project. "The only thing between those permits and a finished roof is the suspension," he said.
A neighbor identified as Paul said a hot tub came up at the pre-application meeting but never appeared on the original plans. He argued the project is a rebuild, not a remodel, and should follow the original blueprint.
Weather worries: An adjacent senior neighbor said she feared water damage and mold. She said no one had told her about the weather risk, and she asked for help.
Erica Katrak, who lives across the street, supported letting Planning Commission review proceed. She also wants weather and safety protection to move forward, and said she wants the Mathurs back home.
A caller identified as Ms. Young questioned the contractor's photo of exposed walls. She said the walls appeared to be the project's new framing, not neighboring buildings. She added that waterproofing is needed where the project's roof peeled off the building next door.
The other side: Georgia Sutish, a public commenter, said she was sympathetic to the owners. She warned that a partial suspension like the one at 649 28th Street raises enforcement questions and could neuter review under the demolition code. She urged a Planning Commission hearing.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Kishanipour said the owners would drop the hot tub. He said they would also exclude the roof deck and stair penthouse from any lifted suspension. Planning and DBI said the revision permit cannot move forward while the parent permit is suspended. Neighbors can file complaints with DBI.
What's next: Neighbors will get their say at the Planning Commission's conditional use hearing.
Wilder Street Wall Permit Survives Absent Appellant
Why it matters: The board left a neighbor's flooding claims to DBI field inspection rather than reversing the permit.
Where things stand: Appeal 26-032 challenged a permit legalizing repairs to an L-shaped retaining wall at 18 Wilder Street. The appellant, Christopher Rodehau, did not answer calls or join the hearing, so the board relied on his written materials.
"The task before the board this evening is to determine if DBI approved and issued the appealed permit in error," said Emily Charlie, representative for the permit holders. She argued the wall work did not cause the flooding, citing a structural engineer and rainfall history.
Teague called it "a very simple, straightforward permit for the Planning Department." McElroy said the plans show drainage behind the new wall section, and the field inspector will verify construction.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Abad Ocubillo said "there seems to be a correlation there" between the wall work and the flooding. He still moved denial on the grounds that the permit was not improperly issued. Vote: For: 4, Against: 0, Absent: 1 (Saroyan).
Minor Items
- 15 Park Hill Avenue (Appeal 26-048): Granted 4-0 under an agreed settlement. Revised Oct. 29, 2026, plans add rear-deck planters creating 3-foot setbacks. The parties waived rehearing so the written decision could issue the next day.
- 678 Vermont Street (Appeal 26-047): Continued 4-0 to Dec. 9, 2026, with the appellants' agreement, so a full board can hear it. Four votes are needed to grant an appeal.
- 1511 Lyon Street (Appeal 26-058): Continued 4-0 to Nov. 10 after the appellant received the department's brief late.
- Disclosure: Commissioner Wong disclosed her service on the Community Equity Advisory Council.
- Minutes: The board adopted its Oct. 28, 2026, minutes 4-0.
Looking Ahead
The Lyon Street appeal returns Nov. 10, and Vermont Street follows Dec. 9. The next major step for 3829 25th Street is a Planning Commission conditional use hearing.