

Bloomfield Townhouse Plan Wins 4-2 Majority but Fails Five-Vote Test
Zoning Board of Adjustment • BloomfieldNovember 5, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
A five-unit townhouse plan for a Liberty Street lot that has sat vacant for about 14 years won majority support from Bloomfield's Zoning Board of Adjustment on Nov. 5, 2026, and still lost. The approval motion drew four yes votes and two no votes, one short of the five affirmative votes a use variance requires. The board also approved three smaller residential cases and halted a fourth over defective public notice.
- 118-128 Liberty Street townhouses denied despite 4-2 vote; use variances need five votes
- Board rules 6-0 that a 2014 denial does not bar the revised five-unit plan
- Unpermitted Beach Street backyard work legalized 4-1 with lot coverage near 69.5%
- 6 Stone Street driveway case halted: defective notice leaves the board without jurisdiction
Liberty Street Townhouses Fall One Vote Short
The basics: A D-1 use variance lets a property owner build a use the zone does not permit. Applicants must show "special reasons," including that the site is particularly suited to the use. They must also meet the Medici "enhanced quality of proof" standard on negative criteria and consistency with the zone plan.
Why it matters: The five-vote threshold applies no matter how many members attend. A majority of the six members voting backed the project, and the lot stays empty.
Where things stand: Integrity Holdings and Development sought to build five townhouses on a vacant R-2A lot, where only two-family homes are permitted. Attorney Robert Gassion of Gassion Pomacco presented revised plans. They included a 5-foot sidewalk with an ADA ramp, ADA and EV parking, a 10-by-10 masonry trash enclosure, fencing, a bike rack, added landscaping and fire sprinklers.
Board engineer Anthony Marucci noted the trash enclosure sat 2.9 feet from the property line. Gassion agreed to move it: "Should this be approved, we'll amend the plan to move that to the 5-foot distance from the property line," said Robert Gassion, attorney for the applicant. Board attorney Michael Rubin flagged that the 6-foot side-yard fence would also need a variance.
Planner Lindsay Knight argued the site works as a buffer between multifamily and commercial uses and single-family homes. "The enhanced quality of proof is satisfied because the proposed townhouse is particularly suited to this vacant infill parcel," said Lindsay Knight, planner. Knight also acknowledged the master plan does not specifically call for townhouses.
Board traffic engineer Kevin Chen asked that his Nov. 2, 2026, letter be made part of any approval. The only public commenter, Stephanie Tirado, a neighbor on Walnut Street, asked where the east-side fence would go. The applicant's engineer said it would sit inside the applicant's property and would not touch her existing fence.
The other side: Marucci said the lot could instead hold two two-family homes with a minor subdivision and a slight frontage variance. Members also doubted that a homeowners association would maintain the property over the long term. "HOA doesn't go with the land," said Board Member Ryan Wangner.
Board Member Edgardo Perez moved to deny. "I don't think that the proofs were met. I think this neighborhood is not in transition," said Board Member Edgardo Perez.
Board Member Mark Santasieri disagreed, pointing to the planner's and traffic engineer's testimony and the absence of neighbor objections. "I do think the Medici was met. I don't see the significant negative criteria," said Board Member Mark Santasieri. "I tend to agree with Mr. Santasieri," said Board Member Joyce Sun.
Board Chair Ray McCarthy seconded the denial motion for discussion and then signaled he was open to the project given the long vacancy. "If we can't put two two-family houses there, I could be inclined to support the five townhouses," said Board Chair Ray McCarthy.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts:
- Motion to deny: tied and failed. For: 3 (Wangner, Perez, Mohan), Against: 3 (Santasieri, Sun, McCarthy).
- Motion to approve: conditioned on Marucci's report, Chen's letter and the fence variance. For: 4 (Wangner, Santasieri, Sun, McCarthy), Against: 2 (Perez, Mohan), Absent: 0.
- Wangner switched to yes during that roll call: "I am changing my vote," he said.
- "4 votes, it needed 5. The motion's denied. The application is denied," said Michael Rubin, board attorney.
The developer leaves without approval, and the vacant lot remains under its two-family zoning.
What's next: The board did not discuss any next steps for the site. For residents, the open question is whether a by-right plan for two two-family homes, which Marucci described, comes forward instead.
Board Rules 2014 Denial Doesn't Block New Plan
The basics: Res judicata is a legal doctrine that can bar a board from rehearing an application substantially similar to one it already denied.
Where things stand: The board denied a seven-townhouse plan for the site in 2014. That plan needed D-4 floor-area-ratio and D-5 density variances. Knight noted "the previous application was requesting 7 townhomes as opposed to the application at hand, which is only requesting 5 townhomes," with no FAR or density variance now sought.
Board planner George Williams walked through the test from the Cox treatise. Citing a South Orange case, he said the board could find the doctrine did not apply. Gassion argued the revisions far outstripped the earlier plan: "The magnitude of this change is so great that I don't think it comes close to being res judicata," said Robert Gassion, attorney for the applicant.
Rubin explained that D variance cases differ from C variance cases. He also cited case law construing changes liberally in the applicant's favor and stressed the decision belonged to the board. He drew a firm line between the two legal questions: "I don't believe that there's any relationship between res judicata and Medici," said Michael Rubin, board attorney.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Santasieri moved that res judicata did not apply, and Wangner seconded. For: 6, Against: 0, Absent: 0. The ruling cleared the way for a vote on the merits and shows applicants that cutting density can reopen a door closed a decade earlier.
Beach Street Backyard Legalized After the Fact
Why it matters: The board granted retroactive relief for work that pushed lot coverage above 69.5% in an R-1A zone capped at 45%.
Where things stand: Dr. Sean Egan, the applicant at 50 Beach Street, said a contractor told him permits were unnecessary. "I ended up paying the summons, going to court, pled guilty that I broke the rules regardless whether it's unknowing or not," said Egan.
The work included:
- A replacement pool deck and a walkway
- An 8-by-8 hot tub slab
- A gazebo and a bar shed
- A 6-foot side-yard fence
Marucci listed the C variances needed for accessory building count, size and height, the hot tub's side-yard location, fence height and lot coverage. He said drainage was not a concern because the lot is flat. He urged permits and inspections for the electrical work: "The purpose of the permits is to protect you," said Anthony Marucci, board engineer. The Historic Preservation Commission had already approved the improvements.
The other side: Perez questioned which structures were actually before the board and cast the lone no vote.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: McCarthy moved approval and Santasieri seconded. For: 4 (Santasieri, Sun, Mohan, McCarthy), Against: 1 (Perez). Wangner had left the meeting.
Stone Street Driveway Case Halted Over Notice
Where things stand: James Wong, the owner of a two-family home at 6 Stone Street, wants to widen the driveway on his corner lot in an R-1B zone. The wider driveway would fit a third car and preserve a street parking spot.
Marucci agreed the widening expands a nonconforming use. Rubin said that triggers a D-2 variance, which Wong's C-variance notice did not cover. "Your notice is defective. And this board has no jurisdiction when notice is improper," said Michael Rubin, board attorney.
Why it matters: Any approval granted without proper notice would have been invalid. Wong now faces a delay and a higher burden of proof, since a D-2 variance also requires five affirmative votes.
What's next: Rubin offered help preparing the new notice. Amanda Waters, Planning Board and Zoning Board secretary, will schedule a new hearing date.
Minor Items
- 29 Stone Street: Approved 4-0, with Mohan recused, for a 10-by-12 rear walk-in closet. Building coverage will be 26.77% against 25% allowed, and lot coverage 61.16% against 60%; a resolution is still required.
- 101 Sylvan Road: Approved 4-0, with Perez recused, for a rear shed dormer adding a bedroom and bathroom. "We're keeping the existing ridge where it currently is," said architect Lawrence Quirk; the board granted no variance for the existing lack of a garage.
- 45 Elm Brook Place: The board accepted the applicant's withdrawal by voice vote, with no ruling on the merits.
- Minutes: Minutes from the Oct. 22 meeting were approved by voice vote.
Looking Ahead
The Liberty Street outcome shows how the five-vote threshold can turn a majority into a denial. Residents near Liberty Street should watch for any new filing for the lot. Neighbors within 200 feet of 6 Stone Street should expect a fresh notice once Waters sets the D-2 hearing date.