Locunity — where decisions happen.
Police Defend Flock Cameras as Residents Raise Privacy, Cost Concerns

Police Defend Flock Cameras as Residents Raise Privacy, Cost Concerns

Town Council • Black MountainNovember 9, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Black Mountain police gave the outgoing Town Council a detailed defense of the town's five Flock license plate cameras on Nov. 9, 2026. Two residents answered with constitutional and cost objections. No vote was taken; instead, the mayor asked police to bring a stricter, rewritten policy back so the incoming board can review it. The same council tabled a street-access zoning change, took no action on a leaking public safety building, and heard that a delayed audit is blocking town borrowing while the State Bureau of Investigation reviews possible misspending.


  • Flock policy heads to the new board after police detail limits on the town's five plate readers
  • Residents cite the Fourth Amendment, privacy and a $12,000 bill in opposing the cameras
  • Delayed audit stalls borrowing as the mayor says the SBI is reviewing possible misspent funds
  • No motion on the public safety building despite active water intrusion and a $16,500 roof proposal
  • Street-access amendment tabled after a public hearing exposed unclear road-acceptance standards
  • Buncombe County inspections deal moved, but the vote result was not announced

Flock Cameras: Police Make Their Case

Why it matters: License plate readers log every passing vehicle at the town's main entrances. The rules on who can search that data, and for how long, now rest with an incoming board.

Where things stand: Assistant Police Chief Coon said the town has used Flock since 2023. Its five cameras sit on private property along main roads into town. He laid out the safeguards:

  • Alerts are tied to National Crime Information Center data
  • Officers must verify any hit before acting
  • No facial recognition is used
  • Data is kept for 30 days
  • Every search requires a case number
  • Out-of-state, federal, auto-approved, immigration and reproductive-care searches are disabled

Coon cited vehicle recoveries and investigations the system has aided. He said the department budgeted $15,000 for the cameras, but the most recent bill came to $12,000.

Mayor C. Michael Sobol did not reject the technology, but he set conditions. "But for government agencies to do it, I think it needs to have heavy, heavy scrutiny," said Mayor Sobol. He told police to "go ahead and bring that back to the board so that the new board members can also review it."

The other side: Two residents used citizen comments to oppose the program outright. Jay File, a public commenter, objected to paying for the cameras with property tax dollars and questioned how long the vendor keeps data. "I'm concerned about the increase in just lack of privacy and spying on our local citizens," said File.

Michael Schumacher, a public commenter, cited court rulings and cities that have ended their Flock contracts. "There are very serious Fourth Amendment constitutional issues with this technology," said Schumacher.

Sobol's response focused on money rather than constitutional questions. He suggested opponents raise their cost objections when the budget is built in the spring.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: This was an informational briefing, so the council took no vote. The cameras keep running under current rules. Police and the incoming council will shape the next policy. Residents focused on privacy have two openings: the policy review and spring budget talks, where the roughly $12,000 annual line item will be decided.

What's next: Police will return with the rewritten policy for the new board's review. Budget discussions are expected in the spring.


Audit Delay Freezes Borrowing as SBI Steps In

Why it matters: The state Local Government Commission (LGC), which must sign off on local government debt, will not approve town borrowing until the audit is complete. That puts capital project financing on hold.

Where things stand: Finance Director Jay Copley reported that through Oct. 31, general fund revenues were $2,273,180 and expenditures were $4,244,000. The general fund totals about $13.25M. The gap reflects timing: most property tax revenue arrives in December and January. Staff said overall spending is tracking under budget and that every invoice is now reviewed before payment.

The audit was due Dec. 31, but staff expect it to be late.

During council communications, Mayor Sobol said he had met with the State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) about town money that may not have been spent wisely. No further details on the scope of that review were provided.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No action was required. The new invoice-review practice signals tighter internal controls. Still, the audit delay and the SBI review together leave the incoming board facing a credibility test with state overseers and residents. Cheryl Milton, a public commenter, thanked outgoing members and pledged to keep examining the town's finances.

What's next: Watch for the audit's completion. Until then, the LGC will not approve any borrowing.


Public Safety Building: Leaks Continue, No Motion

Why it matters: Water is still getting into the public safety building. Two engineering reviews point to deeper structural questions, and the repair decision now passes to the next board.

Where things stand: Staff walked through two reports. One was from Mosley Architects, cited at about $35,000; the other was from Stewart. Both found settling in floors and walls that needs further exploration.

Mayor Sobol argued the building is not a life-safety concern and pressed for a quick fix. "I would hope that the board would move forward and appropriate $16,500 to Benton Roofing to fix the roof and the gutters," said Mayor Sobol.

The other side: Others noted that multiple bids are required and said more information is needed before spending money. "I still don't feel comfortable moving forward until there's a little more definitive information," said one council member.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No motion was made. The leak continues while the town weighs a roof repair against further excavation. Police and other staff working in the building bear the near-term cost of the delay.

What's next: The incoming board inherits the choice between a roof-and-gutter repair and further structural investigation.


Street-Access Amendment Tabled for More Detail

The basics: Chapter 4 of the Land Use Code governs street requirements for new development. Staff proposed replacing the phrase "public or private street" with "publicly accessible" streets.

Why it matters: According to staff, the current wording has led developers to believe the town must build their roads. Developers still lack clear standards for when the town will accept a street.

Where things stand: The Planning Board recommended the change. At the public hearing, one speaker urged the town to keep its practice of taking over developer-built streets. A second asked for clear specifications for streets the town would accept. Speakers also noted that town acceptance of a street is not automatic.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Mayor Sobol said the amendment needed to be more specific. The council voted by voice to table it; the tally was not announced. Council member Alice Berry was reported absent due to illness. Developers will continue working under the existing language for now.

What's next: The amendment returns only when the council chooses to revisit it, likely under the new board.


Building Inspections May Shift to Buncombe County

Why it matters: The town has only a Level 1 inspector. A county partnership would change who reviews more complex projects, and at what fees.

Where things stand: Staff said about 90% of current permits are residential Level 1 work. "Buncombe County has currently agreed to perform all of our inspections that will be above a Level 1," said town staff. Under the proposed interlocal agreement, the county could handle higher-level inspections or all inspections. The town would adopt county fees, and the local inspector's job is not guaranteed.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: A council member moved to approve the resolution, but the result was not announced. Builders should expect county fee schedules if the agreement takes effect.


Minor Items

  • Service revolver: The council approved, by voice vote with no opposition heard, awarding retiring Police Chief Steve Parker his service revolver, as state statute allows and as past chiefs received.
  • Fire training conference: Deputy Fire Chief James Bingham said the town will host a national truck company training conference Feb. 8–12, 2027. Organizers expect more than 500 participants at a 46,000-square-foot facility.
  • Consent agenda: A motion was made to approve, with the golf course grant resolution (7F) subject to the town attorney's edits; the result was not announced. Richard Hudson, a public commenter, urged that the grant money go first to creek bank maintenance.
  • Front Street speeding: Resident Lawrence said the state declined requests for speed bumps on the road, so neighbors are circulating a petition. Mayor Sobol asked that it go to the next board.
  • Emergency housing appeal: Frank Capelli alleged that staff approved emergency housing without notice and delayed notice of the appeal outcome. "Residents are people to serve, not opponents to defeat," said Capelli.

Looking Ahead

The incoming board inherits a crowded docket: the rewritten Flock policy, the public safety building repairs, the tabled street-access amendment, the Front Street petition and a delayed audit that is holding up any new borrowing.