Locunity — where decisions happen.
Tear Gas Reinstatement Draws Hours of Opposition, Deferred to Special Meeting

Tear Gas Reinstatement Draws Hours of Opposition, Deferred to Special Meeting

City Council • BerkeleySeptember 16, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Berkeley's City Council spent a marathon evening dominated by a fierce debate over whether to restore police access to tear gas — a tool banned unanimously during the 2020 George Floyd protests — only to run out of time and equipment before a vote could be taken. The council also cleared a packed consent calendar that included wildfire legislation, a coal terminal opposition resolution, and a commercial vacancy strategy, while the morning's closure of the Harrison Street encampment drew raw public anger into the evening.

  • Tear gas reinstatement debate draws 30+ speakers unanimously opposed; continued to Sept. 29 special meeting
  • Harrison Street encampment cleared amid court battles; public commenters condemn the action
  • Council opposes coal and petroleum coke operations in the Bay Area, backs AB 40
  • Sweeping commercial vacancy strategy referred to City Manager, but critics demand deadlines
  • Council urges Governor to sign eight wildfire resiliency bills before Sept. 30 deadline
  • Neighborhood decarbonization pilot endorsed with PG&E partnership

The Fight Over Tear Gas: Every Speaker Said No

The most contentious item of the night — and ultimately unresolved — pitted two competing proposals against each other and the full weight of public opposition.

The basics: In 2020, the Berkeley City Council unanimously banned police use of chemical agents, including tear gas, during the national reckoning over police violence. Item 21a, authored by Councilmember Rashi Kesarwani, District 1, would reinstate BPD's ability to deploy tear gas solely in barricaded suspect and hostage situations, keeping the crowd-control ban intact. Item 21b, from the Peace and Justice Commission, would retain the full ban and commission an academic health study before any policy change.

Why it matters: Reversing even a narrow piece of the 2020 ban would undo one of Berkeley's signature progressive policing reforms — in a city closely watched nationally on police accountability — less than six weeks before a November election.

Where things stand: Councilmember Brent Blackaby, District 6, presented supplemental amendments negotiated with the Police Accountability Board that narrowed the authorized uses to just three scenarios. "We sort of eliminated the other potential high-risk situations. It's just at suspects shooting at officers during warrant service, hostage rescue situations, and armed barricaded suspects," he said.

Councilmember Kesarwani framed the reinstatement as a measured response to operational gaps, noting the narrow historical record. "Over more than 40 years, BPD Special Response Team has used tear gas exactly once during a barricaded subject incident in the early 2000s," she said.

A BPD captain testified that three incidents since 2020 could have warranted tear gas but didn't require it. He described the tool as a way to avoid lethal force. "This tool impacts the environment and gives us the option potentially of creating an environment that the suspect wants to come out of," the captain said.

The other side: The Peace and Justice Commission urged the council to reject 21a entirely. George, presenting on behalf of the commission, invoked BPD's conduct during the 2014 Black Lives Matter protests, when "officers shot less-lethal projectiles into the crowd, hit marchers with batons and launched some 50 cans of CS gas, such a large amount that they nearly exhausted their supply."

An estimated 30 or more public speakers then testified — every one of them opposed to reinstating tear gas. Their arguments converged on several themes: health risks including reproductive harm from chemical agents; the impossibility of containing aerosolized chemicals to a targeted area; BPD's history of misuse; the rarity of incidents proving the tool is unnecessary; and the inconsistency of opposing coal dust while authorizing chemical weapons.

Moni Law Calumnia, a peace activist and attorney, described being clubbed and gassed during the 2014 protests and filing a federal class-action lawsuit against the city. Glenn Turner, speaking from the Behavioral Health Commission, argued the extremely low probability of needing tear gas meant funds should go to crisis intervention training instead. An analytical chemist with 13 years of experience cited peer-reviewed studies on reproductive health effects and corneal injuries from tear gas exposure. Kelly Hammergrum referenced a Minneapolis Star Tribune investigation finding 1,300 ppm of lead contamination in soil from tear gas deployment. Solly Alpert, the Rent Board chair speaking in a personal capacity, argued Berkeley should call in a specialized agency for rare hostage situations rather than equip BPD.

Mimi, a District 8 resident, drew a contrast with other contentious issues: unlike the divided Hopkins Street bike lane debate, she noted, every single public speaker opposed tear gas reinstatement — and asked how the council could act against unanimous constituency opposition.

Decisions: No vote was taken on the substance of either item. Audio equipment failed late in the evening, and a motion to extend the meeting past midnight failed 5-4 (For: Kesarwani, O'Keefe, Blackaby, Humbert; Against: Bartlett, Tregub, Lunaparra, Ishii), falling short of the required supermajority.

What's next: Mayor Adena Ishii moved to continue both items to a special meeting on Sept. 29 at 4 p.m. That motion passed 7-1, with Councilmember Igor Tregub, District 4, casting the lone no vote. The two-week delay gives opponents additional time to organize before a final vote that will land less than six weeks before the November election.


Encampment Cleared, Community Anger Erupts

Though not a formal agenda item, the morning closure of the Harrison Street encampment at 8th and Harrison dominated both the city manager's report and public comment.

Why it matters: The closure followed nearly two years of litigation with the Berkeley Homeless Union; the city is now appealing Ninth Circuit rulings that required it to evaluate alternative encampment sites. Critics say Berkeley lacks any sanctioned encampment or adequate winter shelter plan.

Where things stand: The City Manager opened with a detailed statement on court compliance and the city's position. "The city does not suggest locations for people to camp, nor does the city approve locations for encampments. We know that living outside lowers life expectancy, and our goal is to end unsheltered homelessness by moving people indoors," he said.

Mayor Ishii acknowledged the limits of the action. "Clearing the encampment is not by itself a solution and it doesn't end anyone's homelessness. It just changes where the immediate problem of homelessness is visible," she said.

Councilmember Blackaby defended the closure on public health grounds — including leptospirosis and fire hazards — while calling for durable, long-term solutions. "We can't allow a situation like this to reform once abatement is complete. That's not a win for public health, for public safety, for the unhoused individuals, nor the rest of our community," he said.

Councilmember Kesarwani noted the timeline: "We initially sought to close this encampment in January 2025. It's now September 2026 because of the litigation that was brought forward by the Berkeley Homeless Union."

The other side: Multiple public commenters passionately condemned the closure. Alana called the eviction traumatizing and demanded a Safe Stay sanctioned encampment. Cheryl described the scene as looking "like Gaza." Jesse Sheehan accused city staff of breaking the law and threatened political consequences for the mayor. Yesica, a Berkeley Homeless Union representative, alleged the city failed to provide required disability accommodations and threatened contempt proceedings. Several commenters noted no councilmembers were present at the actual closure.

What's next: The city's appeal to the Ninth Circuit could set regional precedent on encampment litigation and municipal obligations to evaluate alternative sites.


Berkeley Opposes Coal in the Bay Area

Why it matters: A proposed coal terminal in Oakland would route mile-long trains through Berkeley, exposing residents near parks and schools to toxic particulate matter. Item 19, authored by Councilmember Tregub and co-sponsored by Councilmember Kesarwani, Councilmember Terry Taplin, District 2, and Mayor Ishii, passed unanimously on the consent calendar.

The resolution opposes coal and petroleum coke handling in the San Francisco Bay region and supports AB 40, which would impose stricter environmental protections. Councilmember Tregub praised the initiative: "I'm also very proud of our city for standing up to coal yet again in Item 19." Councilmember Cecilia Lunaparra, District 7, connected the resolution to grassroots organizing by the No Coal in Oakland campaign, and speakers referenced a rally of 200 people at University and Bonar.

Ariella Grinnett of the Berkeley 350 Hub described mile-long coal trains exposing hundreds of thousands of residents to pollution. Megan Wachspros, a parent, spoke of health risks to children playing on sports fields near the rail line. Several public speakers drew a pointed parallel: opposing coal dust while authorizing chemical agents struck them as contradictory.


Commercial Vacancy Strategy: Big Plans, No Deadlines

Why it matters: Downtown Berkeley and commercial corridors face persistent ground-floor retail vacancies that multiple speakers described as "ghost town" conditions.

Where things stand: Item 20, the RENAISSANCE Part 2 referral authored by Councilmember Tregub with co-sponsors Councilmember Shoshana O'Keefe, District 5, and Councilmember Blackaby, directs the City Manager and City Attorney to develop an integrated strategy against commercial vacancy and blight. Proposed tools include cold shell prevention, warm shell requirements, and storefront subdivision.

The other side: Public commenters praised the intent but hammered the execution. Donald Simon, president of Save Berkeley Shops, argued against issuing demolition permits before developers prove financing and said warm shell requirements are unenforceable for projects using state density bonuses. Paola Laverde called the referral "all talk and no action," citing its lack of deadlines, accountability mechanisms, or metrics of success. A commission member urged target dates for the referral to return to council.

What's next: The referral now sits with the City Manager. Without deadlines built in, advocates have signaled they will push for concrete timelines when the item returns.


Wildfire Bills and Fire Prevention Progress

Why it matters: With more than 600 of 1,400 ember zone homes on the path to compliance, Berkeley has a direct stake in state wildfire mitigation funding.

Councilmember Blackaby presented the urgent item, explaining that eight wildfire resiliency bills covering homeowner financing, innovation units, county coordinator support, home hardening, and community grants passed the legislature in late August and await the Governor's signature by Sept. 30. He noted he sent a letter co-signed by 250 District 6 residents.

On the related Fireside software contract (Item 5), Councilmember Blackaby highlighted progress: "Of the 1,400 homes in the ember zone, more than 600 are already on the path to zone zero and home hardening compliance, which is amazing." The community chipper program has completed 2,400 pickups removing 6,000 cubic yards of vegetation.

Anne Marks of PG&E praised the wildfire bills. A public commenter raised privacy concerns about Fireside's data practices, arguing the contract may violate Article 1, Section 1 of the California Constitution by stockpiling private information in a database managed by a private entity.


Decarbonization Pilot Gets Green Light

Item 13, supporting a neighborhood-scale decarbonization pilot under SB 1221, passed on the consent calendar. Mayor Ishii noted that "greenhouse gas emissions declined 41% since the 2000 baseline in Berkeley." Councilmember Tregub thanked the Environmental and Climate Commission and Commissioner Daniel Tahara for initiating the pilot. Anne Marks of PG&E said the utility would be "delighted to partner," calling decarbonization and electrification "the future."


Minor Items

  • Whistleblower report on workplace policies: City Auditor Jenny Wong presented findings that Berkeley's workplace relationship policies don't address romantic relationships intersecting with employment decisions. "Berkeley's policies are more limited than approaches used by nearby cities of Oakland and San Francisco, which does address a broader range of personal relationships and provide additional tools for managing conflicts of interest," she said. Recommendations include Municipal Code changes on nepotism and cronyism.
  • $500K Civic Center resilience grant: Council authorized a grant application to the California Strategic Growth Council for seismic retrofit planning of two historic civic buildings (Item 1).
  • $150K Addison Street catenary lighting: Contract awarded to the Downtown Berkeley Association for decorative overhead lighting in the arts district (Item 2).
  • Loan Administration Board dissolved: Board had not met for two years due to lack of members; Revolving Loan Fund oversight moves to City Manager (Item 3).
  • $410K Fireside wildfire software contract expanded for fire department inspections (Item 5).
  • $65K grant to Gilman District Merchants Association for street fair and business sustainability (Item 15).
  • Housing fee study ordered: Council referred a comprehensive assessment of all housing-related impact, development, and local parcel tax fees to compare Berkeley's total cost burden against peer cities (Item 16). Co-sponsors Councilmember Humbert, District 8, and Councilmember Lunaparra were added.
  • Evans Manor conditions: Public commenter Derek Wallace, an Evans Manor tenant at a Berkeley Student Cooperative property, described extreme conditions including mold, asbestos, rats, and security failures, and asked the city to intervene.