Locunity — where decisions happen.
Belvedere Approves Conditional Flood Barrier Funds Ahead of Winter Tides

Belvedere Approves Conditional Flood Barrier Funds Ahead of Winter Tides

City Council • BelvedereNovember 9, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Belvedere is racing the calendar. With peak tides above 7 feet predicted for the day before Thanksgiving, the City Council on Nov. 9, 2026, declared a local El Niño emergency and authorized unspecified funds for temporary flood barriers on Beach Road and San Rafael Avenue. The council attached conditions after members admitted the San Rafael barrier has never been tested locally. Earlier in the evening, the council also launched the first formal study of whether the city's six-officer police department can sustain itself.


  • Temporary flood barriers approved with conditions after about 90 minutes of debate over wind, drains and unchecked references
  • Local emergency declared effective Nov. 9, unlocking emergency contracting before king tides arrive
  • Police assessment funded at just over $87,000. Members insisted no merger with Tiburon is planned.

A Stopgap Wall, Approved With Strings Attached

Why it matters: Two of Belvedere's waterfront routes sit about 8 feet above the tide datum, below the city's protection target. Tides on Oct. 29 already ran 1.5 feet above predictions. Peak astronomical tides are forecast for the day before Thanksgiving, the day before Christmas and Jan. 21, 2027.

The basics: Stetson Engineers set the design target using federal flood mapping. "FEMA developed a 1% stillwater elevation of 9.7 feet," said Julian Fulweiler of Stetson Engineers. Stillwater elevation is the projected water level without waves. A 1% event has a 1-in-100 chance of occurring in any given year. The pathways along Tiburon Boulevard and West Shore Road already meet that height. Beach Road and San Rafael Avenue do not.

Where things stand: The plan has two parts:

  • Beach Road: Panels would fill about 200 feet of open railing near China Cabin, with sandbags at gangways and buildings.
  • San Rafael Avenue: A 20-inch, L-shaped NOAC Box Wall barrier would run along about 1,500 feet of the road.

Staff compared three options: water bladders, rigid water-filled barriers and the L-shaped wall. They examined protection heights from 9 to 11 feet and judged 9 to 10 feet practical. "The L-shaped barrier was the only product that showed that it was able to withstand wave action," said Tony, a city staff presenter. The product carries a five-year warranty with a 70% buyback. The San Rafael path would be closed to pedestrians for most of the winter.

City Manager Robert Zadnik said the goal is emergency access, not private property. "We're looking to protect city's infrastructure," he said.

Wind, Gravel and Unchecked References

The other side: Council members raised the sharpest doubts themselves. Councilmember Peter Mark read aloud from the product's own specifications: "Once Boxwell is in action as a flood barrier, the water covering the horizontal base, it is not affected by winds, but before the water arrives, it is wind susceptible." He also noted the warranty depends on water-filled storm anchors. Staff acknowledged they had not read that language. They said they would revisit anchoring with T-stakes and sandbags.

Vice Mayor Kevin Burke questioned the surface along San Rafael Avenue, a path of decomposed granite (DG). "I worry that the DG is not flat, it's not even, and it's probably easily eroded," he said. Burke also noted the supplier's references come mostly from Southern California. Staff confirmed that gap. "We have been provided with references by the supplier, but we haven't been in touch with any of them at this point," Tony said.

Councilmember Pat Carapiet called the Beach Road fix simple but wanted more research on San Rafael Avenue. She warned that "we're giving false hope." Mark pushed on process: "That's a pretty big decision that we're making to authorize that to happen without any sort of community involvement."

Residents Ask Who Pays if the Wall Fails

Four public commenters weighed in, mostly with questions about the details:

  • Alex Higbee, a San Rafael-area resident and boatyard operator, asked about drains backing up and whether staff would be on station during high tides. He also asked who bears the damage if a barrier is breached. He said the barriers do the road a disservice, with effects on insurance and resale.
  • Larry Storr recalled waves crossing Beach Road in the early 1980s. He worried that plugging drains could flood the road. "I think you really need to reconsider the water bladders," he said.
  • Dr. Rothman, recalling past lagoon flooding, urged staff to verify the manufacturer's claims under comparable storm, wave and wind conditions. "You're really making quite a commitment here," he said.
  • A Belvedere Lagoon Property Owners Association (BLPOA) board member, speaking for himself, asked whether stakes could anchor a water bladder. Staff said the supplier did not recommend it.

Homeowners Told to Plan for Themselves

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Burke moved to approve the resolution "with the conditions we expressed," and Carapiet seconded. The motion passed on a voice vote, and no tally was announced. Mark voiced skepticism during the debate, but his vote was not stated. The conditions are:

  • Staff will pick the best barrier solution.
  • Mayor Sally Wilkinson and Burke will serve as council liaisons.
  • Staff must check references. Burke said the city should "need to get three references that are positive."
  • Staff must produce a staffing plan.
  • The determination under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) moves from a "whereas" clause to a "resolve" clause, at Mark's request. That makes it a formal part of the council's action rather than background text.

The dollar amount was not stated publicly.

The council left residents with a clear warning. "It is the obligation of the homeowner to do the best that they can to protect their property," Wilkinson said. Councilmember Jane Cooper added that "the city can only do so much."

The effects fall unevenly:

  • Drivers and emergency responders gain protected access routes.
  • San Rafael Avenue walkers lose the path for most of the winter.
  • Homeowners on Beach Road and San Rafael Avenue must still protect their own property.
  • Some residents fear the barriers will hurt insurance costs and resale values.

What's next: Staff will contact references and finalize a barrier choice with the two liaisons before the first predicted peak tide, the day before Thanksgiving.


Emergency Powers, No Price Tag Yet

Why it matters: Elevated water levels and high astronomical tides threaten low-lying roads, including critical routes in and out of Belvedere. The declaration lets the city move resources and equipment before roads flood, when its options would narrow.

Where things stand: The proclamation, effective Nov. 9, sets an emergency framework under state law and the municipal code. It delegates emergency contracting authority, subject to findings, reporting and ongoing council review. It commits no spending and does not guarantee reimbursement. Mark asked how long it lasts. Zadnik said it stays in place until the council rescinds it, with periodic review.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Carapiet moved approval, and the seconder was not audible. The motion passed, and no tally was announced. No one spoke during public comment.


Police Study Launches Amid Merger Jitters

Why it matters: Belvedere's police department has six sworn personnel, so a single vacancy affects coverage. The study will shape whether the city ever considers broader options. It arrives amid public concern over a headline about a possible Tiburon merger.

Where things stand: A working group selected the consulting firm MRG. The group included Police Chief Wu, Mark, Cooper and Zadnik. Phase 1 will examine:

  • Staffing, supervision and deployment
  • Workload and vacancy coverage
  • City finances over the next 5 and 10 years

The firm will also conduct interviews and hold four community focus groups, with results presented in spring 2027. "Importantly, Phase 1 does not evaluate alternative service models," Zadnik said.

The contract runs just over $87,000, plus a $10,000 contingency. Only $30,000 is budgeted, so staff expects to bring a $67,985 budget amendment in December.

Mark called the study "a necessary and valuable documentation of where we are." Cooper said "we're not going into this with any preconceived ideas of any outcome," and Carapiet also stressed that no merger is planned.

The other side: Dr. Rothman questioned whether the consultant's comparisons fit a town of about 2,000 people. He warned that floating alternatives discourages police recruitment. "So my position is get it firmed up as soon as possible that Belvedere wants its own police force," he said.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Carapiet moved approval, and Cooper seconded. The motion passed on a voice vote, and no tally was announced. Officers and recruits gain a baseline review. Residents get a say through the focus groups, though any study of alternative service models would require a separate, later phase.

What's next: The $67,985 budget amendment comes back in December, and MRG presents its findings in spring 2027.


Minor Items

  • Mallard Point bulkhead: At a special meeting earlier that day, the council unanimously denied an appeal of the bulkhead building permit. Details will appear in the Belvedere Breeze.
  • The Ranch annual report: Recreation Director Jessica Hotchkiss reported the following:
  • 1,552 children attended summer camps.
  • The agency employed 40 seasonal workers.
  • 17 households received fee assistance.
  • The Ranch has been the sole Early Learning Opportunity Program provider for Reed Union School District since 2025.
  • "The ranch has continued to generate profits, leading to healthy reserves," she said.
  • Consent calendar (4A–4E): Passed on a voice vote. Zadnik said item 4E, a planning department electric vehicle, will likely be a truck shared with police and public works.
  • Council chat: Mark and Cooper will host a council chat Nov. 17.

Looking ahead: Watch for barrier reference checks before the Thanksgiving-eve tide, the police budget amendment in December and MRG's findings in spring 2027.