

Nine-Townhouse Plan Carried to Dec. 3 Amid Easement, Parking Disputes
Zoning Board of Adjustment • BellevilleNovember 12, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
A nine-unit townhouse proposal tucked behind a condominium complex and next to School 7 drew more than two hours of testimony and pushback at the Belleville Zoning Board of Adjustment on Nov. 12, 2026. The applicant asked for more time, and the board carried the case to Dec. 3 at 6 p.m. The board also moved to certify a Roosevelt Avenue carriage house over at least one dissent, and its attorney settled a lingering dispute over whether unpaid property taxes can keep an applicant from being heard.
- 9-townhouse flag lot plan carried to Dec. 3 after easement, parking and drainage challenges
- Project seeks 71.7% lot coverage where 60% is allowed, plus a use variance
- Condo association's counsel cites a court-ordered 70/30 easement maintenance split
- Roosevelt Avenue carriage house certification passes on a split roll call
- Board attorney: unpaid taxes can't block a hearing, only condition an approval
Franklin Avenue LLC's Flag Lot Gamble
The basics: 36 Franklin Avenue LLC wants to build nine townhouses at 504 Geraldine Street (Block 4801, Lot 46), a flag lot in the RC zone. A flag lot is a parcel reached by a narrow strip of land. The plan needs a D variance, or use variance, because it puts multiple structures and more than three units on the lot. It also needs variances for lot coverage and lot width.
Why it matters: This was the night's dominant item, consuming most of the meeting. The site shares an easement with a neighboring condominium association and sits beside School 7. That combination leaves traffic, maintenance costs and safety concerns for the board to weigh before it votes.
Where things stand: Diana McGovern, attorney for the applicant with Gascione and DiMacco, presented the case. Engineer J. Michael Petrie, the applicant's expert witness, testified that the site would cover 71.7% of the lot against a 60% limit. He described porous pavers, utility connections and landscaping. He said the applicant accepts the board engineer's conditions.
Parking became a sticking point. The plan counts 21 spaces, including tandem garages, where one car parks behind another. Board members questioned the math. The Town Manager noted that tandem spaces count only for one- to three-family structures, a limit that could undercut the applicant's count for a nine-unit project.
The other side: William Rodriguez, attorney for the condominium association with Griffin Alexander, pressed on who pays to maintain the shared driveway easement. He also raised traffic, lighting and a retaining wall he said encroaches.
"That easement is court-ordered to be repairs and maintenance to be 70% with the association and 30% with Mr. Kopar," said Rodriguez.
The association has not hired its own expert, which leaves Rodriguez relying on cross-examination rather than competing testimony.
Public commenter Michael Sheldon went further, challenging the applicant's figures on lot area, buildable area, impervious coverage, stormwater management, fire hydrants and parking calculations.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken. The applicant requested the continuance to get board feedback on the architecture and to make sure seven eligible voters will be seated for the decision. Under this request, every member who votes will need to be eligible to participate. For the condo owners, the stakes are a shared driveway they already pay most of the cost to maintain. For the developer, the parking ruling and the coverage overage could force a redesign or conditions. School 7 families have an interest in how added traffic is handled.
What's next: The hearing resumes Dec. 3 at 6 p.m. with no further notice. Cross-examination of Petrie and board feedback on the architecture remain pending. Residents who want to weigh in should plan to attend that session.
Roosevelt Avenue Carriage House Wins Certification
The basics: Owner Ivan Gonzalez sought certification that his 20 Roosevelt Avenue property is a lawful pre-existing nonconforming use. That means a use that predates current zoning rules and may continue even though it would not be allowed today. The request was handled as a Section 68 certification.
Why it matters: The ruling would confirm an existing garage apartment that lacks a key approval document. It could also guide how the board handles similar carriage-house and garage-apartment cases.
Where things stand: Counsel presented property cards and testimony from Gonzalez. Gonzalez said the separate meters and utility services were already in place when he bought the property in 2006. Records from a 1999–2000 subdivision exist, but the resolution approving it is missing.
The other side: One member urged the board to adjourn and gather more records on lots 8–20 Roosevelt before deciding. Others favored voting that night. The board's attorney advised that a simple majority would suffice.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The motion certified the property as a two-family house plus carriage house, not as a three-family home. The board will memorialize the decision in a Section 68 resolution. The motion passed on a roll call with at least one no vote. The full tally and the names of the mover and seconder could not be confirmed and should be checked against the official minutes.
The distinction matters to the owner: a two-family-plus-carriage-house designation legalizes the existing apartment without a broader three-family designation.
What's next: The board will adopt a written resolution memorializing the certification at a future meeting.
Counsel Settles the Unpaid-Taxes Fight
Why it matters: The clarification affects every applicant who comes before the board. It also ends a dispute that had caused friction among members at the prior meeting.
Where things stand: The board's attorney said he found no legal authority that would let the board refuse to hear an application because the applicant owes property taxes. Payment can, however, be required as a condition of any approval.
"Taxes can be a condition of approval, not you have to pay it before we hear you," said the board's attorney.
A member who had researched the question using AI said he had revised his view. Members also stressed the need for decorum after the earlier clash.
What's next: The board agreed to flag the tax requirement on the application form in its annual report. The board may also urge the Town Council to revise the ordinance. Any change to the rule would require council action.
Minor Items
- Resolutions memorialized: The board memorialized resolutions for ZB-2026-04, 33–35 Jefferson Street, and ZB-2026-37, 10–12 Hill Street. All audible votes were yes.
- Minutes: The board moved to approve prior meeting minutes. The outcome was not clearly announced.
Looking Ahead
The Franklin Avenue townhouse hearing resumes Dec. 3 at 6 p.m. with no new notice. Vote tallies from Nov. 12, including the Roosevelt Avenue roll call, should be confirmed in the board's official minutes.