Locunity — where decisions happen.
Council Delays Promontory Newell Drive Changes Until New Member Arrives

Council Delays Promontory Newell Drive Changes Until New Member Arrives

City Council • American CanyonNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

American Canyon's City Council on Nov. 17, 2026, declined to let a developer drop its obligation to build part of Newell Drive. Instead, members voted 5-0 to continue the Promontory hearing with no date set, so a new councilmember can weigh in and developers can try to work out the disputed road costs with staff. The same night, the council signaled support for a new east-west Highway 29 crossing plan and said goodbye to Vice Mayor Mark Joseph after 28 years in city service.


  • Promontory road changes continued 5-0. The Newell Drive Segment 1 obligation stays in place for now.
  • Alternative 3B wins informal backing. It moves the planned railroad crossing to South Napa Junction. No vote was taken.
  • Vice Mayor Mark Joseph honored for roles as finance director, city manager and councilmember.
  • $704,395 trail contract awarded 5-0. The low bid came in well under the $1.3M budget.

Newell Drive Fight Heads to a New Council

The basics: The 216-home Promontory subdivision, which includes 54 junior accessory dwelling units, sits within the Watson Ranch Specific Plan. It was approved in 2023, and its final map was approved in December 2025. The developer filed a formal protest on March 6, 2026, arguing that the infrastructure the city required violated state law. In June, the council entered a settlement under which the city would consider a modified project.

Where things stand: The modification would:
- Remove the developer's duty to build Newell Drive Segment 1 and replace it with temporary emergency vehicle access.
- Narrow Segment 2 and add a 12-foot shared path.
- Move water lines into the project.
- Drop two roundabouts and add a mini roundabout.

The Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval on Oct. 22.

"The agreement did not obligate the city to approve the modified project, nor could it under CEQA. It obligated the city to consider it," said City Attorney Summers. City Manager Jason Holley described the settlement as "kind of a balancing act to try to avoid being in more disputes."

Steve Riley, representing developer 330 Land Company, said the original offsite infrastructure burden was about $15M. The company is seeking reimbursement or fee credits for costs above its fair share. "What we opposed was not being reimbursed for the part that we were building that was above and beyond our fair share," Riley said. He also argued that "the level of service of that intersection remains an A even without Newell Drive Segment 1 for the foreseeable future."

The other side: Opposition centered on four concerns: precedent, transparency, cost and traffic.
- Sam Clarisi, a public commenter, urged the council to view Newell citywide rather than through one subdivision, and warned the change could set a precedent for infrastructure obligations.
- Robert Cole, a public commenter, asked why the city would give ground if it believed it was right, and why the public lacks information on the settlement.
- Chris Chiego, a public commenter, requested the June settlement agreement, a fiscal accounting and the traffic study behind the Mallin Way/Rio Del Mar stop.
- Hugh Marquez, a public commenter, called Newell a key way out of town.

Written letters added more pressure:
- McGrath Properties/American Canyon One LLC said it does not oppose the project but cited unanswered concerns.
- Matthew Francois of Rutan & Tucker, representing the Hess-Laird property owners, raised CEQA, General Plan and Specific Plan objections and recommended convening the developers.
- Nicole Payne urged rejection.

Councilmembers were skeptical. "That stop sign is going to be a hot mess for people coming north and south or through town," said Councilmember David Oro. Vice Mayor Mark Joseph urged "a public process in which we analyze the pros and cons of Newell versus Watson Lane," and asked for compensation or bonding to cover a 120-foot unbuilt gap.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Councilmember Brando Cruz moved to continue the item, and Councilmember Melissa Lamattina seconded. Vote: For: 5 (Washington, Joseph, Oro, Cruz, Lamattina); Against: 0; Absent: 0. "It's never about one developer. It's about what is best for the entire city of American Canyon," said Mayor Pierre Washington.

The 2023 approval and the Segment 1 obligation remain in effect for now. That leaves 330 Land Company's reimbursement claim unresolved. Neighboring landowners, including AC1 and the Hess-Laird owners, now have a formal opening to shape the outcome.

What's next: Staff said the item will be re-noticed. Developers and staff were asked to confer before it returns.


Council Leans Toward Alternative 3B Crossing

Why it matters: Only one new railroad crossing is feasible on this corridor. Where it goes will shape Highway 29 signal spacing and how Watson Ranch residents reach the highway.

Where things stand: Holley framed the choice as Rio Del Mar versus South Napa Junction. Vignesh Swaminathan of Kimley-Horn and Associates compared 16 alternatives against 10 weighted criteria at a planning level, and Alternative 3B scored best. Under 3B, the crossing would be built at South Napa Junction, Eucalyptus Drive would be extended, and Rio Del Mar would become right-in/right-out. Staff pointed to signal spacing and the nearby California Northern Railroad switching yard as the deciding factors.

Public commenters raised several questions:
- Cindy, the incoming councilmember, asked whether studies examined cut-through traffic in neighborhoods.
- Cole asked where the city would get land for the Eucalyptus realignment, how it would be funded, and whether it could be built before the NVTA project.
- Jacqueline Romero, a South Napa Junction property owner, asked for crash studies, raised safety and crime concerns, and asked to be included in outreach.

Chiego praised the "accordion" signal spacing. Responding to the sequencing question, Holley called the idea of building first "this Eucalyptus leg" intriguing because it "doesn't have any other sort of dominoes that fall."

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No vote was taken, and no councilmember objected.
- "I think option 3B makes the most sense," said Joseph.
- "Eucalyptus sounds like a great option for us," said Oro.
- Cruz said, "I do not object to 3B, but definitely would like to have the community involved in this conversation."
- Lamattina said, "I'm excited for some better traffic flow for sure."

What's next: Staff outlined these steps:
- Community engagement in January or early February 2027.
- General Plan and Specific Plan amendments.
- An environmental initial study.
- A California Public Utilities Commission crossing application, which staff said could take about 18 months.


A Farewell for Vice Mayor Mark Joseph

Mayor Washington read the proclamation honoring Joseph's career:
- Finance director starting in 1994.
- City manager from 1997 to 2006.
- Councilmember since 2010.
- Chair of the Napa Valley Transportation Authority.
- Climate action work and volunteering with the Arts Foundation and Kiwanis.

Supervisor Belia Ramos of the Napa County Board of Supervisors recalled taking office alongside Joseph in 2010. Representatives of Congressman Thompson, an Assemblymember and a state senator also spoke. Rick Hess, speaking as a developer, credited Joseph with helping secure the Canyon Plaza agreement despite their disagreements. Leon Garcia called him a mentor.

"I'll still be around, and I'm not finished yet," Joseph said, adding that he would continue as a community activist. He cast his final vote later that night with "Last vote, yes."

In the future-agenda discussion, Joseph left the incoming council a to-do list:
- A debrief on why the Green Island Road project took so long.
- A wetlands regional park funded by Measure B.
- A capital set-aside using Measure P money.
- A refreshed community mission, vision and values process, which Cruz supported.


Green Island Road Trail Comes in Under Budget

Where things stand: Public Works Director Erica Ammons-Millies reported that the city received 13 bids. Martin Brothers Construction was the low bidder at $704,395, against a $1.3M budget and a $1M grant. The contract covers about 4,200 feet of Class 1 trail from Paoli Loop to Commerce Boulevard, a Napa Valley Vine Trail link. Staff are working with Caltrans to maximize the grant.

Public commenter Travis asked why the city takes the lowest bid. "Agencies such as ourselves using tax dollars are generally required to take a low bid," Holley said. He added that the project is covered by the city's project labor agreement with the Napa-Solano Building Trades Council.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The resolution passed 5-0 (For: 5; Against: 0; Absent: 0). It also authorizes the public works director to execute change orders up to the project budget.


Minor Items

  • Vallejo water settlement: In closed session, the council unanimously approved settling its water services contract lawsuit with Vallejo. Terms will be available once finalized.
  • Future agendas: The council voted 5-0 to schedule a Visit Napa Valley presentation and, separately, 5-0 to consider a sister-city proclamation and draft MOU with Cavite, Philippines.
  • Diwali: Mayor Washington proclaimed Nov. 6–10, 2026, as Diwali, the Festival of Lights.
  • East-side development worries: Jeanette Goyetch sought environmental review before pre-zoning the Hess-Laird property. Scott Meyer opposed a rumored complex at 106 Wilson Way.
  • Consent calendar: The council approved four consent items 5-0 without discussion.

Looking Ahead

The Promontory item returns after re-noticing, with a new councilmember seated. Community engagement on Alternative 3B is slated for January or early February 2027.