Locunity — where decisions happen.
Supervisors Adopt Foreign-Policy Neutrality 3-2 Over Wall of Public Opposition

Supervisors Adopt Foreign-Policy Neutrality 3-2 Over Wall of Public Opposition

Board of Supervisors • Alameda CountyNovember 17, 2026

Sources:

Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.

Alameda County supervisors voted Nov. 17 to stop taking formal sides in international conflicts. The 3-2 decision came after roughly 20 public speakers opposed it, many tying it to the county's stalled ethical investment policy. The same meeting brought a 4-1 renewal of the sheriff's military equipment authority, including contested multiple-projectile rounds, and a unanimous crackdown on illegal dumping.


  • Neutrality policy passes 3-2, with an exception for county operations; Marquez and Bas opposed
  • Sheriff's military equipment report approved 4-1 after a bid to restrict round 6064 collapsed
  • Illegal dumping ordinance passes 5-0, with fines of $2,500 to $10,000
  • SEIU 1021 contract advances as workers press for faster retroactive pay

Board Steps Back From Global Disputes

The basics: Item 32, brought by Board Vice President Lena Tam and Supervisor Nate Miley, sets a policy of institutional neutrality. The board will not adopt resolutions taking one side in international conflicts, foreign policy matters or geopolitical disputes. Individual supervisors and the public remain free to speak.

Why it matters: The board has acted on global issues before. It divested from South Africa in 1985 and Burma in 1996, and it adopted an ethical investment policy (EIP) that is now under peer review with implementation suspended. Opponents saw the new policy as a way to bury that EIP.

Where things stand: Supporters framed the policy as a matter of focus. "Institutional neutrality does not mean indifference, silence, or a lack of compassion," said Board Vice President Lena Tam.

Supervisor Nate Miley, District 4, cited the county's $6 billion budget and 10,000 employees and urged colleagues to "stay in your lane, do your job, and do it well."

Board President David Haubert supplied the third vote. "Every minute we spend on foreign affairs dilutes our efforts for our most vulnerable people," said Haubert.

The other side: Nearly every public speaker opposed the item, in what amounted to an organized coalition. Martin Putnam, speaking for 12,000 Indivisible East Bay members, recalled the South Africa and Burma divestments. Ranjit Tate, speaking for Jewish Voice for Peace, Hindus for Human Rights and others, argued that neutrality favors the powerful. Lotta Kiswani, Executive Director of the Arab Resource and Organizing Center, called the policy tone deaf and said it shuts the door on petitioning. Lisa Adhikari pointed to the board's past action on Ukraine as evidence of a double standard.

Two supervisors agreed the board should stay focused but objected to giving up flexibility. "I don't want to preemptively give away our ability to bring issues forward," said Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas, District 5. "It was premature to bring this item forward without settling the EIP implementation that was voted on October of last year," said Supervisor Elisa Marquez, District 2.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: County Counsel noted the policy is not absolute. "It does say that it would not preclude you from taking up matters of foreign issues and disputes that directly concern the county governance or operations," said County Counsel. Tam moved adoption with that exception. The motion passed (For: 3, Tam, Miley, Haubert; Against: 2, Marquez, Bas).

Supervisors seeking a tighter agenda gain a procedural shield. Advocacy groups that have used board resolutions and the EIP as leverage now face a higher bar. They will need to frame requests around county governance or operations.

What's next: County Counsel said the board's pending revision of its operating procedures could refine how exceptions are handled. The EIP remains under peer review.


Sheriff Keeps Contested Multiple-Projectile Rounds

Why it matters: State law AB 481 requires the board to review the sheriff's military equipment every year. This year's vote keeps multiple-projectile round 6064 authorized despite sustained objections from physicians and activists.

Where things stand: Lieutenant Gustavo Mora of the Sheriff's Office reported 1,201 equipment uses, 1,032 of them by drones, with no complaints and 6,825 training hours. The office is retiring the FN303 system and Stinger canisters. It requested 50 replacement rifles and 500 PepperBall VXR Shatter glass-breaking rounds.

Approved drone authorizations drop from 258 to 97, then rise by 122 new authorizations, for a net of 219. "This is a cleanup of our existing drone inventory," said Mora.

The other side: About a dozen speakers urged the board to ban or restrict rounds 6064 and 6098. Dr. Loni Castro, a physician and Indivisible East Bay member, called scattershot munitions inaccurate and harmful, especially to the eyes. Juan Pablo Fonseca, Director of the International Research Center on Ocular Violence and a victim of a less-lethal munition, asked the board to suspend acquisitions and order an independent technical evaluation. Natasha Baker of the Care First, Jails Last Coalition urged rejection unless the munitions are banned for use on people.

Commander McGill defended the rounds as de-escalation options and breaching tools. "I understand the physicians say it's harmful, but so is a bullet," said Sheriff Yesenia Sanchez.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Bas offered a substitute motion. "I'd really prefer to approve this, either removing the 6064 from the report or not allowing its use on persons," said Bas. Marquez seconded, then withdrew her second, and the substitute died.

Miley and Tam said they trusted the sheriff's expertise. Haubert questioned repeating a review the Public Protection Committee had already conducted. The original motion, moved by Miley and seconded by Tam, passed (For: 4, Marquez, Tam, Miley, Haubert; Against: 1, Bas).

The Sheriff's Office keeps its full toolkit and a smaller drone authorization. Protest advocates and medical voices leave without the restrictions they sought.

What's next: The board must revisit alternatives in next year's annual report.


Dumping Ordinance Widens Liability, Raises Fines

Why it matters: Public Works spent $3.8M on about 1,483 dumping work orders in 2024, roughly $2,500 per dump, with no prosecutions.

Where things stand: Aaron Armstrong, Deputy Chief of Staff for District 4, presented Chapter 6.121, a model ordinance developed by a statewide task force. Existing state law reaches only the person who physically dumps, requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt and caps first fines at $250 to $1,000.

The new ordinance makes three parties liable:
- The waste owner, unless a licensed hauler was used
- The vehicle owner, unless the vehicle was used without consent
- The dumper

Fines rise to $2,500, $5,000 and $10,000. The ordinance also creates an administrative hearing process, with community service available for hardship cases. Oakland has already adopted the model.

The other side: No one opposed the ordinance. Chuck Meadows described seven years of dumping on his property and more than $1M in legal fees without abatement. Kelly Abreu supported the measure but asked for explicit entry procedures, including consent, administrative warrants and emergency entry.

Decisions and stakeholder impacts: The ordinance passed 5-0 on a motion by Miley, seconded by Tam. Residents of unincorporated areas gain the county's first administrative enforcement tool against dumping. Businesses that hand waste to unlicensed haulers now carry legal risk. Tam noted franchise complexities and a possible review in two to three years.


Union Contract Advances as Workers Push for Pay

Where things stand: SEIU Local 1021 reached a tentative agreement Sept. 18 and ratified it Oct. 15. Members thanked the board for moving up the hearing but pressed for retroactive pay sooner than the reported Jan. 29, 2027, date.

Kathy Reeves, an SEIU 1021 shop steward in the Public Defender's office, urged speedy ratification for 4,500 families and raised concerns about low retention. Peter Mazziak, SEIU 1021 East Bay Field Director, said some payments may arrive before Christmas.

Human Resource Services Director Margarita Zamora said the process "takes about 10 weeks from the point we reach TA to the first reading of the ordinance by your board." She acknowledged a lesson about disclosing timelines at the bargaining table.

What's next: Tam moved to introduce the MOU and salary ordinances, and Miley seconded. The outcome of the roll call was not announced.


Minor Items

  • ABC Security, $4.76M: The guard contract extension drew 3 yes votes, with Tam abstaining and Miley recused over $2,000 in contributions. No result was announced; GSA Director Kimberly Gasaway said AB 520 requirements delayed a new procurement.
  • Closed session: County Counsel reported a $200,000 settlement in Chopra et al. v. Dublin Police Department et al., authorized Sept. 15 on a 4-0 vote with one absence.
  • Eviction defense: The board approved an amendment letting Centro Legal de la Raza receive advance settlement funds. David Hall said reimbursement-only payment would equal more than a third of the group's operating budget.
  • Concealed carry fees: The board introduced an ordinance raising fees about $42 per classification to recover state DOJ costs. No public comment.
  • Juvenile hall: Urban Peace Movement youth Mateo Ramirez and Graciela Medina asked the board to agendize a ban on chemical agents, including "Repulse" spray. The board did not respond.

Looking Ahead

Marquez called the local ICE enforcement surge a crisis, citing 13 arrests the prior weekend, and asked for an interim rapid-response coordinator. "I would elevate this to a crisis," said Marquez.

Bas requested an investigation into ICE presence at Santa Rita Jail. She announced a Together for All meeting on Dec. 7 and a wildfire town hall on Dec. 1.

With El Niño approaching, Public Works now has explicit authority to close county roads. Sandbag locations are listed on the county website.