

Divided Council Orders Study of Folding Housing Authority Into City
City Council • AlamedaNovember 18, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Alameda's City Council voted 3-2 on Nov. 17, 2026, to explore bringing the independent Housing Authority under city control, a step that could reshape who delivers the city's affordable housing. The split came alongside a unanimous resolution barring civil immigration enforcement on city property, and a preview of a 2027 East Bay MUD pipeline project that will close sidewalks and a park-and-ride on Bay Farm Island.
- Housing Authority governance study approved 3-2 after a fight over Stardust Gardens and $25.5M in Alameda Point funds
- City property barred from civil immigration enforcement, and sanctuary status reaffirmed unanimously
- East Bay MUD to drill under San Leandro Channel in 2027, with up to six weeks of Island Drive sidewalk work
Housing Authority Study Splits Council 3-2
Why it matters: The vote starts a study that could end the Housing Authority's independence. It follows a standoff over Stardust Gardens vouchers and $25.5M in Alameda Point redevelopment money.
The basics: The Housing Authority of the City of Alameda is a separate agency with its own board of commissioners. RHNA, the Regional Housing Needs Allocation, is the state-assigned housing target each city must plan for.
Where things stand: City Manager Gerry Beaudin said the authority was once part of city governance. He argued that integration would improve alignment, transparency and accountability, and he noted that the city's Sunshine Ordinance does not apply to the authority. He cited the numbers: 209 of 1,400 very-low-income units delivered, and about 472 of more than 5,300 RHNA units.
He also named the pressure point. "We have $25.5 million of Alameda Point redevelopment money that's tied up now in Stardust Gardens," said Beaudin. He framed the request as a first step: "we're not asking for a final decision on the topic."
David Hall, Director, Tenants' Rights Team, Centro Legal de la Raza, backed the study. He cited harsher eviction and voucher-termination practices and the Alakozee v. Alameda Housing Authority case. "These organizations should not have had to file a lawsuit to make these reforms," said Hall.
The other side: Carly Grob, a Housing Authority Board Commissioner speaking on her own behalf, cited HUD rules and disputed the staff report. She proposed a working group or joint hearings instead. "We should not spend city staff time and resources studying how we can dismantle a highly functioning independent agency," said Grob.
Councilmember Tony Daysog urged colleagues to "just table this item" and hold a joint meeting with the authority's board under the next council. "I'm going to vote no on the motion that's forthcoming because I believe it's imperative to maintain the independence of the Alameda Housing Authority," said Daysog.
Councilmember Tracy Jensen raised concerns about acting before a new council is seated and called the evidence one-sided. She said the case did not show failures attributable to independent governance. Beaudin said the analysis would draw on a confidential memo council had received rather than settle the underlying disputes.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Vice Mayor Michele Pryor moved the item, and Councilmember Greg Boller seconded. "I don't think we should defer this," said Pryor. Boller said he supports the staff recommendation, citing urgency. Mayor Marilyn Ezzy Ashcraft said "exploring is not deciding, but it's seeing what the possibilities are."
The vote: For: 3 (Pryor, Boller, Ezzy Ashcraft), Against: 2 (Daysog, Jensen), Absent: 0.
Tenant advocates won the review they sought. The authority's commissioners face a possible loss of autonomy, and the Stardust Gardens money remains the flashpoint.
What's next: Staff will explore integration into the city or other governance models. No return date was announced.
Alameda Bars ICE Civil Enforcement on City Property
Why it matters: The resolution puts Alameda's sanctuary stance in writing. Officials acknowledged its reach stops at the many federal properties in the city.
Where things stand: Councilmember Tracy Jensen pulled the item from the consent calendar so it would get a full presentation. Amanda Gerke, Special Projects Manager, City Manager's Office, recounted council direction from April and October. That direction included:
- A prohibition on using city property for civil immigration enforcement
- Mandatory documentation and reporting of requests
- An inventory of city property
- A reaffirmation of sanctuary Resolution 15225
- Possible zoning changes at Alameda Point, planned for 2027
Jensen asked, "how will this be enforced?" Beaudin replied, "we follow state law in the City of Alameda with respect to enforcement of immigration," and noted the extent of federal property in Alameda.
Public commenters backed the measure. David Freitag, a public commenter, urged the city to strengthen its sanctuary status. Ronan Bernsaro, a public commenter, thanked staff and asked for clear enforcement guidelines and protections.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: "It is largely symbolic, but symbolism is important because we do have the enforcement piece," said Mayor Ezzy Ashcraft. Daysog moved the resolution, Pryor seconded, and it passed unanimously on a voice vote. Immigrant residents gain a written commitment covering city-owned sites, though federal land falls outside it.
What's next: The property inventory is still pending, and Alameda Point zoning work is planned for 2027.
Pipeline Drilling Will Close Bay Farm Sidewalks
Why it matters: About a third of Alameda depends on pipelines vulnerable to liquefaction. This seismic-resilience project will disrupt Bay Farm Island through much of 2027.
The basics: Horizontal directional drilling (HDD) bores a pipe path underground rather than digging an open trench.
Where things stand: East Bay MUD Board Director Jim Odey introduced the project. Design Project Manager Sana Garcia and Associate Engineer Frank Jesus presented the details. The plan includes:
- A roughly 2,100-foot HDD crossing west of the Bay Farm Island Bridge
- A 24-inch open-trench connection along Peach and San Jose streets
- Staging at Peach Street and the Bay Farm park-and-ride, which will close from January to July 2027, with an alternate lot at the old CVS site
- 16-foot sound walls, plus dust and vibration monitoring
Pipe fusing on Island Drive will run "Monday through Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., up to 6 weeks," said Jesus.
The other side: Council pressed on sidewalk obstruction, residential vibration, storms, school outreach and truck trips. "Can you help us understand how a 2,200-foot pipeline stored on the sidewalk doesn't present any disruption?" asked Ezzy Ashcraft.
On vibration, an East Bay MUD staff member said "there's not a specific permit agency for vibration monitoring," adding that the city was not involved on that issue.
What's next: No action was taken. The mayor asked city staff to look into oversight of vibration.
- Consent calendars: Council approved the Successor Agency and regular consent calendars by voice votes.
- Greenway: The Greenway lease amendment ordinance (7B) was withdrawn until a later meeting. In closed session on the Greenway Golf litigation, council gave direction 4-0, with Pryor absent.
- Gibbons Drive: In a statement read by the clerk, Julie Lyons said firefighters had to lift her stranded scooter from uplifted pavement. She urged ADA Title II action using the Public Works sidewalk and tree plan.
- Poseidon Aerospace lease: Marilyn Alwan asked council to revisit the lease or adopt an ethical leasing policy matching the city's defense investment policy.
- Board nominations: The mayor announced nominations for boards and commissions; council votes are expected Dec. 1.
Looking ahead: Beaudin warned of rain and king tides around Thanksgiving. The Webster and Posey tubes and Doolittle may close, three sandbag sites are open, and the emergency operations center is partly activated. Residents can find information at alamedaca.gov/ready and sign up for AC Alerts.
Anita Bing of the SBA Office of Disaster Recovery said loans become available once a disaster is declared: 3% for homeowner and renter loans, and up to $2M for businesses.
Fire Chief Nick Looby retires Dec. 30, and Cody Moxley will step in.