

Appeals Board Rejects Portal-Glitch Defense, Upholds Vacation Rental Suspension
Administrative Appeals Board • Palm SpringsOctober 21, 2026
Locunity is an independent informational service and is not an official government page for this commission. All information is sourced from public footage and an analysis of official agendas with the aid of responsible, fact-checked AI. to report an error or omission.
Palm Springs’ Administrative Appeals Board voted 5-0 on Oct. 21, 2026, to uphold a $2,500 fine and six-month suspension for a McManus Drive vacation rental. The board was not persuaded by a property manager’s claim that the city’s online portal swallowed his filing. Across three appeals, members repeated one message: Under the city’s strict-liability rules, sympathy does not change the outcome.
- Portal-glitch claim fails: Board upholds McManus Drive penalties 5-0 after staff find no outage.
- Navajo Drive owner’s travel-hardship defense fails to stop a 5-0 vote to uphold.
- Joyce Drive appeal: Motion to uphold the $2,500 fine and six-month suspension made; no tally announced.
- Board tables 5-0 a committee to explore enforcement discretion after a liability warning.
- City Council acted on only one of the board’s earlier recommendations, staff say.
McManus Drive Glitch Claim Doesn’t Move Board
The basics: Palm Springs requires vacation rental operators to file a contract summary with the city before guests arrive. The board treats a missed filing as a strict-liability violation, meaning intent and excuses don’t count.
Why it matters: This was the night’s longest hearing, roughly 42 minutes. It tested whether the city’s own submission system can be blamed when a filing goes missing. The answer was no, at least without corroborating evidence.
Where things stand: Code Compliance Supervisor Mitch Navghan said officers responded to a July 26, 2026, noise call and found no contract summary for guests who arrived July 25. He said the manager submitted one at 9:32 p.m., after enforcement contact, and listed incorrect dates. Navghan said all four extra third-quarter contracts allowed for the property had already been used. He said other operators successfully submitted that day, and a staff email search found no record of the complaint the manager said he made.
“The facts that I’ve looked into just don’t support that he wouldn’t have been able to submit it,” said Navghan.
The other side: Ryan Newcomb of Palms to Pines Vacation Rentals, who manages the property for owner Lisa Davis, testified under oath. He said he submits contracts in monthly batches and believes he filed this one. He blamed an intermittent portal problem.
“It was a glitch in the system that just wasn’t sending them through,” said Newcomb.
Newcomb cited a staff reply that mentioned a repair ticket. He handed out the document on the day of the hearing. Board members pressed him on why he didn’t audit his confirmations or report the problem sooner. They also noted they had no information about what the ticket covered.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Vice Chair David Parker moved to uphold the $2,500 fine and six-month suspension, seconded by Board Member Edwin Koren. The motion carried by roll call (For: 5 — Board Member Lauren Hein, Board Member Richard Llewellyn, Koren, Parker, Board Chair Patrick Basile; Against: 0).
For professional managers handling multiple properties, the ruling puts the burden of proof on the operator. Batch filing without checking confirmations is now a demonstrated risk. A late-day ticket reference was not enough to shift blame to the city’s system.
Navajo Drive Owner’s Travel Saga Earns Sympathy, Not Relief
Why it matters: Even a credible hardship story did not overcome the filing rule. The case shows owners who travel need backup access to the city portal.
Where things stand: Staff read the issuing officer’s statement. An Aug. 9, 2026, complaint about loud music and excess vehicles led officers to find no contract summary on file before occupancy. Staff said an attempted submission had inaccurate dates and was never confirmed.
The other side: Mariana Badia, owner of Acasa Properties, LLC, said she had not seen the agenda and disputed the attempted submission. She described canceled flights, a passport problem and no in-flight internet while traveling abroad. She said Airbnb accepted a same-day booking despite her settings.
“Fifteen to twenty attempts. To connect to the Wi-Fi. Zero,” said Badia.
She said she has since added a co-host with portal access and is moving away from Airbnb.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Board members said they believed her but that responsibility stays with the owner. Parker moved to uphold the fine and suspension, and the motion carried (For: 5, Against: 0). The ruling signals to owners that a platform auto-accepting a booking, or a missed connection, won’t excuse a missing filing.
Joyce Drive Appeal Ends Without Announced Result
Why it matters: The appellant had 6.5 years of clean operation and filed about 48 hours late. Even so, board members said the ordinance left them no room to act.
Where things stand: Staff said a July 20, 2026, music complaint led officers to find no contract summary had been filed before guests checked in July 18. Staff said the owner filed it only after enforcement contact. They called the late filing and the music complaint two distinct violations. Staff said the portal cannot backdate filings and no system-wide outage was documented.
The other side: Nicole Lamani, attorney and appellant for RL Global Investment Group, LLC, objected to the officer’s unsworn statement as hearsay. She put the property’s gross income at about $4,650 a month. She argued due process was violated because the suspension took effect before the appeal. She also noted the music strike counts against the license, but the owner cannot appeal it.
“I think a 6-month suspension of a license is really — it’s unconscionable,” said Lamani.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: Members commended the operator but said they cannot grant exceptions.
“Our role, really our sole role here is to determine the facts and apply them to the ordinance, to the law,” said Board Member Lauren Hein.
“Our hands are tied in terms of we’re making sure that the city applied the code in the correct way that it’s written,” said Parker.
Basile moved to uphold the $2,500 fine and six-month suspension, and the motion was seconded. Voting was set up, but no result or tally was announced. Basile told the appellant the city would be in touch about the fine.
What’s next: The official outcome should appear in the board’s minutes.
Board Shelves Push for Enforcement Discretion
Why it matters: The three appeals showed a board that feels boxed in, but members declined to pursue changes. The strict-liability system stays as it is.
Where things stand: Members debated forming an ad hoc committee to examine whether the board should get some discretion under the municipal code. Board Member Richard Llewellyn said he was unenthusiastic because the current system works.
“Even though it’s not perfect, I’d probably leave it alone,” said Llewellyn.
Another member suggested that tiered penalties for first offenses would not amount to discretion. A representative of the City Attorney’s Office pushed back hard.
“It’s a slippery slope. And it does open this commission, this board to potential liabilities,” said the City Attorney’s Office representative.
The representative said the code allows the board to make recommendations to the City Council. They added that the City Attorney’s Office would give the council the same advice.
“Our position is to listen to both sides,” said Basile.
Decisions and stakeholder impacts: No member volunteered to serve as a liaison. A motion to table, seconded by Basile, passed by roll call (For: 5, Against: 0). The clerk’s office was directed to bring the item back if requested.
Council follow-through: During board comments, Navghan said the council acted on only one of the board’s earlier recommendations. It kept existing permittees at 32 contracts plus four, rather than cutting them to 26, and tabled the rest. Staff are exploring an educational component.
Llewellyn asked for more explanation of strict liability in appeal packets, “so people understand other than just watch old hearings.” The City Attorney’s Office representative recommended against it, saying it could create ambiguity.
Navghan said staff spend 30 to 45 minutes with callers. He said the city has a little over 2,600 registered vacation rentals and fewer than about 20 appeal cases this year. The appeal fee is $1,324. That cost matters for owners deciding whether to challenge a penalty the board has repeatedly said it cannot waive.
Minor Items
- Board accepted the agenda 5-0.
- Approval of the Sept. 16, 2026, minutes was raised and seconded; the outcome wasn’t recorded.
- City Attorney’s Office reported no updates.
Looking Ahead
The board next meets Nov. 18 at 2 p.m. in the large conference room.